Brown Family Challenges Utah’s Polygamy Law

Today, we filed the complaint below in the challenge to Utah’s criminal polygamy law. I am still in Salt Lake City for the filing. With me today is our local counsel Adam Alba, an outstanding young attorney and one of my former students. As noted earlier, the lawsuit is on behalf of my clients, the Brown family. The Browns are featured in the TLC program Sister Wives as an openly polygamous family.

The Plaintiffs are Kody Brown, Christine Brown, Janelle Brown, Meri Brown, and Robyn Sullivan.

The Defendants are Governor Gary Herbert, Attorney General Mark Shurtleff, and County Attorney Jeffrey R. Buhman.

There are seven claims for relief:

Claim One: Due Process

Claim Two: Equal Protection

Claim Three: Free Exercise

Claim Four: Free Speech

Claim Five: Freedom of Association

Claim Six: Establishment of Religion

Claim Seven: 42 U.S.C. § 1983

As in past cases, I will have to be circumspect in what I say after the filing of this action. However, we are honored to represent the Brown family in this historic challenge,” said Professor Turley. “We believe that this case represents the strongest factual and legal basis for a challenge to the criminalization of polygamy ever filed in the federal courts. We are not demanding the recognition of polygamous marriage. We are only challenging the right of the state to prosecute people for their private relations and demanding equal treatment with other citizens in living their lives according to their own beliefs. This action seeks to protect one of the defining principles of this country, what Justice Louis Brandeis called ‘the right to be left alone.’ In that sense, it is a challenge designed to benefit not just polygamists but all citizens who wish to live their lives according to their own values – even if those values run counter to those of the majority in the state.

The following is the statement from Kody Brown, which will be the only statement at this time on the filing:

Statement of Kody Brown:

“There are tens of thousands of plural families in Utah and other states. We are one of those families. We only wish to live our private lives according to our beliefs. While we understand that this may be a long struggle in court, it has already been a long struggle for my family and other plural families to end the stereotypes and unfair treatment given consensual polygamy. We are indebted to Professor Turley and his team for their work and dedication. Together we hope to secure equal treatment with other families in the United States.”

Here is the complaint filed today: Brown Complaint

Jonathan Turley

190 thoughts on “Brown Family Challenges Utah’s Polygamy Law”

  1. I should take the example of a misogynistic religious zealot and self-described “prophet” as the normal polyamorous experience? Then I should also look at the millions of women who will be beaten by their husbands as an indictment of heteronormative monogamy. This case is awful and scary and that is why it is in the news. The thousands of healthy polyamorous families who are quietly and happily living out their lives are not the beaten and frightened women that the media keeps showing.

    That situation is the result of the destructive and oppressive theology practiced by those specific individuals.

  2. I suggest you review the well documented facts in Elaine’s post above.

    In the lottery of life, maximizing the number of winners is a good and just thing. Polygamy assures, if widely practiced, that many men will never marry and never reproduce. This is a self evidently cruelty. Elaine’s report gives you a taste of just how cruel the mechanism of driving young men away really is, but the deeper cruelty is to freeze those men out of marriage and reproduction.

    Economic modeling? No, basic principles of political equality.

    Fortunately for the homosexuality argument there are lots of gay women too. The numbers don’t have to add up perfectly, but they have to point in the right direction.

    Monogamy assures that women are not products or objects, and that teenage boys are not driven off as useless threats to social order.

    Finally, as noted above, in the end both men and women who care about equality have an interest in monogamy. All the men who are threatened with never marrying or reproducing are the first injured party, but every father or mother who loves those men shares that interest.

    Beyond that, we all have an interest in a society that does not have a free floating class of bachelors who are frozen out of marriage, if not out our sympathy for their plight, then out of simple self interest for the order and safety of our society.

  3. Miles,

    “Monogamy is a pact of equality among men.”

    Really? The ladies have no say or equality in the matter then? I suppose that might be true if one wants to take the strictly sexist view of the Declaration but last time I checked a relationship, long term or otherwise, requires the equal consent of the female in this country. We don’t sell women into this country like they do in Saudi Arabia and parts of India. Women do have a say in the matter. Also, just because something is rare doesn’t mean it is not going to happen. Polygamy is defined as marriage between more than two partners. Just because polyandry was historically a Tibetan practice does not mean that once legal barriers to polygamy are removed that it won’t be practiced here any more than just because polygyny is historically an African and Asian practice that it won’t be practiced here either.

    The matter here is indeed equality. It is equality of choice for both males and females to enter into polygamous relationships which, by the way, includes the right to exit from polygamous relationships and enter into monogamous relationships should they so desire. No one is suggesting forced polygyny or any other form of polygamy, but rather giving an equal choice to enter into those relationships by consenting adults of either gender.

