Prominent Orthodox Counselor Convicted Of Sexual Abuse Of 12-Year-Old Girl — Three Orthodox Men Charged With Harassing Victim In Court

gavel2We have previously discussed the often hostile treatment of victims of sexual abuse in some Orthodox Jewish communities. On Monday, one such case reached verdict with the conviction of Nechemya Weberman, a religious counselor in Brooklyn’s ultra-orthodox Jewish community. Weberman was convicted of 59 counts for the sustained sexual abuse of a girl who was sent to him after she began to question her faith and dress immodestly. The case highlighted the harsh treatment of those who reveal such crimes in the Orthodox community. During the trial, three men were charged with criminal contempt for snapping images of the victim on the witness stand with cellphone cameras and then posting them online. Previously, Brooklyn District Attorney Charles Hynes charged four men with trying to bribe the accuser to drop the charges. The case also raised troubling questions of special treatment given to the accused in this politically powerful community by Hynes in withholding their names from the public.


Weberman is a member of the large Orthodox community in Brooklyn. The 59 counts include sustained sex abuse of a child, endangering the welfare of a child and other counts. The abuse started when the girl was just 12 and continued until she was 15. Her parents were concerned that she was expressing interest in boys and dressing immodestly. She was also questioning their rigid faith practices of the Satmar Hasidic sect. He response, according to the jury, was sexually abusing her. The family paid him $12,800 in counseling fees.

Weberman, 54, is looking at a possible 25 years in prison.

Defense attorney Stacey Richman insisted that the girl was just vengeful and made up the entire story.

What is most disturbing are accounts from the girl and her family of how they were shunned and mistreated by the community for accusing a prominent Orthodox person. The father lost his business and the girl’s nieces were kicked out of their school.

The recent charges against the men show not just the continued hostility toward victims but the disregard of legal authority over the actions of some members of this community. The grotesque distortion of moral and ethical principles is shocking but hardly unique in today’s world of religious extremism. Rather than view the accused as a threat to this religious sect, it was the victim and her family that were blindly persecuted and harassed. The continued contempt shown by these individuals only magnifies the earlier concerns over the troubling special treatment shown by Hynes. There is clearly an absence of responsibility in parts of this community for such crimes. That leaves it to the government to reinforce the values clearly missing among these self-described moral men.

Source: NBC

77 thoughts on “Prominent Orthodox Counselor Convicted Of Sexual Abuse Of 12-Year-Old Girl — Three Orthodox Men Charged With Harassing Victim In Court”

  1. People need to stop, and look at the legal system. They have to analyze it seeing whether they see Jesus in it or whether they see the evil scribes ,and Pharisees in it. I say the religious scribes,and pharisees are in it. People have to answer for what they do or do not do.

        1. “The character of Jesus. Don’t you know the character of Jesus when you see him? He can be in spirit in anyone.”

          “I see Jesus clearly wherever he is. I unfortunately do not see Jesus in you at this time.”

          Jonathan Hughes,

          Far be it from me to criticize your religious views, as you have deigned to criticize the views of others, including myself. What I will say is that you exhibit the “deadly sin” of pride in that you think you can understand the thinking of a higher being and make pronouncements as to what that being wishes. You appear to take your beliefs from the KJV, but surely you know that bible is only one of many and one whose translations have been proven to be faulty. As to:

          “Jesus is not a pharisee”.

          You’re simply wrong historically and in terms of your understanding of what the Pharisees taught and believed. There are more historical records of what the Pharisees believed, than there are of Jesus actual existence. There are so far more records of Pharisee teaching than there are contemporary records of Jesus life, that there simply is no basis for comparison. Almost all of Jesus preachings, such as the “Golden rule” are elements of Pharisee philosophy.

          However, it really isn’t my intention to denigrate your religious beliefs, or even to attempt to shake your faith, which would be impossible. What I wish is merely to inform you that as dear as your beliefs are, so are mine. Where I chastise you is in the implication of your writing here that would have our governmental system ruled by your beliefs. You don’t get to impose your beliefs on me, nor should I try to impose my beliefs on you. The world we live in would be a far better place if people would follow that line of thought, in addition to living by the “Golden Rule”.

