Supreme Court Declines Review of Maryland’s Sensitive Places Gun Control Measure

We have previously discussed the effort by some states to achieve greater gun control by using the language from the concurrence of Justice Brett Kavanaugh in  New York State Rifle & Pistol Association, Inc. v. Bruen, recognizing the right to bar guns from certain “sensitive places.” The response from blue states was to assemble a long list of such sensitive places to achieve indirectly what they could not achieve directly in cases like Bruen.  Some of us have been writing for years that this trend is ripe for Second Amendment review, but the Court just turned down review of such a law in Novotny v. Moore. While agreeing that the case was not ideal for reviewing the issue, Justice Clarence Thomas said the Court needs to take up the matter and leaned into the merits.

The decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association, Inc. v. Bruen was one of the most significant victories for the Second Amendment in the history of the Supreme Court — and one of a number of defeats for states like New York.

However, New York Gov. Kathy Hochul (D) held a virtually mocking press conference after the decision that they would just come up with a long list of sensitive places.

Hochul and others are relying on the Kavanaugh concurrence in Bruen, joined by Chief Justice John Roberts. Kavanaugh reaffirmed the language in the 2008 decision in Heller v. District of Columbia that the Second Amendment was “neither a regulatory straightjacket nor a regulatory blank check.” States and the federal government could still adopt some restrictions on firearms. He specifically noted that the list of “sensitive places” referenced in the earlier case was not “exhaustive.”

Kavanaugh’s limiting language was immediately taken as a license to bar guns by redefining places where they might be carried. Some of us have suggested these laws go far beyond the exception intended in Bruen. and called for the Court to clarify the standard.

It appears that Justice Thomas shares the same concern. His statement on the denial of certiorari in Novotny v. Moore suggests (as expected) that he is highly skeptical of such lists:

Maryland is one of several States that prohibit law-abiding gun owners from carrying firearms in a wide variety of public places. Under Maryland law, an individual may not carry a firearm in public demonstrations, mass transit, places of amusement, healthcare facilities, locations that sell alcohol for onsite consumption, and tens of thousands of acres of state park and forest land. The Fourth Circuit upheld these restrictions against petitioners’ Second Amendment challenge because it concluded that each law banned firearms in a “sensitive place.”

I am skeptical that each of these laws “is consistent with this Nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation” in “sensitive places.” Still, I agree with the Court’s decision not to grant certiorari. Because each Maryland statute implicates a distinct historical tradition of firearm regulation, the breadth of petitioners’ challenge would complicate our review. In an appropriate and more narrowly focused case, however, we should consider the scope of States’ authority to ban firearms in “sensitive places.”

The Second Amendment recognizes the people’s “inherent” right to keep and bear firearms, a right that admits of only historically grounded exceptions. Before and after the founding, it was well understood that individuals enjoyed a natural right to keep and bear arms, which included the right to carry firearms in public spaces for self-defense. The Constitution “codified [that] pre-existing right.” The first generations after the founding recognized the breadth of the Second Amendment’s “guarante[e],” and “those who sought to carry firearms publicly and peaceably in antebellum America were generally free to do so.” Thus, when a State seeks to restrict the right to bear arms—including by limiting the places in which a law-abiding citizen may carry his firearm—the State must root its law in the Second Amendment’s “historical understanding” by “demonstrat[ing] that the regulation is consistent with this Nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.”

This Court has previously acknowledged a limited tradition of States’ regulating the right to carry firearms in certain “sensitive places.” In Bruen, we observed that early American legislatures sometimes prohibited weapons in “legislative assemblies, polling places, and courthouses.” But, we emphasized that this tradition was narrow. “[T]he historical record yields relatively few 18th- and 19th-century ‘sensitive places’ where weapons were altogether prohibited.” While “courts can use analogies to those historical regulations of ‘sensitive places’ to determine that modern regulations … are constitutionally permissible,” “expanding the category of ‘sensitive places’ … to all places of public congregation … would eviscerate the general right to publicly carry arms for self-defense.”