    So what’s it going to be? Are you going to allow others to have freedom of choice (including the freedom to practice their religious beliefs) or are you going to limit their choices because you think (in a rather sexist manner I might add) that “[m]onogamy is a pact of equality among men”? Because if you opt on your current course of logic, you are denying equality to men (as well as women) who disagree with you about monogamy being a pact of equality between men. If you don’t like polygamy, don’t practice it. That’s what I plan to do. However, just because I don’t like it doesn’t mean I think others should be denied the choices on how to manage their relationships (absent the obvious criminal behaviors of pedophilia and slavery).

  4. Miles,
    >”societies that widely adopt polygamous marriage end up with an underclass of men who can never marry.”

    Source? And please disregard data from countries where the family (i.e. the father) chooses the spouse rather than the child and/or where a dowry is paid when the daughter is sold.

    >”But the fact remains that polygamous marriage as an institution is in-egalitarian. It produces male winners and male losers. This is the opposite of gay marriage which produces more male and female winners in a society.”

    Not only is this a false dichotomy but “winning” in this case is a value judgment and presupposes that anyone other than Charlie Sheen wants to “win” constantly.

    >”What I am sure of is that simple math assures that the advantage of some men, inevitably and mathematically is the disadvantage of others, in polygamy.”

    You mean just like every other human endeavor? I almost get the feeling that you’re trying to apply economic modeling to this issue.

    >“But the forgotten and forever unable to marry men who it freezes out of family, are the forgotten victims, and good reason to consign it, along with slavery, to the dustbin of history.”

    You know that is one of the older, discredited arguments against homosexuality? That every homosexual man living the “bachelor lifestyle” somehow condemns a woman to poverty and spinsterhood?

    Women are not products, this is not an issue of ‘supply and demand”. You are in every case expressing the relationship as a function of Man controlling Woman. That relationship will be unhealthy and unwholesome regardless of the number of people involved.

  5. Yes, thanks Elaine.

    …and even though I called monogamy a mythological “pact among men”, really every mother of sons surely has an interest in each of her sons’ future happiness as a groom with a bride. Women should be part of that pact too.

    If her only interest is grandchildren, then one married son with two wives and one who can’t fine a wife, is just as good as two with one wife each… but surely women have an interest in the equal happiness of all their sons, and not just the number of grandchildren they end up with.

    Monogamy is about equality. Polygamy provides choices, but human history suggests that the choices people make tend to lead us away from basic equality. Can democracy survive polygamy?

    The male victims of polygamy are invisible, driven away, and not in the courtroom where the happy family appeals for its right to be a family like any other.

  6. Bob,

    “Other than William Holden in “Stalag 17,” who says ‘give that man a kewpie doll?’”

    Apparently at least one other person does. 🙂

  7. Monogamy is a pact of equality among men. The more freely men can acquire multiple wives (simultaneously or serially), the more a society will tend toward an unequal distribution of women. Abandon monogamy and powerful men will acquire women. Indeed, the very idea that women are “objects” to acquire like wealth, is encouraged by a polygamous social structure. In this sense, polygamy is also bad for women, because it makes them pawns in an acquisition game.

    The odd Tibetan and similar examples aside, there simply are very few examples of women acquiring multiple husbands, so we can dismiss that as a practical matter.

    But does monogamy have any place in the American constitution or legal framework, or must marriage be consigned to a more “market based” analysis (acquire whatever you can), or simply addressed under the categories of:
    Claim One: Due Process
    Claim Two: Equal Protection
    Claim Three: Free Exercise
    Claim Four: Free Speech
    Claim Five: Freedom of Association
    Claim Six: Establishment of Religion ?

    Well I’m no constitutional scholar, but I’d argue that you have to go back to the core principles of the declaration… the equality of man… and in this case perhaps even the original gendered meaning…. “all men are created equal”… and use that core principle to defend monogamy.

    Of course we had to enact whole amendments to the constitution to establish that principle for African Americans. We’d probably have to do something similar to establish the same general principle in the area of the equal rights of all men to form a family. (I understand how radical this is… I’m pursuing this as a thought experiment.)

    The point is that monogamy is about the equal rights of most men to take a bride and to have children. The fact that polygamy meets the needs of women to take a husband and have children, and might even meet their needs for freedom of choice in so doing, doesn’t eliminate the reality of the shut-out men.

    Do we feel a sense of solidarity with them? Does restricting the number of partners a man may have, or the number of wives a woman may partner with in a marriage, produce a harm that is so great that it outweighs the harm experienced by men who are shut out from ever reproducing?

