Foul Play: Phillies Protest Decision Not To Expel Its Own Pitcher[Updated]

cubs-shotAs I always do, I watched my Chicago Cubs play last night against the Phillies.  In the Eighth inning with the game all but over with a 5-1 Cubs lead, a curious thing happened.  Third base umpire Joe West came out as Addison Russell was batting.  He called out Phillies pitcher Austin Davis for something that was not clear — something that brought out manager Gabe Kapler.  It turned out that Davis was using a crib sheet or scouting card and pulled it out to check out the stats on Russell who was brought in to pinch hit for Kyle Schwarber.  That was in violation Rule 6.02(c)(7) and the sheet was taken away.  Now, the Phillies are seeing a convoluted way to try to negate the one-sided loss. It is my dream come true: law has finally made it into an actual baseball game.  Before I address the legal issue, I simply want to repeat my willingness to suit up as the Cubs pinch lawyer to call all future legal hits, strikes, and balls. Since I am already responsible for winning the 2016 World Series (and I clearly already have a uniform), I think that this is a signing that needs to happen this season. Joe Maddon, I am ready to start as the designated lawyer.  Send me in, coach.

Rule 6.02(c)(7), is entitled “Improper Play, Illegal Action, and Misconduct” and “Pitching Prohibitions,” and mandates that a pitcher must not have “on his person, or in his possession, any foreign substance.”  The commentary to the rule further states  that a pitcher may not “attach anything to either hand, any finger or either wrist,” and that the umpire shall determine “if such attachment is indeed a foreign substance for the purpose of Rule 6.02(c)(7).”

Now here is the kicker.  The Phillies are arguing that if the rule was violated, West should have thrown their pitcher out of the game.  That’s right, they are complaining that their own pitcher was allowed to pitch — or be allowed to violate the rule with the crib sheet.

It is a legal variation of “junking a game”– not trying to win as much as losing in a better way.

The sheet is clearly a “foreign substance.”  And the rule mandate that, for any violation of Rule 6.02(c)(2) through Rule 6.02(c)(7), the  pitcher “shall be ejected immediately from the game” and receive an automatic suspension of 10 games.  West merely took the scouting card when he should have tossed out Davis.


Kapler did protest but it is not clear if he demanded an expelling of his own pitcher.  That brings us to  the protocol:

Managers can protest a game when they allege that the umpires have misapplied the rules. The umpires must be notified of the protest at the time the play in question occurs and before the next pitch or attempted play begins. If the play in question ended the game, a protest can be filed with the league office until noon the following day. No protests are permitted on judgment calls by the umpires.

Major League Baseball’s executive vice president of baseball operations later determines whether the protested decision violated the rules, though the game will not be replayed unless it is also determined that the violation adversely affected the protesting team’s chances of winning.

It did not seem to me that Kapler was protesting the game in seeking the explanation. He also seemed to be arguing that it was not a violation.  (Other pitchers have been spotted with such cards).  I believe an argument can be made that there was not a sufficient protest before the next pitch to Russell.
What is fascinating is the lack of discretion on the violation. West was trying to take a measured and non-disruptive action in the interests of the Phillies. However the rule does not have an option for the lesser (removal of the foreign substance) within the greater (expulsion and suspension).
The question now is whether the Phillies can actually erase a loss in their close bid for the playoffs based on the fact that their own pitcher was not tossed from the game.  That is an argument that only a lawyer — and a Philly fan — could love.


Update:  I am left watching today’s game like a regular slob with no call up from Maddon.  Worse yet, the MLB has declared that cheat sheets will be allowed — removing my big play for designated hitter.

13 thoughts on “Foul Play: Phillies Protest Decision Not To Expel Its Own Pitcher[Updated]”

  1. Professor Turley’s love of the game is infections. Has he ever gotten the chance to meet the team in person?

  2. It requires a special sentencing. One season learning cricket.

    To speed up the game cut down the number of statistics and lengthen the time spent playing instead of airing commercials.My last one watched was a rally monkey game but it was easily 50% commercials and 25% statisics. With the rally monkey to watch that left 10% playing the most uninteresting part.

  3. “Third base coach Joe West” confirms my suspicion, as a life-long Phillies’ fan, that the umpires work for the opposing team.

  4. Baseball is making rule changes to speed up the game. One rule change is limiting mound visits by catcher/coach/manager to 6 per game. A good rule change IMO. Pitching coaches would often visit to go over the scouting report on a batter. Allowing notes on scouting reports should have accompanied this 6 visit rule.

  5. While this may have technically violated the rule on foreign substances, it did not violate the intent of the rule. The intent is to prevent doctoring of the baseball to benefit the pitcher. The idea that a pitcher would have a card with information on all the possible opposing pinch hitters is something relatively new and should be addressed by MLB. I don’t have a problem with it. It certainly beats stopping the game while the pitching coach comes out to the mound to tell the pitcher about the batter.

  6. I suspect that Austin Davis will be granted immunity by Mueller and will be the star witness in the upcoming Cubs Collusion trial.

  7. Personally, I see this going the Supreme Court. This is a case of great import and the entire nation is waiting for an expedited decision.

    1. As a St. Louis Cardinals fan, if this goes to court, I’m going to file an amicus brief in favor of the Phillies.

      1. Don de Drain – we clearly need a SC decision the first week in October. Baseball waits for no man.

Comments are closed.