Today, we filed the complaint below in the challenge to Utah’s criminal polygamy law. I am still in Salt Lake City for the filing. With me today is our local counsel Adam Alba, an outstanding young attorney and one of my former students. As noted earlier, the lawsuit is on behalf of my clients, the Brown family. The Browns are featured in the TLC program Sister Wives as an openly polygamous family.
The Plaintiffs are Kody Brown, Christine Brown, Janelle Brown, Meri Brown, and Robyn Sullivan.
The Defendants are Governor Gary Herbert, Attorney General Mark Shurtleff, and County Attorney Jeffrey R. Buhman.
There are seven claims for relief:
Claim One: Due Process
Claim Two: Equal Protection
Claim Three: Free Exercise
Claim Four: Free Speech
Claim Five: Freedom of Association
Claim Six: Establishment of Religion
Claim Seven: 42 U.S.C. § 1983
As in past cases, I will have to be circumspect in what I say after the filing of this action. However, we are honored to represent the Brown family in this historic challenge,” said Professor Turley. “We believe that this case represents the strongest factual and legal basis for a challenge to the criminalization of polygamy ever filed in the federal courts. We are not demanding the recognition of polygamous marriage. We are only challenging the right of the state to prosecute people for their private relations and demanding equal treatment with other citizens in living their lives according to their own beliefs. This action seeks to protect one of the defining principles of this country, what Justice Louis Brandeis called ‘the right to be left alone.’ In that sense, it is a challenge designed to benefit not just polygamists but all citizens who wish to live their lives according to their own values – even if those values run counter to those of the majority in the state.
The following is the statement from Kody Brown, which will be the only statement at this time on the filing:
Statement of Kody Brown:
“There are tens of thousands of plural families in Utah and other states. We are one of those families. We only wish to live our private lives according to our beliefs. While we understand that this may be a long struggle in court, it has already been a long struggle for my family and other plural families to end the stereotypes and unfair treatment given consensual polygamy. We are indebted to Professor Turley and his team for their work and dedication. Together we hope to secure equal treatment with other families in the United States.”
Here is the complaint filed today: Brown Complaint
Jonathan Turley
Mike S.,
Are you suggesting my comment was a double-entendre? I’ll let you draw your own conclusion.
😉
Elaine M. wrote
“If so, why did the family decide to star in a TV reality show? Didn’t the family think the show would call attention to itself?”
Perhaps to gain public sympathy for their cause, and when the time was right sue the state and perhaps win and then finally be left alone to share the freedoms that the rest of us enjoy without fear?
Chris,
“2. In a free relationship market maybe polygamy would soak up some of the demand created by same sex marriages?”
Not sure how that would work. Can you explain?
“That’s true. We librarians know where it’s at–and we know how to use it!”
Elaine,
Was that “code” for some other meaning?
Gyges,
“Everything you object to happens just as regularly in monogamist societies with inequality as they do in polygamist societies with inequality. That suggests to me that they’re related to problems in the social rather than legal structure.”
Sure, it is possible to imagine that new things can happen in this world.
Social, legal and economic structures are all related to each other.
I think that polygamy in a modern industrial society like ours, once Mr. Turley and friends are successful, is likely to be to ancient polygamy, as modern day capitalism was to merchant traders from the middle ages – vastly more significant in scale and impact.
Powerful men already practice serial polygamy, of course, and with little shame. Why not do away with the pretense of divorce? Well, again, what is the goal? What vision of the good society do we want to paint in law and social institutions?
I see legalized polygamy as part of the general set of ways in which the world can grow vastly more unequal, if we let it.
Monogamy is no panacea – it’s just a reasonable balancing of interests and passions and human needs. Polygamy is also a “balance” of interests, passions and needs, but has such an obvious downside in its exclusionary effects, particularly in societies with growing inequality, that I can’t imagine how its legalization could be viewed as an advance in human society. It’s a balance too… a balance that stomps on the lives of many men.
“I support homosexual marriage for the same reason I support monogamy and oppose polygamy. Homosexual marriage enables more people to experience the benefits, with social approval, of marriage. Polygamy, does the opposite – it shuts people, men, out of marriage, in proportion to its success.”
That does not make sense on several levels.
1. Why is homosexuality gender neutral but not polygamy? Your position seems inherently sexist.
2. In a free relationship market maybe polygamy would soak up some of the demand created by same sex marriages?
3. Maybe some people would prefer and be fulfilled in an other than traditional marriage where they would not be in a traditional marriage. In fact the complaint lists one of the sister wives (Robyn Sullivan) who was in a monogamous marriage, but preferred polygamist marriage.
