Today, we filed the complaint below in the challenge to Utah’s criminal polygamy law. I am still in Salt Lake City for the filing. With me today is our local counsel Adam Alba, an outstanding young attorney and one of my former students. As noted earlier, the lawsuit is on behalf of my clients, the Brown family. The Browns are featured in the TLC program Sister Wives as an openly polygamous family.
The Plaintiffs are Kody Brown, Christine Brown, Janelle Brown, Meri Brown, and Robyn Sullivan.
The Defendants are Governor Gary Herbert, Attorney General Mark Shurtleff, and County Attorney Jeffrey R. Buhman.
There are seven claims for relief:
Claim One: Due Process
Claim Two: Equal Protection
Claim Three: Free Exercise
Claim Four: Free Speech
Claim Five: Freedom of Association
Claim Six: Establishment of Religion
Claim Seven: 42 U.S.C. § 1983
As in past cases, I will have to be circumspect in what I say after the filing of this action. However, we are honored to represent the Brown family in this historic challenge,” said Professor Turley. “We believe that this case represents the strongest factual and legal basis for a challenge to the criminalization of polygamy ever filed in the federal courts. We are not demanding the recognition of polygamous marriage. We are only challenging the right of the state to prosecute people for their private relations and demanding equal treatment with other citizens in living their lives according to their own beliefs. This action seeks to protect one of the defining principles of this country, what Justice Louis Brandeis called ‘the right to be left alone.’ In that sense, it is a challenge designed to benefit not just polygamists but all citizens who wish to live their lives according to their own values – even if those values run counter to those of the majority in the state.
The following is the statement from Kody Brown, which will be the only statement at this time on the filing:
Statement of Kody Brown:
“There are tens of thousands of plural families in Utah and other states. We are one of those families. We only wish to live our private lives according to our beliefs. While we understand that this may be a long struggle in court, it has already been a long struggle for my family and other plural families to end the stereotypes and unfair treatment given consensual polygamy. We are indebted to Professor Turley and his team for their work and dedication. Together we hope to secure equal treatment with other families in the United States.”
Here is the complaint filed today: Brown Complaint
Jonathan Turley
Elaine,
Thanks for finding that. I always try to base my opinion on something other than “what ifs?”
Gyges,
You say: “I somehow don’t see this becoming a social norm any time in the near to distant future.”
I do. I see our entire society moving in a direction of inequal distribution of economic resources. Now in parallel, we are observing an effort to enable unequal “distribution” (to put it crudely) of women… which amounts to unequal distribution of access to reproductive opportunity, sexual opportunity, relationship and love opportunity.
Polygamy is part of the same package that we see on a national scale with income distribution. Right now it doesn’t look that way. People think that polygamy is a San Francisco thing, a Utah thing… a hinterlands thing. What could it have to do with Wall Street and the concentration of economic and political power?
Well, I say, just watch. Polygamy is natural and it is ancient. In the ancient world powerful men often controlled disproportionate resources (we’re moving in that direction).
Meanwhile, as we endorse the unequal distribution of economic resources, we are also further along in the US toward creating a disenfranchised imprisoned underclass, with more people per capita in prison than anywhere. That’s just a little like those poor Mormon teenagers who are driven out of their communities because they are a threat to the powerful men who want to take their sisters for wives (speaking loosely here.)
I think that the more you understand about how normal and widespread polygamy has always been, the clearer can be your understanding of why its outlawing was such an important political advance.
—
Mike
I support homosexual marriage for the same reason I support monogamy and oppose polygamy. Homosexual marriage enables more people to experience the benefits, with social approval, of marriage. Polygamy, does the opposite – it shuts people, men, out of marriage, in proportion to its success.
—-
I’m pretty tired of repeated claims that polygamy (by which I mean poly-gyny) is somehow an equal opportunity phenomenon. Polyandry is extremely rare and always has been. There is no reason to think that one woman – many men constellations would ever approach in number the formation of one man – many woman constellations.