    And really, do we want to live in a society that is so unequal and cruel?

    Polygamy seems innocuous because it is still rare. But our whole society is moving in a direction of wealth and status inequality. Do we want to enable that growing inequality among rich guys (they are mostly guys) to include the number of spouses they can simultaneously control?

    At a primitive level, monogamy is a bunch of guys sitting around saying “we’re in this together… everyone gets the same plot of land, the same basic rights, and for God’s sake, just one wife per man.” That’s a purely mythological expression of a deep idea. The growth of monogamy parallels the growth of human equality in history… its decline presages the rise of inequality.

    Which side of history do we want to be on, Mr. Turley?

  8. Mike S.,

    “However, I will defend the right of individual, non-conforming Mormon’s to adhere to what they believe are the true Mormon teachings of their Prophet.”

    I’d say we must be cautious about defending certain rights of individuals regarding the adherence to the teachings/practices of their churches. Some FDLS groups force young women into marriages with much older men. In some cases, the women are practically held captive.

    *****
    And this:

    Polygamy’s ‘Lost Boys’ expelled from only life they knew
    Sect’s outcasts are casualties of marriage practice
    By David Kelly, Los Angeles Times | June 19, 2005
    http://www.boston.com/news/nation/articles/2005/06/19/polygamys_lost_boys_expelled_from_only_life_they_knew/

    Excerpt:
    ST. GEORGE, Utah — Abandoned by his family, faith, and community, Gideon Barlow arrived here an orphan from another world.

    The freckle-faced 17-year-old said he was left to fend for himself last year after being forced out of Colorado City, Ariz., just over the state line.

    ”I couldn’t see how my mom would let them do what they did to me,” he said.

    When he tried to visit her on Mother’s Day, he said, she told him to stay away. When he begged to give her a present, she said she wanted nothing. ”I am dead to her now,” he said.

    Gideon is one of the ”Lost Boys,” a group of more than 400 teenagers — some as young as 13 — who authorities in Utah and Arizona say have fled or been driven out of the polygamous enclaves of Hildale, Utah, and Colorado City over the last four years.

    His stated offenses: wearing short-sleeved shirts, listening to compact discs, and having a girlfriend. Other boys say they were booted out for going to movies, watching television, and staying out past curfew.

    Some say they were sometimes given as little as two hours’ notice before being driven to St. George or nearby Hurricane, Utah, and left like unwanted pets along the road.

    Authorities say the teenagers aren’t really being expelled for what they watch or wear, but rather to reduce competition for women in places where men can have dozens of wives.

    ”It’s a mathematical thing. If you are marrying all these girls to one man, what do you do with all the boys?” said Utah Attorney General Mark Shurtleff, who has had boys in his office crying to see their mothers. ”People have said to me: ‘Why don’t you prosecute the parents?’ But the kids don’t want their parents prosecuted; they want us to get the number one bad guy — Warren Jeffs. He is chiefly responsible for kicking out these boys.”

    The 49-year-old Jeffs is the prophet, or leader, of the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. The FLDS, as it is known,
    controls Hildale and Colorado City.

    The sect, which broke from the Mormon Church more than a century ago, has between 10,000 and 15,000 members.

    It believes in ”plural marriage,” that a man must have at least three wives to reach the highest levels of heaven. The Mormon Church forbids polygamy and excommunicates those who practice it.

    *****

    Warren Jeffs may be in jail now–but…

    Jailed sect leader retakes legal control of church
    By Dennis Wagner, USA TODAY
    Updated 2/24/2011
    http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2011-02-24-jeffs-church_N.htm

    Excerpt:
    PHOENIX — Warren Jeffs, the jailed “prophet” of a polygamist sect based in two towns on the Arizona-Utah line, has launched a purge of key followers and reassumed legal command over his church’s corporation.

    But former members of the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints don’t seem to agree on what it means for the embattled organization or for its 55-year-old spiritual leader, in jail since his arrest in 2006. He resigned the presidency a year later.

    “It looks like Warren is taking power back,” said Carolyn Jessop, a former congregant who now lives in Salt Lake City and is still in contact with sect members. “It changes everything. He had indirect access before. Now, instead of people managing everything in the name of Warren, he’s managing in his own name.”

    Flora Jessop, a former church member in Phoenix who is not related to Carolyn and who also keeps in touch with members, offered a contrary view: “Warren never let go of control of the church, so I don’t know why this is a big deal. He’s always been calling the shots. Warren has always been the prophet, and there can be only one prophet on Earth at a time.”

