
Republicans and independents often complain of being an outcast political minority in the heavily Democratic Washington, D.C. However, one parent was unprepared for the homework assignment that his child brought home from McKinley Tech Middle School: asking students to draw comparisons between Adolf Hitler and George W. Bush.
No, this was not an art class comparing painting styles (here and here if you want to compare and contrast)
The students were told to fill in a Venn diagram comparing and contrasting the two figures:
“Now that we have read about two men of power who abused their power in various ways, we will compare and contrast them and their actions. Please refer to your texts, ‘Fighting Hitler — A Holocaust Story’ and ‘Bush: Iraq War Justified Despite No WMD’ to compare and contrast former President George W. Bush and Hitler. We will use this in class tomorrow for an activity!”
The parent called to complain and was told that the assignment was part of a curriculum unit approved by the school system as part of a focus on both the Holocaust and the Iraq war.
A spokeswoman for D.C. Public Schools later said the two readings were among suggested curriculum the school system had previously approved but that the texts were not meant to be compared in the manner assigned by the teacher who “deeply regrets this mistake, and any suggestion to malign the presidency or make any comparison in this egregious way.” “Suggestion [of] . . . any comparison in this egregious way”? A bit more than a suggestion, I would think. It is like comparing Obama and the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse and has a certain loaded quality. It is like saying “Ebola has killed thousands of people. Bush killed thousands of people. Compare and contrast.” This is bit misleading without a tad more information.
What is interesting is that the assignment has the same quality as a push poll designed to influence or voters under the guise of conducting a poll. It has the same impact as the neutral poll used recently against a Democratic candidate when people were asked “What would you think of Elizabeth Colbert Busch if I told you she had had an abortion?”
How is this for the next Venn diagram: “Propaganda is used to to give biased or misleading information from a particular political point of view. Your last assignment sought to compare a recent president to a genocidal murdering fanatic that killed millions. Compare and contrast.”
Source: Washington Times

Why just the other day, September 6th, I noticed that two comments were silently deleted from the 99.999% Certainty Thread. Most specifically, from 7:19 am to 10:22 am — blog time.
The first comment deleted was posted by Max-1, while the second comment deleted was posted by rainparade. Max-1 stated something to the effect that Nick Spinelli was a bully. Rainparade stated that Spinelli was the, “Conrad Dobler of the blogosphere.”
I remember this because I had no idea who Conrad Dobler was. So I googled it and saw that it was a reference to some “dirty player” in the NFL.
I didn’t think too much of the two small comments from Max-1 and rainparade, as at the most both comments consumed only twenty or so words.
Upon returning to the thread later, though, it was noticed that Max-1’s and rainparade’s comments were gone. Now, in and of itself, I couldn’t care as their comments were insignificant.
But then something strange happened. Paul C. Schulte posted a comment referring to rainparade’s “Conrad Dobler” comment, which had been deleted, by someone, three hours earlier:
“Conrad Dobler of the blogosphere? That is the pot calling the kettle black!”
http://jonathanturley.org/2014/09/04/report-there-is-a-99-999-certainty-that-humans-driving-global-warming/#comment-1284418
There is no mention of a “Conrad Dobler” anywhere else in the thread, and rainparade’s comment had been deleted three hours prior.
Have fun, kids!
James – JT sometimes does stealth deletions. It has happened to me. 🙁 Both of the comments that went missing would be considered uncivil.
Here’s my homework assignment teacher…
… Charlie Chaplin as Hitler, speaks!
Lets remember Karen too that it was the German Psychiatrists doing the experiments and eugenic exterminations.
TL – much as I hate to say it, eugenics was in full-swing in the United States at the same time.
Mike and Darren,
I have been away from the site for a few hours, but I noticed your responses to questions about the weekend contributors possibly censoring comments. Thanks for your responses.
John, what the heck are you saying or not saying? Sure, Darren is an honorable guy, most honorable blogger I know on the site. Finishing with ‘I don’t know him’ suggests a twisted mind.
I leave the Hitler associations to the http://larouchepac.com/ activists.
Doesn’t that teacher know that Obama is Hitler now? http://larouchepac.com/files/remove_0.jpg
Obama fits the bill much better. I had several T shirts made a year ago and often wear one. Others I sold; they say on the front:Is Barack O More Dangerous Than Adolf H? Back: 1.Murders Children To Abolish 2nd Amendment! 2. Abolishes The Rule Of Law Using US Drone Strikes! 3. Repeals The Magna Carta With Rights Stripping NDA Act!
In the early days I thought Junior was the evil clown, but later I realized he was the sincerest prez we’ve had since Carter & maybe the only one ever, but severely misguided by his dad and others. He’s probably the only real Christian prez in 60 years; not particularly a compliment on the last as I think Father Christmas is realer than any big G god the three big G religions dream up. Anyway, my T shirt has been well complimented in the Rockies but most Americans are too chicken to wear it.
Notice how haunted BO looked in last night’s address? Possibly no sleep but for sure he’s leaned on by the Illuminati. Seems like the plan is to keep on generating more terrorism to ‘combat’.