No, polygamy amounts to desirable successful men forming relationships with multiple women that serve to lock out less desirable, less successful men. How do we feel about those cast aside men? Are they part of our human society? Are they our brothers, our sons? Do we want to integrate them, or cast them aside, send them off to prison or war, and rule them out of the human future by denying them a reasonable chance to reproduce?
I’m a leftist, a progressive, who happens to believe that the evidence of human history and anthropology supports the profound value of monogamous marriage as a foundation of political equality, social stability and human happiness.
Mike S.,
“That he says it doesn’t make it so.”
I didn’t say it did. I had asked Gene H. yesterday if he knew about any studies that had been done on polygamy. He said he didn’t. I found one that I provided a link to. That’s all.
Just as there are dumb men–so, too, there are dumb women. Neither sex has a monopoly on “dumbness.”
“The problem with polygamy from a societal perspective is less the polygamous marriages than the people who are excluded from them – the men who are denied the opportunity to marry and reproduce.”
“A commitment to polygamy is a commitment to inequality.”
Miles,
I understand that is your opinion and I’ve read your arguments backing it up. They simply don’t persuade me. As to the first quote above I have seriously heard that argument made in the past about maintaining bans against homosexuality in lesbians. I don’t for a second believe you are homophobic, because you write very reasonably. However, assertions of belief have been most often responsible for bad law. Your second statement is just bald, unsubstantiated assertion, which ends up as your opinion which I would defend your right to have.
“can wipe away the social reality that polygamy creates a class of men who are winners in the marriage and reproduction lottery and a class who must be losers.”
Isn’t the basis of this assertion that many, many men would want to hog all the women and indeed if able would have multiple marriages, if permitted. I don’t think that is true. I certainly wouldn’t and I doubt you or the majority of men here would. There will always be some egotistical asses of men who would want essentially harems, but then there will always be men who are asses. Just as with homosexuality, legalization won’t make any of the poly’s more attractive.
“the polyandry argument is simply not realistic”
Could you explain why it isn’t realistic. Do you believe that the vast majority of women only want to have sex with one man? In a society where women have equal rights, we still admittedly have a way to go, why shouldn’t they want multiple partners/husbands? Some will, most won’t, but that is also the case for males. Relating well to one woman, even one as worthy as my wife, is not an easy task. Relating to more than one woman at a time can be quite exhausting as I discovered in my “single” days. However, I knew many guys who handled it with ease, but when they finally settled down it was with one woman. By the way there were no double entendres implied. Relationships are only tangentially about sex, although sex is important.
Miles,
So, let me ask you a question. Why is your basic assumption that if legalized polygamy would become the social norm?
Women in the US get to reject marriages, with no legal and few social repercussions, that’s a HUGE difference between us and polygamist societies that have existed in the past.
If, like me, you feel that most women (and men for that matter) would reject the arrangement, then there’s no reason to worry about the hordes of men without mates. In fact, if you look at the numbers, there’s a movement away from marriage and co-habitation of any sort. I somehow don’t see this becoming a social norm any time in the near to distant future.
“He warns that the practice of taking multiple wives generally drives men into competition that is “increasingly dangerous to society and to themselves.” This tends to make women “valuable objects rather than loveable people” and leads men to try to “control them more carefully.” The upshot is greater inequality between the sexes, a push for younger and younger wives, and lesser male investment in their individual children and wives”
Elaine,
That he says it doesn’t make it so. Eight now as Gene pointed out the trend of serial marriages shows some men do objectify women and go after younger ones. Women, however,have a choice in our society and if they freely want to enter into such a relationship that’s their business. Why they would I don’t know, but then I’m often amazed by men who want to marry women 20 or more years younger than men. As AY said and I agree:
“There is something sexy about an intelligent woman…Maybe it is just me….but I would take a woman’s mind over body”
We’re always going to have ignorant men who objectify women, but I think women are too smart to fall for that kind of man, or if the do establish a relationship it is for personal reasons beyond affection.