I looked over the information that was submitted to the courts and I’m impressed with the breadth of his research. I will point out something that the author himself confirms in his report.
The societies that Joseph Henrich uses as the basis for his projections have the roots of their sexual inequality rooted much deeper than polygyny. The woman is treated as chattel from the moment of her birth and the decisions about who she will marry is decided by the family through a complicated calculation of improving the wealth and social standing /of the family/. Those women have little or no vocational education or independent means of support. Most are solely reliant on their husbands for their wellbeing due to prohibitive laws (Such as prohibitions against women driving in Saudi Arabia). The laws in those countries impose further inequality by restricting or denying divorce to women unhappy with their situation. Also present are cultural conventions that stigmatize divorced women, providing a strong disincentive for them to leave unhealthy or unhappy relationships. Without those legal and cultural barriers, specifically worth noting; ‘living in a paternalistic theocracy’, the effects of the legalization of polyamory in a world of (ostensible*) sexual equality are NOT known and can only be guessed at.
My personal opinion is that monogamy is, and will likely remain, the most common type of marriage commitment. But it’s not the life I’ve found myself living and I don’t think the government should continue to criminalize the private relationships between informed consenting adults.
*gender, racial, and sexual equality are all things that we need to continue to work on in our society.
Miles,
“The absurdity is that the fiction of naming a wife a “girlfriend” currently somehow absolves the men of a felony.”
So are you contending that the difference between felony polygyny and the act of infidelity with a mistress is that your wife doesn’t know so it’s not illegal?
Miles,
“It should not be legal to maintain a relationship with multiple women (whether they are called girlfriends or wives), with whom a man repeatedly sires children.”
And you think that any system set up to enforce this wouldn’t favor the connected and wealthy?
Gene H.,
I’m a firm believer in getting as much information on a subject as I can.
“Librarians know where it’s at.”
That’s true. We librarians know where it’s at–and we know how to use it!
🙂
The absurdity is that the fiction of naming a wife a “girlfriend” currently somehow absolves the men of a felony.
Laws against bigamy / polygamy should address the reality of one man / multiple women… regardless of the legal status of the marriage.
It should not be legal to maintain a relationship with multiple women (whether they are called girlfriends or wives), with whom a man repeatedly sires children.
Do we want the State that involved in people’s lives? Well, the State is ultimately an expression of the community and its democratic will and its constitutional foundations.
Of course, it would be better if the State didn’t need to be involved, but when men are tying down multiple women we have a form of social organization that has consequences beyond the men, the women and their children, as noted above.
Chris Nystrom,
Please understand this: I am not for the criminalization of polygamy! I’ve already stated that more than once before on this thread–or maybe the other “Brown” thread. I don’t think Kody Brown should be charged with a felony.
The Browns may be a good case study. That said, it is just one polygamous family.
You wrote: “All they want is the right to be left alone from the government.”
If so, why did the family decide to star in a TV reality show? Didn’t the family think the show would call attention to itself?
Miles,
I could give you this “history hasn’t yet done all the things that history is capable of doing” exact response to your statement that all polygamist societies are unequal. Everything you object to happens just as regularly in monogamist societies with inequality as they do in polygamist societies with inequality. That suggests to me that they’re related to problems in the social rather than legal structure.
Elaine,
I read that Canadian report over lunch. Interesting stuff. I’d like to re-read it before forming a final opinion on the data, but my first impressions are that polygamy presents a more interesting set of problems than the contractual analysis suggests. While I thought that some of the problems (such as the slide into younger age pools for brides) could be addressed by taking societal norms and codifying them to create legal barriers to that practice, others clearly could not, such as the increased child mortality rates. There is some of the conclusions – specifically some of those regarding social status – that I was somewhat unconvinced by but those disagreements probably stem from my own admittedly unusual thoughts (and biases) concerning social status on the whole. I’ve always found that the way I value people socially is a bit different than the way others do so I try to take that properly into account when reading this sort of data. Overall, I’m going to say that the report – while not perfectly persuasive on all points – gives me reasons to change my opinion, but just the details of that change need time to gel and another review of the data.
Great find, by the way. I guess it’s true what they say about librarians. Librarians know where it’s at. 😉
Elaine M.