          1. MY views are directly from Christ that is not part of reliugon. How can religious people that wanted Jesus or lkazerus dead be a part of it? I teach the truth . Where lies have been taught.
            Search the scriptures. Jesus is in them. Jesus is in people that are like he is. I teach the golden rule. Had religions done the same would world history have been the way it was?
            The pharisees did not keep what was in their own book even as people do not keep what is in the KJV. It is either not taught, twisted or perverted in every which way or verses quoted saying nothing or verses out of context to make God look bad.
            Had people be like Jesus who did not war there would be no war = terrorism. Rule by the beliefs God has set fort through me will save .. your soul regardless of what an idiot does to your body.
            You have a lot of studying to do so you can get the right inturpritaton of the KJV. Religions butcher the KJV making it into a weapon. jails, and military, and oppressive laws against people like Pedo’s, zoosexuals naked people etc,etc.are made calling it good. That is religious. Kill or want to kill or arrest and be religious. Don’t whatever name you go by ,and you will be a Christian. Jesus gave life, and other good things that people cannot touch.
            13 different religious lies. Religion is militarily minded, connected to the legal system because religious people were behind the arresting and killing of Jesus.

            I believe Jesus who is the word made flesh. People like to use the bible KJV or other translation to hurt people. That is a misusing of the bible. People that misuse the Bible end up acting like the enemy of Jesus rather than Jesus. Pharisaical lies have been feed to people for centuries.

            1, Religions lie about hell giving the illusion that God is a god of war. Now you know why there are military armies, police, legal system, Sharia law., etc.
            Jesus never threw a stone,but because the truth was not taught worse than stones were thrown saying God was on their side with laws against whoever about whatever.
            Gods light seen to the human that kills or hates not being like Jesus sees God glory as if it was fire = hell. KJV 1 John 1;5, God is light. Heb; 12:29; a consuming fire. James 1:17, Father of lights, Hell is the glorified face of God Moses could not look at or become ashes. That light makes the earth to have no more sea making elements melt, and consumes the wicked around the city of God rev, 20. Hell is not a place. No lost no lake of fire. Gods light is good to those that love to do good.

            2, Religion lies about these words being public nudity or a various kinds of sexual activity.
            Defiled, abominable, perverted, and deviant art not what religions have taught over the centuries Fetishes, Yiffing, zoosexual sex are not abominable, defiled or perverted or deviant either. People perverted the words,10 things that are abominable. 15 verses about perverse. 4 about defile., zero about any sex. Pro: 17:23, Pro:, 15 4, Job 6 – 30, Pro:, 12 -8, Isa:”, 30 -12, 1 Tim:’, 6 -5, Deut: 16 -19, Job 8 -3, Jer: 23 -36, Gal: 1 -7, Ecc:, 5 -8, Micah, 3 -9, Pro: 19 1, Pro: 4 24, Pro: 3, 32, Pro: 12; 22, Pro: 20 :10, Pro: 6;16, Heb: 12:15: Isa: 59 -3, Mat: 15 – 11, Mark, 7 – 15,

            3, religions lie saying fornication is an active sexual sin.
            Fornication is a sin against the body, the other sin is outside of the body. War most certainly sins against ones own body, and the bodies outside of your body. Respect not the wife of another, and war is a thing that can result. Jesus avoided war by not wanting that which was not his.

            4, Religions lie about what sodomy really is.
            Oppressive Sodomites made sex other than heterosexual sex sodomy. Read Isaiah 1: 17, KJV.Gays, and zoosexuals oppress no one.
            Sodomite speaking in verse below.
            KJV,Genesis 19:. 9And they said, Stand back. And they said again, This one fellow came in to sojourn, and he will needs be a judge: now will we deal worse with thee, than with them.:Sodomite speaking is the one who came in to sojourn speaking in the third person wanting to judge condemn the two people in lots house. Lot does not let them. The Sodomite gets angry, and threatens lot. The angel pulls lot back into the house.
            Sodomy according to scripture is not sex of any kind. .Sodomites are judges condemners like sodomites Government supports sodomistic I will do worse to whosoever military.

            Luke 6:37;King James Bible (Cambridge Ed.)
            5, Religions encourage condemning being anti Christ.
            Judge not, and ye shall not be judged: condemn not, and ye shall not be condemned: forgive, and ye shall be forgiven:

            This is obviously not taught. Existing condemning legal system proves that.

