Obama and the Decline of the American Civil Liberties Movement

Below is today’s column in The Los Angeles Times on the record of Barack Obama on civil liberties and his impact on the civil liberties movement in the United States.

OBAMA: A DISASTER FOR CIVIL LIBERTIES

With the 2012 presidential election before us, the country is again caught up in debating national security issues, our ongoing wars and the threat of terrorism. There is one related subject, however, that is rarely mentioned: civil liberties.

Protecting individual rights and liberties — apart from the right to be tax-free — seems barely relevant to candidates or voters. One man is primarily responsible for the disappearance of civil liberties from the national debate, and he is Barack Obama. While many are reluctant to admit it, Obama has proved a disaster not just for specific civil liberties but the civil liberties cause in the United States.

Civil libertarians have long had a dysfunctional relationship with the Democratic Party, which treats them as a captive voting bloc with nowhere else to turn in elections. Not even this history, however, prepared civil libertarians for Obama. After the George W. Bush years, they were ready to fight to regain ground lost after Sept. 11. Historically, this country has tended to correct periods of heightened police powers with a pendulum swing back toward greater individual rights. Many were questioning the extreme measures taken by the Bush administration, especially after the disclosure of abuses and illegalities. Candidate Obama capitalized on this swing and portrayed himself as the champion of civil liberties.

However, President Obama not only retained the controversial Bush policies, he expanded on them. The earliest, and most startling, move came quickly. Soon after his election, various military and political figures reported that Obama reportedly promised Bush officials in private that no one would be investigated or prosecuted for torture. In his first year, Obama made good on that promise, announcing that no CIA employee would be prosecuted for torture. Later, his administration refused to prosecute any of the Bush officials responsible for ordering or justifying the program and embraced the “just following orders” defense for other officials, the very defense rejected by the United States at the Nuremberg trials after World War II.

Obama failed to close Guantanamo Bay as promised. He continued warrantless surveillance and military tribunals that denied defendants basic rights. He asserted the right to kill U.S. citizens he views as terrorists. His administration has fought to block dozens of public-interest lawsuits challenging privacy violations and presidential abuses.

But perhaps the biggest blow to civil liberties is what he has done to the movement itself. It has quieted to a whisper, muted by the power of Obama’s personality and his symbolic importance as the first black president as well as the liberal who replaced Bush. Indeed, only a few days after he took office, the Nobel committee awarded him the Nobel Peace Prize without his having a single accomplishment to his credit beyond being elected. Many Democrats were, and remain, enraptured.

It’s almost a classic case of the Stockholm syndrome, in which a hostage bonds with his captor despite the obvious threat to his existence. Even though many Democrats admit in private that they are shocked by Obama’s position on civil liberties, they are incapable of opposing him. Some insist that they are simply motivated by realism: A Republican would be worse. However, realism alone cannot explain the utter absence of a push for an alternative Democratic candidate or organized opposition to Obama’s policies on civil liberties in Congress during his term. It looks more like a cult of personality. Obama’s policies have become secondary to his persona.

Ironically, had Obama been defeated in 2008, it is likely that an alliance for civil liberties might have coalesced and effectively fought the government’s burgeoning police powers. A Gallup poll released this week shows 49% of Americans, a record since the poll began asking this question in 2003, believe that “the federal government poses an immediate threat to individuals’ rights and freedoms.” Yet the Obama administration long ago made a cynical calculation that it already had such voters in the bag and tacked to the right on this issue to show Obama was not “soft” on terror. He assumed that, yet again, civil libertarians might grumble and gripe but, come election day, they would not dare stay home.

This calculation may be wrong. Obama may have flown by the fail-safe line, especially when it comes to waterboarding. For many civil libertarians, it will be virtually impossible to vote for someone who has flagrantly ignored the Convention Against Torture or its underlying Nuremberg Principles. As Obama and Atty. Gen. Eric H. Holder Jr. have admitted, waterboarding is clearly torture and has been long defined as such by both international and U.S. courts. It is not only a crime but a war crime. By blocking the investigation and prosecution of those responsible for torture, Obama violated international law and reinforced other countries in refusing investigation of their own alleged war crimes. The administration magnified the damage by blocking efforts of other countries like Spain from investigating our alleged war crimes. In this process, his administration shredded principles on the accountability of government officials and lawyers facilitating war crimes and further destroyed the credibility of the U.S. in objecting to civil liberties abuses abroad.

In time, the election of Barack Obama may stand as one of the single most devastating events in our history for civil liberties. Now the president has begun campaigning for a second term. He will again be selling himself more than his policies, but he is likely to find many civil libertarians who simply are not buying.

Jonathan Turley is a professor of law at George Washington University.

