
Republicans and independents often complain of being an outcast political minority in the heavily Democratic Washington, D.C. However, one parent was unprepared for the homework assignment that his child brought home from McKinley Tech Middle School: asking students to draw comparisons between Adolf Hitler and George W. Bush.
No, this was not an art class comparing painting styles (here and here if you want to compare and contrast)
The students were told to fill in a Venn diagram comparing and contrasting the two figures:
“Now that we have read about two men of power who abused their power in various ways, we will compare and contrast them and their actions. Please refer to your texts, ‘Fighting Hitler — A Holocaust Story’ and ‘Bush: Iraq War Justified Despite No WMD’ to compare and contrast former President George W. Bush and Hitler. We will use this in class tomorrow for an activity!”
The parent called to complain and was told that the assignment was part of a curriculum unit approved by the school system as part of a focus on both the Holocaust and the Iraq war.
A spokeswoman for D.C. Public Schools later said the two readings were among suggested curriculum the school system had previously approved but that the texts were not meant to be compared in the manner assigned by the teacher who “deeply regrets this mistake, and any suggestion to malign the presidency or make any comparison in this egregious way.” “Suggestion [of] . . . any comparison in this egregious way”? A bit more than a suggestion, I would think. It is like comparing Obama and the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse and has a certain loaded quality. It is like saying “Ebola has killed thousands of people. Bush killed thousands of people. Compare and contrast.” This is bit misleading without a tad more information.
What is interesting is that the assignment has the same quality as a push poll designed to influence or voters under the guise of conducting a poll. It has the same impact as the neutral poll used recently against a Democratic candidate when people were asked “What would you think of Elizabeth Colbert Busch if I told you she had had an abortion?”
How is this for the next Venn diagram: “Propaganda is used to to give biased or misleading information from a particular political point of view. Your last assignment sought to compare a recent president to a genocidal murdering fanatic that killed millions. Compare and contrast.”
Source: Washington Times

I agree Annie. And I would add those people seeking anonymity have the responsibility to make that desire clear when they leave this blog and decide to send an unsolicited tweet under a different name.
FYI, I’ve never had any of my comments ‘silently’ deleted.
Yes Olly, that would include respecting other commenters’s privacy, for those who choose to comment anonymously. We don’t get away with “outing” people here.
For the benefit of those unfamiliar with WordPress, here is an image of what those with “Editor” privileges can see. They see your name, the email address you entered when posting the comment, and your ip address. If you included a website, that information is also included.
An “Editor” can edit, delete, recover, and reply to any comment. If a filter puts the comment in the spam folder, the Editor can recover it. — I’m sure this site gets lots of SPAM. As such, finding your comment among the SPAM can take some time. Asking nicely for assistance will go a long way.
If your comment violates the civility rules, your comment can be deleted without comment. At some point you would think that those who consistently violate the civility rules would stop expecting JT to take the time to personally address them each and every time the violate the civility policy.
https://www.dropbox.com/s/ioynfnrert8xzgj/wordpress%20Editor.jpg?dl=0
I find it less of a mystery as to why posts go missing than why the contributor is shocked that they do. I actually support the system JT employs as it forces people to be more considerate with their contribution. If one does not want to run the risk of losing a post then simply stay away from the edge of civility.
Barkin Dog, I actually like your idea. To bad it’s never gonna happen.
Annie,
It like his policy on everything else. Expect inconsistency…. You and I get named when the thread gets personal…. The instigators never get named…. I have had posts deleted without warning and got blocked without warning…. You explain the rational and Ill nominate you for congress and donate money to your campaign…
AY – any ‘blocking’ of your posts is the fault of WordPress, not any human.
Laura, When the govt. keeps secrets they are spitting in our faces.
Actually AY, I don’t think it’s any weekend blogger, I believe it is JT and I just am wondering why sometimes it’s announced and sometimes it’s not. A bit of consistency in a policy might create less confusion.
Why haven’t we heard the name of this teacher? First it is the cops who are kept secret and now teachers. This is ridiculous. The teacher I am sure is not in any great danger and the public, including the media, has a right to look into the background of this individual to see if he or she has had other problems that the school board should have dealt with.