            6, Religion thinks they are crafty connecting their name to the name of Jesus seeking his death. Religion has many names doing one of two things killing or arresting. You figure out who does that. That is religion that is against Jesus.
            Mark 14:1-9 KJV the chief priests and the scribes sought how they might take him by craft, and put him to death. John 12;10 the chief priests consulted that they might put Lazarus also to death;
            Since religion wanted worse to happen to Jesus killing him anyone or any institution wanting death or jailing for anyone would also be religion = people that are pre flood in behavior, and sodomistic in behavior. This means church, and state in spirit are not separate. People have been lied to for a long long time.

            7, Religion lies saying we are not a beast -animal. We are an animal needing to be like Christ is with Jesus in us to be like he is.
            God wants to manifest that fact to leave no doubt, and says there is no preeminence between us, and a beast KJV, Ecc: 3: 18 -20.,
            People are an animals. Do you want me to count the ways? Physiologically, biologically, Chemically, scientifically, microscopically piss, and shit like them sleep like them are born and die like them having territorial instincts,and the fight or flight response too. To think you are not an animal is in your head. To think not would need a psychologist to give you treatments to show you the truth.

            8, religious people are against the furry and natural genitalia wanting to seek vain glory trying to make the furry or clothing optional human out to be less than they are. Phil: 2: 3. call one part bad call the entire body or furry suit bad because the part called bad-is part of the whole. No schism in the body,1 Cor: 12:25.

            9, Religions have the KJV but do lot teach us the truth therein. Here again is evidence of the devil in people hiding truth, perverting words, taking verses out of context while having KJV in their blood soaked hands. 8 places in KJV says the heart figuratively is to be circumcised not the penis tip at all. Deuteronomy 30:6, Deuteronomy 10:16 ;Jeremiah 4:4 , Jeremiah 9:26; Colossians 2:11-15;Acts 7:51;Leviticus 26:41;Romans 2:29, circumcision is a blood sacrifice. nothing more nothing less.

            10, This country singing God a bless America are blaspheming Gods name to have a legal system, military, police, and calling drugs which are what people call medicine good. What is good care, better yet preventive care U,C,S , Chiropractic practitioners on upcspine or upper cervical heath centers. ”

            11, religions lie about what Satan looks like too. Had Satan show himself as depicted all would know who he is and not give him the time of day ignoring him avoiding him shirking him. Looking narrowly upon him. Satan is a deceiver. Satan is Lucifer a bright angel as bright as God himself in glory. but void of all of the meek, and lowly characteristics of Jesus. Those that do not know Jesus would be awe struck by such a being eagerly doing whatever the being asked them to do which would end in devastating destruction. People follow him doing evil to people. They will get an equal reward.

            Naughty is not we have been taught by religious people.
            12, Proverbs 6:12 A naughty person, a wicked man, walketh with a froward mouth.
            Jeremiah 24,2,One basket had very good figs, even like the figs that are firt ripe: and the other basket had very naughty figs, which could not be eaten, they were so bad.
            The people against the furry, gay, zoo, and Pedo are the people that are naughty.
            This makes the catholic church to be what the KJV calls naughty as the word really means. The people that follow Sharia law feel the same way against the gay too.

            13, The wrath of man is relied on to saying they protect, but the wrath of man is jailing, and warring, and killing in whatever way they can, and oppressing. That makes what people do thinking it protects their body as being naughty. Religion screwed up all of the truths in the KJV. We have God depicted in the media as being an old man with a beard like Santa claws. Religions do not speak up saying don’t that that is wrong. Why am I having to do that? Jesus is God being like a humble child. .
            James:1 20 – 21, for the wrath of man worketh not the rightiouness of God. Whearfor lay apart all filthyness ,and superfluidy of naugtyness, and recieave with meekness the ingraffted word which is able to save your souls.

            1. “MY views are directly from Christ that is not part of reliugon”

              Jonathan,

              Given that you claim direct contact with your God Jesus and in light of sage advice from DMHCarver, I bid you good fortune and continued blessings.