Nevertheless, States have seized on the idea of “sensitive places” to prohibit the peaceable carry of firearms in locations that bear little resemblance to legislatures, polling places, or courthouses. New Jersey, for example, prohibits firearms in at least 25 locations, including zoos, public libraries, casinos, and state-owned beaches. New York has designated 20 locations as “sensitive,” ranging from “any place of worship” to “residential settings licensed … by the department of health.” California’s 29 gun-free spaces include “athletic facilit[ies],” “financial institution[s],” and any government-permitted “public gathering or special event.” {Several other States ban firearms in many public places.} These restrictions stand on questionable historical ground. And, their cumulative effect is to prohibit firearms wherever people gather for eating, drinking, recreation, amusement, and free speech—an affront to the right of “law-abiding citizens” to “carr[y] arms in public for” their “ordinary self-defense.”

The lower courts have largely blessed these ahistorical ventures. The Fourth Circuit below upheld all but one of Maryland’s locational restrictions. A now-vacated decision of the Third Circuit upheld many of New Jersey’s “sensitive-place” laws. Courts of Appeals have also rejected challenges to specific locational restrictions in New York, California, and Hawaii.

I harbor serious doubts that our Nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation supports many of these sweeping restrictions. In an appropriate case, this Court should consider whether particular sensitive-place laws are consistent with the right to public carry.

That’s one vote, and there are likely three other justices inclined to grant certiorari in other challenges moving toward the Court with a narrower footprint. In the meantime, Thomas just gave a shot across the bow for states daisy-chaining sensitive places into a constructive gun ban.

110 thoughts on “Supreme Court Declines Review of Maryland’s Sensitive Places Gun Control Measure”

  1. I wonder if Kavanaugh now recognizes that his concurrence was a mistake, as written. While he may have been correct on principle, it would have been far better had any statement in Bruen recognizing exceptions been crafted far more narrowly, so that the burden of concocting cases and filing appeals designed to end up in SCOTUS’ domain would have fallen on the States.

  2. Dear American liberals, leftists, social progressives, socialists, Marxists, and Obama supporters, et al: We have stuck together since the late 1950s for the sake of the kids, but the whole of this latest election process has made me realize that I want a divorce. I know we tolerated each other for many years for the sake of future generations, but sadly, this relationship has clearly run its course. Our two ideological sides of America cannot and will not ever agree on what is right for us all, so let’s just end it on friendly terms. We can smile and chalk it up to irreconcilable differences and go our own way. Here is our separation agreement: Our two groups can equitably divide up the country by land mass, each taking a similar portion. That will be the difficult part, but I am sure our two sides can come to a friendly agreement. After that, it should be relatively easy! Our respective representatives can effortlessly divide other assets, since both sides have such distinct and disparate tastes. —We don’t like redistributive taxes, so you can keep them. –You are welcome to the liberal judges and the ACLU. –Since you hate guns and war, we’ll take our firearms, the cops, the NRA, and the military. –We’ll take the nasty, smelly oil industry and the coal mines, and you can go with wind, solar, and bio-diesel. –You can keep Oprah, Whoopi, Bill Maher, Michael Moore and Rosie O’Donnell. You are, however, responsible for finding a bio-diesel vehicle big enough to move all five of them. –We’ll keep capitalism, greedy corporations, pharmaceutical companies, Wal-Mart, and Wall Street. –You can have your beloved lifelong welfare dwellers, food stamps, homeless, homeboys, hippies, druggies, and illegal aliens. –We’ll keep the hot Alaskan hockey moms, greedy CEOs, and rednecks. –We’ll keep Bill O’Reilly and Bibles and give you NBC and Hollywood. –You can make nice with Iran and Palestine and we’ll retain the right to invade and hammer places that threaten us. –You can have the peaceniks and war protesters. –When our allies or our way of life are under assault, we’ll help provide them security. –We’ll keep our Judeo-Christian values. –You are welcome to Islam, Scientology, Humanism, political correctness, and Shirley McLaine. You can also have the UN., but we will no longer be paying the bill. –We’ll keep the SUVs, pickup trucks, and oversized luxury cars. You can take every Volt and Leaf you can find. –You can give everyone health care if you can find any practicing doctors. –We’ll keep “The Battle Hymn of the Republic” and “The National Anthem.” –I’m sure you’ll be happy to substitute “Imagine,” “I’d Like to Teach the World to Sing,” “Kum Baya,” or “We Are the World.” –We’ll practice trickle-down economics and you can continue to give trickle-up poverty your best shot. –Since it often so offends you, we’ll keep our history, our name, and our flag. Would you agree to this? If so, please pass it along to other like-minded liberal and conservative patriots and if you do not agree, just hit delete. In the spirit of friendly parting, I’ll bet you might think about which one of us will need whose help in 15 years.