    In a Feb. 10 declaration filed with the Utah Division of Corporations, Jeffs identified himself as the president and “sole” of the corporate arm of the FLDS sect, which is not affiliated with mainstream Mormonism.

  9. Other than William Holden in “Stalag 17,” who says ‘give that man a kewpie doll?’

  10. “Polygamy isn’t as bad as slavery, if all of the partners are consenting. But the forgotten and forever unable to marry men who it freezes out of family, are the forgotten victims, and good reason to consign it, along with slavery, to the dustbin of history.”

    Miles,

    As I alluded to on the other thread, I have never had money, fame or power, yet I’ve been lucky to have had many good relationships with desirable females and a great current one with the love of my life. Your assumption that the powerful will get most of the women is only workable if coercion or an impoverished society exists. In a society where there is choice, women are intelligent enough to choose the relationship that gives them what they need.

    The other thing i think you overlook is as women attain equality of power, who’s to say they wouldn’t want to have multiple husbands? The right to choose one’s relationship goes both ways and the assumption that the so-called Alpha Males will get the females in a free and open society doesn’t hold. By the way in the 19th Century that was a discussion had by mostly males, since women didn’t have any real autonomy

  11. Miles,

    Your comment begs the question that all males (or for that matter females) are equally attractive mates when they are manifestly not. If they were, serial monogamy would not the norm in our society (which is what marriage/divorce statistics tend to indicate). If polygamy has no criminalizing restrictions, what is to stop a woman from having multiple husbands (other than perhaps male ego)?

  12. As a colleague of mine once said about a case I was about to try, ” I am more impressed with counsel than his client’s case.” Good luck!

  13. “As long as no one suffers, the State has no business delving into, or ordaining the nature of human relationships.”

    Mike S. wins the kewpie doll. That statement is quite true regarding all the law as well. “We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.” Establishing justice, insuring domestic tranquility, providing for the common defense, and promoting the general welfare all require that government only intervene to prevent harm and promote the common good. If the common good or the individual is not harmed, a relationship is not the business of government. When it comes to weighing the harm to an individual versus the common good, it is utilitarian and axiomatic that the needs of the many out weight the needs of the few or the one.

  14. So of course the difference between gay marriage and polygamous marriage is that in case 1, more people get what they want, while in case 2, fewer people get what they want. Specifically societies that widely adopt polygamous marriage end up with an underclass of men who can never marry.

    How serious is that problem? Would law have any business enacting pro-monogamy laws to prevent it? Why should women not have the option of being a second or third wife to a “successful” or otherwise “desirable” man, instead of the wife of a “lower status” man?

    Those are all reasonable questions. But the fact remains that polygamous marriage as an institution is in-egalitarian. It produces male winners and male losers. This is the opposite of gay marriage which produces more male and female winners in a society.

    Some people think that it favors unequal patriarchal relationships within the polygamous family too, but I do know that some women defend such relationships – are they doing that because their polygamous marriages are freely chosen, or are they in some way deprived of their free will by the patriarchal ideas that sustain polygamous marriages? I honestly don’t know, but it seems possible. What I am sure of is that simple math assures that the advantage of some men, inevitably and mathematically is the disadvantage of others, in polygamy.

    That is the reason that the 19th century’s two great questions of human equality were slavery and polygamy. They both addressed the question of whether we would live in a society in which men were equal…. or not.

    Polygamy isn’t as bad as slavery, if all of the partners are consenting. But the forgotten and forever unable to marry men who it freezes out of family, are the forgotten victims, and good reason to consign it, along with slavery, to the dustbin of history.

  15. This is such a wonderful case to make, on so many different levels. I note that the LDS donated a lot of money to defeat gay marriage in California. It is time that citizens of Utah have the right to have a government of law under our Constitution, rather than a thinly disguised theocracy, changing the beliefs of their own original prophet for political gains.

    I am not a Mormon and frankly doubt the religion’s authenticity, but I am also not a prophet and don’t arrogate to myself the right to judge others beliefs. However, I will defend the right of individual, non-conforming Mormon’s to adhere to what they believe are the true Mormon teachings of their Prophet. It must also not be forgotten that plural relationships are not merely the choice of certain Mormons, but is also the choice of others holding different beliefs. As long as no one suffers, the State has no business delving into, or ordaining the nature of human relationships.

  16. Good brief, concise and logical. Pretty obviously Utah is engaging in selective prosecution after affirming to the Brown’s that they would not prosecute them. While that is not the central thrust of the case it is indicative of what a hot-potato this matter is. That means it’s ripe to be addressed and the Browns are lucky to have such a fierce advocate as the Professor to do so on their side. May I assume that the outline of the case to be presented before the SCOTUS is already written? 🙂

Comments are closed.