          2. Mike S., I would advise against engaging with Jonathan Hughes. He and “Living God” showed up on the blog about the same time (given the content of their posts and their similar style, I often wonder if they are not the same person), and either are proselytizers or trolls. The remind me of the race-baiters who responded to Prof. Turley’s posts regarding the attack by black youths on the drunk white guy in Baltimore from a while back. I wonder if they know they are in the wrong place, internet-wise?

            (Not to say that I agree with you that Jesus was a Pharisee! But such theological minutiae are completely unrelated to this thread.)

            1. DHMCarver legal system is pharisaical. Both do the same things condemning people. Militarily does the same thing condemning people to death.. How can Jesus be in the legal sytem or the military army? Jesus is not a pharisee. A pharisee is like a reed shaming in the wind to Jesus. Acting like a lot doing nothing.

    1. People need to stop, and look at the legal system. They have to analyze it seeing whether they see Jesus in it or whether they see the evil scribes ,and Pharisees in it. I say the religious scribes,and pharisees are in it. People have to answer fort what they do or do not do.

      1. “I say the religious scribes,and pharisees are in it.”

        Jonathan Hughes,

        It’s too bad you don’t understand the religion you profess to believe in, or its history. Jesus was a Pharisee to the day he died and his teachings were the teachings of the Pharisees. Your Gospels got re-edited at the Council of Nicaea almost three centuries after his death to make them more friendly to the Romans and to their Mithraic Caesar Constantine. Since the Pharisees led the revolts against Roman occupation they needed to be made out to be opponents to Jesus, rather than his allies.

        1. Mike Spindell Religion was apposed to him when God walked with us, and is against people that have him in spirit now. Jesus minded his own business, but those that do not will be burned by his glory.

          I see religion clearly with all of their lies. I see Jesus clearly wherever he is. I unfortunately do not see Jesus in you at this time. Jesus is not a pharisee. He said the self righteous planing the death or Jesus people would not be in the kingdom of God. One pharisee repented, Nicodemus. Jes8us is heaven in whoever.
          Please teach.
          Religions lie about what is in the KJV not telling the truth about key words turning Gods word in to a lie. Naughty in the KJV is being froward connected to abominable which to God is also being froward, and perverted too. Pro 4 24,Put away from thee a froward mouth, and perverse lips put far from thee.
          KJV, Proverbs 3, 32For the froward is abomination to the LORD,
          Pro 12; 22Lying lips are abomination,
          Proverbs 6:12 A naughty person, a wicked man, walketh with a froward mouth.
          Proverbs 17: 4,A wicked doer giveth heed to false lips; and a liar giveth ear to a naughty tongue.
          Jeremiah 24,2,One basket had very good figs, even like the figs that are firt ripe: and the other basket had very naughty figs, which could not be eaten, they were so bad.

          Religions are those words being naughty, perverted abominable, and froward. Jesus is none of those words.

  2. We need to see the photos of the jerkoffs who took the photos of the witness. Put them on buttbook and ridicule them. Put them on Wanted posters in NYC.

  3. The legal system is evil. The legal system acts like the people against Jesus. Sex happens. Whoever does good or bad will be judged equally by God, and God alone. Disassemble the legal system that condemns to save your soul.

  4. Hey, looks like old home week for disaffected Jews. Count me in. Makes you wonder who this big Jewish voting/financing bloc is that the pols keep genuflecting to (to seriously mix an allusion). Nevermind, I know. AIPAC is a pro at manipulating the “I control and speak for the Jews” racket.

  5. So he’s been convicted. Cue the inevitable claims of “anti-semitism”.

    DHMCarver –
    “The Catholic priesthood, the Boy Scouts, Penn State, the ultra-Orthodox in NYC — finally, the walls of silence are cracking.”

    Actually, that’s not the right imagery. I’d say more and more rocks are being turned over.

    The scumbags are there whether we’ve seen them or not. They’re just being exposed more.

  6. >”Defense attorney Stacey Richman insisted that the girl was just vengeful and made up the entire story.

    Do we know with certainity that what Stacy Richman said is NOT true?