    1. Trapper, coastlines, waterways, borders north and south and coast guard, then I’ll think about it.

  3. X offers a useful response to mine when he quotes from his AI summary.

    Yes..RETIRED law enforcement officers who maintain their annual qualifications can carry firearms openly or concealed (subject to the individual State Law). He fails to grasp I stated I was a “former” Officer and Special Agent….not a “retired” officer or special agent.

    He also skipped right over the fact that I presented a hypothetical case where the State enacts a law that expands the State Law that includes Churches but does not offer an exemption for non Law Enforcement Officer Church Security staff.

    As to the suggestion I was offering a threat….I am glad that person took note of that.

    I can assure you that it is a promise …. not a threat. The “threat” is an over zealous mob like control of the the Congress and White House that stacks or fills a Supreme Court that ignores the Constitution and instead assists in the advancement of a political agenda that does infringe upon the Second Amendment and by doing so causes honest law abiding citizens to reject that and see the real need to forcibly resist that over reach by the Democrat Party when it is in control of the federal government or even State Governments.

    The US Supreme Court must adhere to the a legitimate interpretation of the US Constitution and not participate in a partisan political effort.

    We have a Bill of Rights that has guided us the 250 years of this grand experiment that has so changed the World and this Nation….that holds our Rights do not come to us from government but rather from the concepts and beliefs of the People who stood against tyranny and crafted a whole new view of how every individual is equal under the Law and are protected by a common belief in freedom and sanctity of those inalienable Rights set forth in the Constitution and its Amendments.

    As usual…there is a reason the Founders saw a need for the First and Second Amendments as basic Rights owing to the fact they are the first two Rights listed in the Bill of Rights. We should do the same….and ensure those two Rights are effectively guarded against any infringement by fiat of a corrupt political scheme…..in the current case….the Democrat Party.

    The Democrats have lost their way…and there is in existence the means to put an end to it should it become necessary but hopefully it shall be by means of the ballot box.

    What we should do instead of arguing about guns….is look to the Democrat Party to lead the way in obtaining a balanced Federal Budget and dealing with the ever growing Federal Debt. That is the greatest threat to our Nation and our individual freedom. Both Political Parties and every Congress to date that has accepted and approved a Deficit Budget. Those are the true enemies of the State that have harmed all of us the most.

    What say we have that argument….over yet more Federal Spending, higher taxes, higher costs, and the destruction of the future of those that follow us in life. We should be able to agree upon the end goal even if we do not agree on the path to it.

    However…I know without any doubt the Democrats shall as usual go the path of yet more deficit spending, happily raise taxes, and squander Trillions of Dollars. I also know without any doubt the Republicans too shall go along and fail to act as a counter to all of that as they too want their cut of the Federal Grift.

  4. Didn’t Charlie Kirk say about innocent Americans being slaughtered by crazed strangers, “it’s worth it to keep America free”? To me, losing Charlie wasn’t “worth it”.

    There was a time when Americans thought freedom and public safety were compatible goals achievable through common sense, balanced policy. For example, entering a Courthouse through a metal detector, or not allowing firearms in the cabin of an airplane.