Mike S.
Your assertion that I claimed that polygamous relationships are “exploitative” encapsulates your misunderstanding of my argument.
I would argue just the opposite. Polygamous relationships can be happy for all the participants (although evidence suggests that this is far from always the case.)
The problem with polygamy from a societal perspective is less the polygamous marriages than the people who are excluded from them – the men who are denied the opportunity to marry and reproduce.
No argument about the personal freedom of men and women to contract whatever kind of relationships they want among multiple parties can wipe away the social reality that polygamy creates a class of men who are winners in the marriage and reproduction lottery and a class who must be losers.
A commitment to polygamy is a commitment to inequality.
Now there are no guarantees that in a monogamy system marriages will be successful, or that children will be created. But at least each man and woman has something resembling a reasonable chance.
Societies that allow men (and again, the polyandry argument is simply not realistic) to accumulate multiple wives, are creating a gradient that will profoundly reward some men, and punish others.
Unless our laws protect the potentially excluded men that polygamy must create we are not creating a society in which basic equality is guaranteed. This is not equality of outcomes – this is equality of opportunity. You don’t get guaranteed a successful or fruitful marriage – but you have to have some kind of reasonable chance at that. Polygamy denies that to men, in proportion to its success in becoming a social norm.
“Steve McQueen couldn’t hold a candle to William Holden in Stalag 17. Incredible wit, steel resolve, the essence of ‘cool’ and the perfect mindset to adopt when surrounded by mindless jingoism.”
Bob,
I agree. A quality I think Holden had, that McQueen had only to a lesser degree, was the ability to infuse his characters with deep intelligence, as well as cool. McQueen was, however, a favorite of mine and the quintessence of cool, though I the wonderful “Magnificent Seven” I think James Coburn stole the show for cool. Damn, now you’ve got me started on Movies and made me think about Toshiro Mifune, who in “Seven Samurai,”
“Yojimbo” etc. al., represented the best of “ruffian cool.” I’m digressing and going off topic, sorry, but I inhale movies.
Mr. Spindell,
“Nevertheless, we can’t as a society abjure them [Joseph Smith, L. Ron Hubbard, etc] with moral judgments, except when in cases like Jeffs, their conduct is clearly unlawful and despicable.
Absolutely.
Which is why I kept my comment on the personal level. But I felt the need to take a stand and call Josef Smith out on the evil he embroiled his people in.
He had an affair for which his wife left him. Instead of hanging his head in shame for breaking his vow to his wife and to God, God apparently looked favorably on his behavior and blessed him with the “revelation” of plural marriage.
I spit at his feet.
Now we as a society are going to decide, again, whether to reconsider where to draw the line. As this thread indicates, where it will be drawn remains to be seen.
I feel sorry for his people who inherited the madness and can’t seem to escape it.
Gene H.,
Here’s something I just found:
Is polygamy bad for society?
An anthropologist argues that it is as Canada considers whether having multiple wives is a constitutional right
By Tracy Clark-Flory
Salon, 7/28/2010
http://www.salon.com/life/broadsheet/2010/07/28/polygamy
As the U.S. reacts to Warren Jeffs’ shocking legal victory, Canada is embroiled in its own battle over polygamy. The British Columbia Supreme Court is considering whether outlawing polygamy would violate the constitutional right to religious freedom and freedom of expression. The case was prompted by the arrest of two of the country’s own Jeffs-like characters — the leaders of Bountiful, a rather, um, bountiful Mormon group in B.C. — but it gets at a much larger question: Is polygamy bad for society?