  7. Thanks, Mike S.

    For years and years I, a Jew, have been trying to effectively attack Hynes and his office-full of thugs for their protection of abusers in Brooklyn, whether Orthodox Jews or others. He is a disgrace to his office and he uses all imaginable — and some unimaginable — tactics to brutalize victims who try to demand justice. Look at his work at:

    http://mothers-of-valor.org/

    State Senator (and later Governor of NY) David Paterson tried to help Dr. Amy Neustein and her daughter back in the early 90s — nobody could get past Hynes’ evil wall of mafia-style protection for abusers. SHAME SHAME SHAME. And now that this scandal has made the shame public, it reflects badly on ALL JEWS when the majority of us were trying valiantly to straighten out this horrific criminal conspiracy.

    Update on the Neustein case: The daughter apparently continued to reject and insult her mother in the most disrespectful way, but her mother still loves and defends her and points out that, earlier in her life, when she was not 100% in the mental/emotional control of the abusive elements of the coercive community, she was a sweet, kind, smart and empathic person. She gives examples of lovely acts this young woman did as a small child.

    To quote W. H. Auden: “Those to whom evil is done will do evil in return.”

  8. I too was born to Jewish parents, but, I long ago realized the vacancies & discrepancies of religion and I became an Atheist more than 30 years ago. My solution for these Orthodox ”CAVE MEN” would be this….. Tie their heads to their Genitals, using their long sideburns, and beards, and force them to walk around like that for 6 months………..

  9. MikeS

    Thanks for the clear explanation on this cult. Whats sad to me is that we can recognize this horror and the abuses of several Christian denominations as the acts of a fringe and well outside the moral and ethical teachings of those faiths but are totally unwilling to accept that the same can be said for the acts of Islamic radicals. All religions have their fringe whack jobs and those forces wax and wane over time.

    Even as a Pastifarian I am saddened that people use religion as an excuse for their demented behavior I would think religious people would be even more offended

  10. I guess it goes to show

    that Sociopaths come in all Shapes & Flavors, hiding in positions of Authority & dressing Pretty.

  11. DonS
    1, December 12, 2012 at 9:28 am
    ….. Oh, I guess the girl hasn’t been killed. Yet.
    ———————————
    well, according to the most strict interpretation of the Jewish fundamentals, she has been killed. If the abuse included the loss of her virginity she is no longer ‘alive’ to the highest level of life within the sect. Even if still a virgin, her reputation has clearly been murdered and the damage likely done. By taking so much $$$$ from the family under pretense, they have been murdered because they have lost resource with no return, the $$$ no longer available….it is crime most foul and forbidden…

  12. “And this is different from the Taliban or the Islamic suppression of women how? Oh, I guess the girl hasn’t been killed. Yet.”

    DonS,

    As a Jew let me respond to you by saying that your implication that this is no different than Fundamentalist Islamic suppression of women is totally correct. There is no difference. The Satmar Jewish community is much more a cult, than a representative of Judaism. It must be recognized as a cult and condemned as a cult, by Jews as well as no-Jews. They are to the community of Judaism, what the “God Hates Fags” Church is to Christianity. As with most cults it seems there is not only the degradation of females, but also the abuse of females. Also, as with most cults, the members stick together against what they perceive as the “outside”. They are so much a cult that they have attacked other groups in the Hassidic movement of Judaism, at one point threatening the life of “The Rebbe” of the Lubavitcher Hasidim.

    As to Brooklyn D.A. Hynes treating them with “kid gloves”, so to speak, the answer is both easy and telling. They vote as a block under instructions from their religious leaders. Block voting in politics is quite effective, if little achieved. This type of voting gives them more power than their numbers deserve. As a Jew I don’t hesitate to condemn this cult behavior, especially since this is a group that would only tenuously recognize my own Jewishness and certainly wouldn’t invite me into their Synagogues.

    It is necessary when discussing this group to point out their wide divergence from any sort of normative Judaism, Orthodox Judaism and even from the Hasidic movements. It is also necessary to condemn this sort of behavior and the implications it has for women within its aegis.

  13. Can we have some photos of the men who photographed the witness child while she was in court. It would be quite orthodox to ridicule these schmucks worldwide. As for the perp, he needs some time in Attica. The in court photo op dickheads need to be beaten within in inch of their toes.

  14. And this is different from the Taliban or the Islamic suppression of women how? Oh, I guess the girl hasn’t been killed. Yet.

  15. Well.. It appears that this is the right step…. Will wait for mike s to expand….

Comments are closed.