Annie,
JT will regularly delete comments without an announcement. I don’t think Darren has the would as he is a moralist. How he lasted in law enforcement as long I am not sure. I don’t think the GBs have the ability to delete only retrieve. I may be wrong.
John, Your assessment of Darren Smith is spot on. If someone has a problem w/ Darren, they need to look in the mirror. He is unquestionably the most valuable guest blogger here.
Also, 1:14 AM is hardly late night. I don’t smoke weed to fall asleep.
More assumptions, what else is new? It’s actually similar to those who believe in conspiracy theories.
Paul, The late night always brings out the conspiracy folks on all blogs. Some big ones last night. I always envision them listening to Art Bell and commenting on many blogs. I suffered from insomnia earlier in my life. It is tough. But my bout was prior to internet. I just had books, TV and radio. Others didn’t get to know about those thoughts you have in the middle of the night when you can’t sleep. I think it was better that way.
Paul,
I have participated in numerous blogs and I found those contributors that have developed inflammatory nicknames for their targets or draw comparisons like the 8:19a post here, never pan out to be anything more than fool’s gold.
Rather than go to war to police the world with ships at sea, planes on tarmacs in Turkey and in the air over Iraq, and troops on the ground, we need to withdraw and issue a proclamation. Call it the BarkinDog Proclamation. All you people in pirate territories can kill each other off, religion go after religion. But if one single Saudi gets on a plane with a box cutter and tries to hijack it, then we drop an atom bomb on that guy’s mother’s village or city. We catch him and ask the Saint Louis question: Where’d you go to high school?
That is it. Some country or punk screws with us then we wipe out his family, his town, his region, his Mosque and his dumb mommie.
BarkinDog: Great idea! I always wanted US to be the ones to start an atomic war!
The entire premise is wrong here…. Wouldn’t it be more appropriate to compare George W. Bush-it… to a “Downs Syndrome” Retarded person????
zarathustraSmiles – if you compare George W. Bush to a Down’s Syndrome adult, then you have to do the same with Kerry (current secretary of state) who had a lower IQ score and lower grades than George W. Bush. So actually, the assignment would be to compare them both in a triple circle Venn diagram.
Not that I’m any fan of Kerry’s, but I’d love to see some documentation on the concept that W.’s grades and/or IQ were higher than Kerry’s.
markkernes – here is a link to the Bush/Kerry IQ scores. It comes from the NYTimes, a very conservative newspaper, so keep that in mind.
http://www.nytimes.com/2004/10/24/politics/campaign/24points.html?_r=0
Paul: Wow! I know I’M impressed by the “probable” conclusion of a conservative columnist regarding the “estimated” respective IQs of Bush and Kerry—what better evidence would I need than that? And to think, even though Bush and Kerry were both C-students (which I personally think should be an automatic disqualification for high office), Bush was actually ONE grade point higher than Kerry! That says it all, doesn’t it?
markkernes – you asked, I answered. And we have some real problems with Obama since he has never revealed his grades. We do know that he was a poor student in high school and at Occidental (Dreams of My Father). We also know that he was selected to the Harvard Law Review by his fellow students, not by the law professors, so he got in on popularity, not intellect. Hence his one ‘article’ in the review.
Paul: And when *Obama’s* suitability for office is the subject under discussion, I’m sure those facts may have some relevance.
markkernes – Obama’s suitability for office is always a topic.
Progressives have a stranglehold on our schools. It is time to get them out.
No political agenda should be attached to our public schools.
I have no issue with discussion of how a president or the government has abused powers but the problem here is this is all one sided and from the left side. For the record I am against one sided from the right side as well.
James, very interesting. I’ve also noticed several of these unannounced deletions or ‘disappearances’ of these types of comments. Usually when JT has deleted a comment he announces it with a comment. Strange that some deletions are made without an announcement and some with. It gets a bit confusing as to who is doing what when its being announced one time and being ‘silently’ deleted another time. Oh well I guess it’s a mystery.