D.C. School Assigns Homework Comparing Bush To Hitler

hitlerGeorge-W-BushRepublicans and independents often complain of being an outcast political minority in the heavily Democratic Washington, D.C. However, one parent was unprepared for the homework assignment that his child brought home from McKinley Tech Middle School: asking students to draw comparisons between Adolf Hitler and George W. Bush.

No, this was not an art class comparing painting styles (here and here if you want to compare and contrast)

The students were told to fill in a Venn diagram comparing and contrasting the two figures:

homework_s220x344

“Now that we have read about two men of power who abused their power in various ways, we will compare and contrast them and their actions. Please refer to your texts, ‘Fighting Hitler — A Holocaust Story’ and ‘Bush: Iraq War Justified Despite No WMD’ to compare and contrast former President George W. Bush and Hitler. We will use this in class tomorrow for an activity!”

The parent called to complain and was told that the assignment was part of a curriculum unit approved by the school system as part of a focus on both the Holocaust and the Iraq war.

A spokeswoman for D.C. Public Schools later said the two readings were among suggested curriculum the school system had previously approved but that the texts were not meant to be compared in the manner assigned by the teacher who “deeply regrets this mistake, and any suggestion to malign the presidency or make any comparison in this egregious way.” “Suggestion [of] . . . any comparison in this egregious way”? A bit more than a suggestion, I would think. It is like comparing Obama and the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse and has a certain loaded quality. It is like saying “Ebola has killed thousands of people. Bush killed thousands of people. Compare and contrast.” This is bit misleading without a tad more information.

What is interesting is that the assignment has the same quality as a push poll designed to influence or voters under the guise of conducting a poll. It has the same impact as the neutral poll used recently against a Democratic candidate when people were asked “What would you think of Elizabeth Colbert Busch if I told you she had had an abortion?”

How is this for the next Venn diagram: “Propaganda is used to to give biased or misleading information from a particular political point of view. Your last assignment sought to compare a recent president to a genocidal murdering fanatic that killed millions. Compare and contrast.”

Source: Washington Times

304 thoughts on “D.C. School Assigns Homework Comparing Bush To Hitler”

  1. Olly, I respect your take. I too have your general philosophy, that’s why I engage many people w/ whom I disagree. I won’t intrude again, or will take my opinions offline, since that has now been secured..hopefully.

  2. Mike A – it probably does not make you feel any better but I have explained to newcomers that WordPress is not personal, no moderator is stopping things and what possibly can get you into moderation mode.

  3. Olly – I’m still interested in any reasonable points you have – on any subject, even if NS isn’t. Don’t be an Ostrich.

  4. I have a very favorable review of Family of Secrets and have come to realize that the section of Baker’s book on the Kennedy assassination if fatally flawed. It makes the claim that George Poppy Bush bought the Zapruder film and kept it under raps for 10 years when in reality, it was made public almost immediately. 3 copies were made, 2 going to the Secret Service and Zapruder sold the TV rights to the other copy. If this is how well Russ Baker investigates, then it is all down hill.

  5. Mike it gets confusing when there is a weekend blogger who presents himself as a moderator or ‘VP of discipline’ of sorts. Clarity is a good thing and some niggling questions have now been clarified, thanks.

  6. Nick, you have your criteria and I have mine. I wouldn’t remain in this blog if I didn’t have something to learn from the very people I disagree with. And there are plenty of opportunities to learn.

  7. Olly, I have spoken of my “ignore” list. You are engaging a charter member. Hopefully that will influence your future commenting.

  8. Annie:

    I addressed that issue directly when the accusations were made against Elaine and rafflaw. I speak only for myself, but I believe that the guest contributors have grown weary of constantly having to go back to square one with explanations and sometimes just don’t bother responding at all. This is my first opportunity to catch up with the blog in several days, and the first thing I encountered was this issue. It’s frankly annoying.

  9. As to the topic of the thread, the actions of the teacher were evidence not only of poor judgment, but of incredible stupidity. The reaction of the parents was understandable and justified.

  10. Mike, I asked Darren directly once if he deleted comments, he refused to answer as is his right, no problem, but since then I have been curious about the truth of the matter, thanks for answering my question. I agree that it is insulting for weekend bloggers to be accused of deleting comments as Elaine and Rafflaw were accused of a while back also. Ok, end of discussion on my part.

  11. Annie —

    Agree w/your comment at 6:40 p.m. It IS definitely enough to baffle the curious.

  12. olly,

    I don’t need your juvenile unsolicited advice. Besides, I had every reason to WONDER if he was intentionally censoring me. WHY he chose to characterize what imo was/is a reasonable question as insulting him, i don’t know. I also don’t know why he would be so thin-skinned. Must have really bothered him a lot. i thought he’s a LEO, and they are used to dealing with people who feel they’ve been unfairly dealt with. Ask Annie.

  13. Yes, I had an Amazon link on one thread to the Royal Winnipeg ballet, Dracula: Pages From A Virgin’s Diary, and whoooosh, right to moderation. Maybe it is set up to intercept that kind of stuff as “commercial” or something???

    Squeeky Fromm
    Girl Reporter

  14. Annie:

    Guest contributors do not censor posts. A decision as to whether to delete what someone has written is made solely by the owner of the site. When I am available to rescue a post, I try to do so, but I have never deleted anyone’s comment and I am certain that that is true of the other guest contributors as well. For the life of me, I can’t understand the suspicions that occasionally pop up here.

  15. Is there a “moderator” here? Are all weekend bloggers “moderators”? I think respect for other “moderators” has been severely lacking. While its a good idea to respect everyone, can someone tell me why Darren should be afforded more respect than, say Elaine was, or Rafflaw, or Chuck, or Mespo? I’m asking these questions not to cause a disturbance, but because MANY commenters here have noticed a huge discrepancy in enforcement of the civility rules and deletions. I’m not demanding an answer and actually don’t really need an answer, but I think it needs to be said out loud.

  16. bill mcwilliams and everyone else:

    For the umpteenth time, this is not a moderated site. No one is sitting around waiting to intercept comments or commenters. If a comment gets hung up, it has to do with the software itself. Those few of us with editor access also have lives and jobs of our own. Get a grip.

  17. My point is we are privileged guests in the Jonathan Turley blog and with that comes certain responsibilities. One of those is to be respectful to the hosts trusted representatives. Insinuating the moderator has purposely censored you, right after you admit you may be to blame, is not the most respectful method of influence I would recommend.

Comments are closed.