Chief Judge Alex Kozinski Accused of Posting Sexually Explicit Material on Website

Alex Kozinski, chief judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, is in a controversy over his publicly accessible website, which featured sexually explicit photos and videos. He insists that some of these photos were posted privately as a joke. Kozinski is a long-time friend, who has appeared in my classes in past years. While I never visited the website in question or received such material, I can attest to the fact that Kozinski has a peculiar sense of humor. He is a brilliant jurist and a leading libertarian voice on the Court. Nevertheless, the disclosure is complicating Kozinski’s sitting in a leading pornography case involving Ira Isaacs.

The objectionable material include a photo of naked women on all fours painted to look like cows and a video of a half-dressed man cavorting with a sexually aroused farm animal. Another is a graphic step-by-step pictorial in which a woman is seen shaving her pubic hair. Yet, other pictures reportedly involve a striptease featuring a transsexual and a series of photos of women’s crotches as seen through snug fitting clothing or underwear.

Kozinski, 57, said that he did not realize that the material could be accessed by the public. The disclosure has led to calls for him to recuse himself from the case of Ira Isaacs, click here.

The recusal question is an interesting one. It is not clear that any of this material was intended for purposes of arousal. Yet, even if it were, it raises the question of whether interest in such pictures requires recusal. There are many justices who have private lives that include extremely religious activities or conservative cultural values. However, recusal would not be demanded for such private views. Judges are expected to transcend their personal values in reaching legal conclusions and most are capable of doing that. In that sense, it is an issue that could be analogous to the controversy over Judge Robert Somma, click here.

Stephen Gillers, a New York University law professor who specializes in legal ethics, says that he must recuse himself because “the public can reasonably question his objectivity” concerning the issues at hand. Yet, does that mean that anyone who has watched or downloaded pornography is not objective? Doesn’t that create a bias in the other direction? It would suggest that private viewing of pornography is somehow discrediting — a position that would likely limit judges to a more conservative group.

I have not seen the pictures or video but it does appear that recusal is necessary in this case. There are reportedly pictures of themes of defecation and urination, which fall into the scope of the trial. While I believe Kozinski that the posting on a public site was an accident, such pictures would likely come to close to some of the evidence in the case. Moreover, given the public controversy, it may be difficult to separate the case from the controversy.

Such a recusal would be a blow for Isaacs, since Kozinski’s libertarian views would make him ideal for the case from the perspective of the defense.

One of the issue getting a lot of discussion is the fact that Kozinski sought to have filters removed that had been put on computers to deny access to pornography and other materials.

I believe that Kozinski has done the right thing in coming out and speaking frankly about this problem. It would be a shame to allow this controversy to darken an otherwise stellar judicial career. However, this controversy appears to be growing (another good reason to recuse oneself).

For the full story, click here.

70 thoughts on “Chief Judge Alex Kozinski Accused of Posting Sexually Explicit Material on Website

  1. Prima di tutto, ogni di un individuo deve essere il interessante componente di di un individuo burberry borse note. Ogni ultimo deve essere e inoltre costruito per diventare un fatturato lordo Programma. Contattaci a persona lettori sentimenti tramite amore al forza condizionati per la vendita di gran lunga pi霉 libri di addestramento. La verit脿 猫 In realt脿, te dopo modello a libretto incorporare a fuoco elementi qui , di gran lunga pi霉 guide piuttosto che persone possibilmente sognato.

    online shop:

  2. ???`?? ?r??
    ???`?? ????????????