TL – you should be aware that the Magna Carta has NO standing in US law.
compare todays mainstream media to Pravda just the differences I do not see much if any
Commenters,
Darren Smith is an honorable man. His integrity is unassailable and his ethics, above reproach. He is eminently wise, conscientious, accomplished and prompt. It is not known to man when he has been off the mark. When a man lives the truth, he cannot be challenged. Look elsewhere for a source of perturbation.
I do not know Darren Smith, but I know this.
First of all, I have to question why this Washington, D.C. teacher jumped ahead in the text book to compare two world leaders. The school year has just begun and middle school students should not into WWII or modern presidents. There’s too much preliminary history to cover in the Fall semester. That’s what parents should be questioning.
Secondly, I think it would have been more interesting to compare one American president against another American pres. or two controversial World Leaders from other countries e.g. Hilter and Stalin, or Hilter and Mussilini.
As a principal I would question the teachers intent, I would let this assignment slide, but be more observant in the future on the teachers intent on teaching history and making sure he wasn’t propagandizing or teaching an underlying ideology.
Well, you figured me out Bill. The jig is up. How will I ever manage to move past the humility? Speaking of humility and things people know nothing about; I have a book recommendation for you: Humility by David Bobb
olly
So that’s your excuse for avoiding subjects that you know nothing about? You would be forgiven your situation if you would simply say you don’t know enough about the point or subject to talk about something you’re uninformed about.
Better yet, just don’t respond to articles and comments you know little about.
“better to remain silent and thought a fool.than to speak up and remove all that”. A. Lincoln –not Abe Linkman, from Pittsburgh
It’s good to know our private information will be protected here, thanks.
It is well past time to repair to the “elementary school” concepts of Jefferson et al.
Privatize the education industry after Jefferson’s taxpayer funded “elementary school.”
The teachers, unions and collectivists have expropriated the private education industry.
Teachers, unions and collectivists are drunk with their power, and the bias and incoherence of political correctness, or liberalism, has shown its true nature of pointless indulgence, zeal, deliberate convolution and irrationality.
Eliminate unions and contracts for teachers and all taxpayer funded governmental workers.
The governmental workers are the subjects of the sovereigns, who are the
citizens.
Annie wrote:
“Mike, I asked Darren directly once if he deleted comments, he refused to answer as is his right, no problem, but since then I have been curious about the truth of the matter, thanks for answering my question. I agree that it is insulting for weekend bloggers to be accused of deleting comments.”
~+~
I will address this once.
First, as to me refusing to answer, there was no refusal to answer. Whether it was because I did not read the comment or I chose not to I remember not, but drawing inferences to what my intentions are is speculation at best.
If it will settle the issue, the only comments I have deleted were those that were spam. Other comments that contained profanity, were threatening in nature to other commentators, calls for violence, or contained information such as social security numbers, addresses or phone-numbers of others that appeared to be without their permission were the only reasons that I and the rest of us put these into moderation for our host to ultimately decide whether to approve them back to the public forum or to send them to the bit bucket.
As for the issue of the reasons I chose not to bring back a recent commentator’s comment out of moderation: First, we are under no obligation to retrieve comments of others. We do this voluntarily to assist those who visit the website. We are also under no obligation to edit comments that get shunted into moderation because the author provided text that the system flagged. We are not required to make such comments work by spending time editing them.
If we chose to do so it is on our own volition. It is obvious that we collectively have made much effort to retrieve flagged comments. Commentators are free to object to and insult me as they choose, but if they do so and at the same time expect me to do a favor for them, well I am not going to go out of my way to help.
Well said Darren.
Bill,
My speed and direction are doing just fine. I usually don’t take anyone seriously that finds it necessary to use terms like boosh or obummer. That’s a dead giveaway that any hope of finding objective, rational thought within will likely be dashed. I would add you’ve tainted any expectation others might have you’re interested in reasonable dialog given your obvious lack of humility. Thanks
olly –
you, like pcs, need to get up to speed on the subject, first. GW DOES share the same ideology as his father, but you will have to do a little bit of reading, if you want to be taken seriously when you post about the booshes and JFK
go to http://whowhatwhy.com/
and read the research findings about the conspiracy to assassinate jfk.
sounds like you know very little, or nothing about that. just like Paul — only he might be just trying to muddy the waters.
bill mcwilliams – all I have seen on these ‘conspiracy sites’ about Bush are bad scholarship and abysmal research skills.
I’m trying to understand the logic here. Is the point about GHWB in this particular thread meant to demonstrate the son will share the ideology of the father? So hypothetically, if the father suffered under an imperialist regime then it follows the son will carry the torch for the father and seek redress?
PCS – your facts couldn’t be more wrong. Did you just make that up? Go to his web site. He has a ten articles long series on GHWB’s doings related to JFK’s murder.
I am only going by the review which was practically asking him to have his baby. I think the review is as long as the book.
http://exiledonline.com/a-brief-history-of-media-cover-ups-self-censorship-reviewing-family-of-secrets/
WordPress is a third world system.