At least that’s the question anthropologist Joseph Henrich answers in court papers filed recently on behalf of the province. He warns that the practice of taking multiple wives generally drives men into competition that is “increasingly dangerous to society and to themselves.” This tends to make women “valuable objects rather than loveable people” and leads men to try to “control them more carefully.” The upshot is greater inequality between the sexes, a push for younger and younger wives, and lesser male investment in their individual children and wives (“partly because their resources will be much more widely spread; partly because they will increasingly spend their efforts on getting more wives rather than looking after the ones they have”). Note that polyandry, the practice of women taking multiple husbands is incredibly rare, so it doesn’t provide much in the way of real-life outcomes.
His conclusion, which you can read here, is ultimately about the benefits of monogamy:
Societies possessing norms that more effectively shape, harness, reinforce, and suppress aspects of our evolved psychology in ways that benefit the group as a whole in competition with other societies spread at the expense of societies possessing fewer group-beneficial norms. Monogamy may have spread, and continue to spread, because monogamous societies are more competitive: monogamy seems to redirect male motivations in ways that generate lower crime rates, greater GDP per capita, and better outcomes for children.
If we’re to accept his conclusion, then the question the B.C. Supreme Court has to answer is whether those constitutional guarantees can stand up against those negative outcomes.
*****
Link to the sworn affidavit:
Polygyny in Cross-Cultural Perspective: Theory and Implications
By Joseph Henrich, Canada Research Chair in Culture, Cognition, and Coevolution
University of British
http://www.vancouversun.com/pdf/affidavit.pdf
Mike S.,
There is something sexy about an intelligent woman…Maybe it is just me….but I would take a woman’s mind over body….but if we both get Alzheimer, then it won’t really matter….
http://www.onlinenews.com.pk/details.php?id=181382 Young Muslims in Indonesia and Malaysia overwhelmingly oppose polygamy. I think the world’s population is moving away from polygamy not toward it.
Mike S.,
I misunderstood what you wrote. I thought you were implying it was a combination of both religion and public mores.
“There’s a lot of things I admire about Josef Smith.
But I spit at his feet when it comes to polygamy.
His people are still paying for his mistake… and his lies.”
Nate,
There is nothing I admire about Joseph Smith. In my personal view he was a con man, who changed the “gospel” to suit his personal desires. However, I
feel the same way about L.Ron Hubbard. Religious leaders of all persuasions contain many con men dressed as moralists, including my own.
Nevertheless, we can’t as a society abjure them with moral judgments, except when in cases like Jeffs, their conduct is clearly unlawful and despicable.
Elaine,
That’s why I referenced “public mores.” Mores don’t strictly have religious connotations.
Brigham Young realized that giving women the right to vote in Utah would end polygamy.
I think the Brown’s just opened a can of worms. They might be biting of their nose to spite their face. What was once possibly punishable up to five years , may now end up regulated beyond their desires.
I can’t see polygamy not being decriminalized without regard to standard ideals of marriage.
If it were to occur, the best I can see is marriages reflecting business laws.
Sooner or later, a spiritual wife will leave and even if she signed something giving up right to property, children or anything else – with the dark side of polygamy, you can bet that eventually something will be disputed.
Not to mention, the hidden victims, the Lost Boy’s.
If any attorney were to fight for any noble right and cause, you would think it would be for the young victims (such as these Lost Boy’s) instead of for the likes of religious agenda.
In defense of Polygamy (and andry for that matter):
All of the argument’s I’ve read so far against it (with the exception of Bob’s), can also be applied to various forms of monogamy. From paternal overtones, to excess unmarried men, they’ve all existed in monogamist societies. They’re all symptoms of inequalities in a society, either between the sexes, or between the classes. That has nothing to do with the number of mates deemed normal by that society.
So, my question is, if we can have monogamist relationships without them, why on earth couldn’t we have relationships with more than two partners?
Mike S.,
“Morality connotes both religion and public mores.”
I don’t think morality necessarily connotes religion. There are many moral people who are atheists, agnostics, and secular humanists who live by an ethical and moral code.