The Browns themselves are a better case study than your anthropologist. All they want is the right to be left alone from the government.
The case is trying the fix the absurdity of the fact that if the wives are referred to girlfriends there would be no problem, but if they are called wives then it is a felony.
I couldn’t imagine any democracy ever voting to go back to a polygamist society. Certainly the male losers would be against it. And as long as more females than alpha males are against it, as is probably the case, there would never be popular support.
Elaine, Thanks for that great material and the insight of the connection between limiting the supply of women through polygamy, and the analogous (in effect) practice of limiting the supply of women through sex selection.
These are different problems, but the social effects are definitely related.
Gyges, I am not aware of such a society. But history hasn’t yet done all the things that history is capable of doing! In the US, we might be the first, with Mr. Turley’s help.
Apparently the way it would happen is that people would make claims based on freedom and individual autonomy… having forgotten the good reasons that the specific freedom of men to marry multiple women was once ruled out.
I wasn’t aware of the Nazi proposal, but it certainly makes sense that they would propose it. They didn’t last long enough to put it into effect, but do you doubt that they would have had they lasted? And, you can certainly see how polygamy would be consistent with a worship of power and powerful men… and a corresponding disgust for less powerful men.
Miles,
Can you point to a society that changed back from monogamy to widespread polygamy? I’m honestly curious. Things have been WAY more unbalanced economically in Western history, and I can’t recall anybody switching to a polygamist marriage system. It was proposed in Nazi Germany, but that didn’t go anywhere.
The one-child policy in China that has been in effect for, I think, about three decades, has led to an imbalance in the male/female ratio. This had led to some problems.
The following article isn’t about polygamy. Still, I think some of you may find it interesting reading.
*****
In Asia, The Perils Of Aborting Girls And Keeping Boys
by NPR Staff
http://www.npr.org/2011/06/15/137106354/in-asia-the-perils-of-aborting-girls-and-keeping-boys
Excerpt:
June 15, 2011
In her trip through China’s Suining County in Jiangsu province, journalist Mara Hvistendahl saw plenty of familiar signs of economic growth. But she also saw something at an elementary school that startled her: There were far more boys in the classrooms than girls.
After months of research, she discovered a wide gap in the ratio between boys and girls, not just in China, but in other parts of East and South Asia. In her book, Unnatural Selection: Choosing Boys Over Girls and the Consequences of a World Full of Men, Hvistendahl writes that wider access to ultrasound technology and abortion has allowed parents in these developing countries to abort daughters in the womb and keep sons.
“As a country develops, birth rate falls, new technology comes in, and, unfortunately, one of the side effects is skewed sex ratio at birth,” Hvistendahl tells Morning Edition host Renee Montagne.
The rise of an educated and wealthy clientele in many Asian countries has made sex-selective abortion more common. But, Hvistendahl says, there are a few key differences between the cultural context of abortion in Asia and the West.
“In the U.S., a woman may have to brave picket lines to get an abortion,” Hvistendahl says. “She may not have a clinic in her town, and in many parts of Asia abortion is readily available, and so is ultrasound.”
Hvistendahl adds that gender discrimination in developing nations does not fully explain the drop in the number of girls born. “You have countries where women have very low status — in the Middle East for example — and the sex ratio at birth is balanced,” she says.
Gender imbalance comes, in part, from dramatic drops in birth rates. “The average Korean woman in the 1950s had six children. Now the birth rate is close to one,” says Hvistendahl. “It’s not that women necessarily want sons any more than before, but there’s more pressure on them.”
Hvistendahl explains that part of the drop in birth rates in Asia can be attributed to “a history of population control, and a dark history at that.”
***
The Dangers Of Gender Imbalance
As an example of the consequences of sex selection, Hvistendahl says that in Taiwan, many men have difficulty finding wives using traditional methods. Some even spend thousands of dollars on “marriage tours” to other Asian countries.
The fee includes travel, lodging and the purchase of women there. Hvistendahl says the problem is not limited to Taiwan, but also South Korea, and is growing in China, India, Albania and Azerbaijan as well.
As men find it more difficult to find wives in these countries, Hvistendahl says, “it is leading to unrest and almost certainly will lead to more.” Unmarried men are responsible for more violent crime than married men. And, Hvistendahl adds, research in eastern China showed a correlation between a high male-to-female sex ratio and the crime rate.
Here’s some evidence of what happened to our polyamorous ancestors — They went extinct.