The Los Angeles Times
September 29, 2011

210 thoughts on “Obama and the Decline of the American Civil Liberties Movement”

  1. angrymanspeaks, September 29, 2011

    Dredd,

    Unfortunately talking like that is going to get us the big label. “Conspiacy Theorist.” Glad to hear I’m not alone.
    =====================================
    If you read the links in my comment you refer to, you will see that I cite to The Wall Street Journal, and The University of California, for data concluding the same thing.

    A conclusion of conservative and liberal alike.

    What I said is not a conspiracy, conspiracy theory, or the like, it is an academic reality revealed by experts in the field.

  2. That being said … give me a third, fourth, or fifth political party that promotes the principles I hold dear and puts forth a candidate like Kucinich or Sherrod Brown and I’m there.

  3. les,

    Can’t go there with you because the example you use to take the discussion to the area you intend isn’t comparative to today’s electoral (I’m referring to the Electoral College) selection. In the 1800 election states were all over the place in choosing their electors with Georgia opting out entirely from the popular vote … I think a couple of other states also opted out (electors by popular vote) but I’m not certain which ones.

    If you are asking me if I agree with those who choose not to vote because they don’t like either candidate, then my answer would be no, I don’t, which should be pretty obvious from my post regarding the age-old reality that many elections then and now are seen by voters as being a lesser of two evils choice.

  4. Blouise, The level of activism in a few states, Ohio, Wisconsin, Massachusetts, is heartening. Other states- not so much. I have no doubt that you in Ohio are going to be fighting this same battle repeatedly until you change the face of the Governor’s office and the legislature.

  5. Lotta,

    That was one fight we won but it was hard going and is coming around again in another form. the only thing going for us here in Ohio is that the Governor is so unpopular that Obama scores higher with republicans than he does. That means the present administration is saddled with a weak leader and Columbus acts accordingly. It’s the only bright spot in a sea of teabagging idiots.

  6. Lotta,
    the situation in Ohio is unbelievable. The DOJ needs to get off of their butts and get to work on these abuses. If they are not going to go after torturers, at least go after illegal voter suppression.

  7. Swarthmore mom: “I am taking the republican introduction of voter ID laws in 23 states as a serious violation of civil rights and an attempt to reintroduce Jim Crow.”

    I know that there are moves by Ohio congressman to have the Justice Dept. move on the the voter suppression but that may be moot now due to the Ohio legislature backing off the measures. The Justice Dept. should be all over these measures in every state but all that seems to be happening is hearings in Congress. The Justice Dept inaction is enabling this movement. All of these efforts have the effect of discriminating against protected groups and if nothing else the Civil Rights Division of the JD should be all over this.

    “CLEVELAND – Facing calls by area members of Congress for a Justice Department investigation, Secretary of State John Husted retracted a threat not to process mail ballot applications sent to voters by the Cuyahoga County government”

    http://peoplesworld.org/ohio-republican-forced-to-retract-voter-supression-threat/

  8. Off Topic:

    NYC Transit Union Joins Occupy Wall Street
    by Matt Sledge
    Huffington Post, 9/29/2011
    http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/09/29/nyc-transit-union-joins-o_n_987156.html

    Excerpt:
    New York City labor unions are preparing to back the unwieldy grassroots band occupying a park in Lower Manhattan, in a move that could mark a significant shift in the tenor of the anti-corporate Occupy Wall Street protests and send thousands more people into the streets.

    The Transit Workers Union Local 100’s executive committee, which oversees the organization of subway and bus workers, voted unanimously Wednesday night to support the protesters. The union claims 38,000 members. A union-backed organizing coalition, which orchestrated a large May 12 march on Wall Street before the protests, is planning a rally on Oct. 5 in explicit support. And SEIU 32BJ, which represents doormen, security guards and maintenance workers, is using its Oct. 12 rally to express solidarity with the Zuccotti Park protesters.

  9. Remember this, when the founders drafted our constitution they were much more worried about protecting us from our own government then they were about protecting us from outside threats. -thepilgrim

    Yes. We’ve let “our own government” run amok… and it’s clearly our biggest threat right now.

  10. At least when a Republican was in office we had an opposition party. This is why Obama is so dangerous, his actions have placed these issues on the fringe as Democrats either ignore or excuse Bush/Obama policies. Remember this, when the founders drafted our constitution they were much more worried about protecting us from our own government then they were about protecting us from outside threats.

  11. les, I don’t think they would stoop to being for such a thing unless the person was a Ron Paul supporter who favors ending the wars but does not seem to give a damn about other civil rights. I am just trying to make people aware of the extent that voter suppression is going on and that by electing republicans they will be endorsing it. You make good points. Glad you are back.

Comments are closed.