    Mr. Obama in addition to your partner’s fans have outspent Mr. Romney in addition to his or her backers close to 2-to-1 in promoting concerning Spanish-language television set programs within a couple of of the extremely very closely fought for states – Co, Georgia together with Nevada – such as a different advertising wherein Mr. Obama may make a private enchantment designed for program, discussing completely through Spanish. Mr. Romney’s advisors have counted with a lift associated with postings all over the video spectrum, stating that a number of Hispanics talk British and also obtain the economy, not necessarily immigration, the highest subject.
    Nonetheless in case his or her’s practices differ, each ads currently have identified in which changing through Latinos during many a few expresses is certainly doubtless essential. Mr. Obama is trying to roll away a powerful outsize margin concerning Hispanics that could fringe your ex to triumph in many state governments, though Mr. Romney is certainly planning to handle straight down the particular president’s details.
    “Obama grasps ones problems, ” Camila Peterson, 65, says through The spanish language. This lady talked by way of a door towards category of Asian immigrants during Longmont, Colo. “He is actually considered one of u . s .. ”
    Pauline Olvera, 46, any third-generation Us doing business for a Romney campaign place of work outdoors Denver, claimed the girl has been calling lower back voters what individuals the lady sensed expected “just another kick. ”
    “Romney, ” Microsof company. Olvera explained. “I want the property to show me they’re voting just for Romney. ”
    The effort is that it is performed out since the email campaigns proceed with process Hispanic enthusiasts into the in the past more challenging activity of buying the criminals to election. A FABULOUS poll conducted Sept. 7 for you to March. 4 via the Pew Hispanic Core identified the fact that 77 proportion in Latino signed up voters reported these were a number of they will vote, contrary to 89 percentage over everything.
    Mr. Obama’s marketing campaign director, Sam Messina, says which will despite the fact that Latino voters have been central inside a lot more reports – for example Iowa, North carolina not to mention Virginia – nowhere had been these further critical as compared to inside Co, The state of nevada in addition to The southeast.
    The actual voting people regarding Latinos has been on a constant surge around Co along with The state of nevada. With California, it includes moved as a result of Cuban, some sort of a great deal Republican bloc, that include more Puerto Ricans, friends which includes turned out to be additional Democratic inside say. The actual change provides offered Democrats using a fresh combine for probable practitioners.
    “If you’re checking out the to build brand new votes, that’s the site, ” Mr. Messina believed.
    Gov. Susana Martinez in Brand-new Mexico, some sort of Republican who might be campaigning designed for Mr. Romney, proclaimed these in which while Republicans experience a fabulous battle sawing in Mr. Obama’s contribute with the help of Latinos, Mr. Romney has been reeling in upward. “The similar points are essential to make sure you Latinos concerning the rest of the People in the usa, ” your woman says, putting in, “President Obama has designed a large amount of vacant boasts. Individuals forecast their unsupported claims. ”
    Even now, all the concerns that Mr. Romney fronts are plain in any Sin city storing lot final Sat wherever Milliseconds. Martinez possessed just simply discussed to your move connected with Romney volunteers. Typically the cluster was first just about wholly vivid white.
    For Denver colorado, Luis THE. Colón, exactly who goes one small intercontinental industry firm, continues to be get together other Latino small-business homeowners sensitive that will Mr. Romney’s get in touch with that will trim federal government rules and even taxation’s. “The obama’s stimulus income lead to lots of waste materials, and lots of that work this established ended up build employment, ” Mr. Colón claimed. “So if your manufacturing was initially completed, this employment had been carried out. We start to use betterment that’s well over just simply non permanent. ”
    All these keep going many days would be the culmination to a methodology ages on the making designed for Mr. Obama. The idea right now wants to be able to reap the benefits of an important backlash amongst various Latino voters next to really difficult immigration activities shared just by Mr. Romney for the period of his / her party’s presidential primaries.

  3. Reed, 34, has considered retirement after each of the last couple of seasons, and with his contract due to expire at season’s end, it may be a natural stopping point for the ball-hawking safety.

    But after Sunday’s win over the Indianapolis Colts, Reed insisted that his sole focus was on next week’s game at Denver, not his future.

  4. Justin Smith hasn’t played in nearly a month, but the San Francisco 49ers believe their anchoring defensive lineman will be ready for Saturday night’s divisional playoff game against the Green Bay Packers.
    “God willing and the creek don’t rise, he’s going to play,” 49ers coach Jim Harbaugh said Wednesday, via Steve Corkran of the Contra Costa Times.

  5. Cool blog! Is your theme custom made or did you download it
    from somewhere? A design like yours with a few simple tweeks would really make my blog jump
    out. Please let me know where you got your design.

  6. And then, you’ll probably see that the battery’s charge won’t be as durable as before. If you don’t want to use Safari to navigate to pages, zoom in, and read articles, Byline may be just the app for you.

    Although, sound card is integrated device, it functions similar to brightness
    of the screen when talking about power consumption.

Comments are closed.