    Hmmm, there weren’t airplanes in 1790…so what tradition of gun regulation justifies that law?
    These Justices who look to “tradition” instead of contemporary common sense have their wires crossed. They’re grasping for straws.

  5. It’s simple. Firearms can be kept within a person’s domicile UNLESS a landlord, coop, HOA, other, declares such a sensitive place. Private property owners might be what’s left. Defend your 🏰.

    No hunting allowed in the US. The US is vegan. Enjoy the humus and bread, curry chickpea stew on a cold winter night prevents animal cruelty.

    1. The most hilarious thing is that one reason for defending AR-15s is they are needed to kill the feral boars (is there any other kind) that have run rampant – but are only there because hunters imported them to have something else to kill.

      Good job gun nuts.

    1. Gun sales will go up massively in response to the propaganda that the Democrats will take them away. The Democrats will not, in fact, try to take the guns away.

      Some of those guns will get into the hands of toddlers who will shoot and kill other toddlers.

      1. @Anonymous–

        “Some of those guns will get into the hands of toddlers who will shoot and kill other toddlers.”

        Sad, but true.

        Irresponsible parents, relatives and so-called friends who allow children to access their firearms should be skinned alive, salted down and staked out on a red-ant hill.

        While I am no great fan of additional gun-control laws, EVERY state should have a law requiring safe storage of firearms, in order to prevent access by children or irresponsible adults to firearms.

        Yes, yes, yes… I know all the arguments against safe storage laws, especially the one that argues that “safe storage” prevents quick access in the event of a home invasion, robbery, etc., yaddah, yaddah, yaddah…

        First of all, if a person can afford a firearm, one can likely afford an electronic gun safe that allows quick access via a code or touch identification.

        Should that not be the case, keep the loaded firearm under your immediate control, or, in the case of a handgun wear it in a holster on your hip; what could afford quicker access than that?

        And when you are out of the house but children or untrustworthy adults are home, simply unload the gun and store the it and the ammunition separately in some inaccessible place.

        What could be simpler, in order to protect our children from killing each other?

  6. The Second Amendment is abundantly clear.

    Any attack against or infringement of it constitutes rebellion and insurrection, both of which must be suppressed with extreme prejudice by the executive branch.

    ____________________

    2nd Amendment

    A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.

  7. Everyplace is a sensitive place to a crazy person. There are millions upon millions of females who have not ever held gun, picked up a gun, fired a gun and think the world should be a kinder, friendlier place. The criminals just need a donut and a hot cup of coffee and a social worker. Honest to god…

    1. As long as the good guys say a gun can solve personal problems the bad guys will believe them.

      Recall how effective it was to tell people that smoking would make them popular and they would be out doing athletic things? And a lot of adolescents looked at that and wanted to be popular so they smoked.

      The gun lobby tells similar lies. That a good guy with a gun will stop a bad guy. Over 175 guns were at Uvalde while a single bad guy hunted children. How many good guys and their guns should it take?

      1. Estimates of defensive gun uses vary widely. On the high end, an academic study by Kleck and Gertz estimated the number of defensive gun uses in the US could be as high a 3.6 million per year. Even on the extreme low end, the Bureau of Justice Statistics estimates at least 60,000 defensive gun uses per year.

        Congress experimentally banned firearms that Democrats call “assault weapons” for a ten year period. Studies show there was no material change in violent criminal conduct during that time. In fact, during the period of the experimental ban, two boys in Columbine, Colorado used assault weapons to kill several of their classmates at school.

        When have bans every stopped criminal conduct? Some in the temperance movement were so convinced that banning alcohol would turn people into angels that they developed plans to convert all the excess prisons and jails they envisioned inoo productive uses. Instead, banning alcohol turned otherwise lawful establishments into illegal speakeasies and their customers into criminals; led to illegal bootlegging and wholly unregulated and taxable alcohol production and distribution; and contributed to the growth in organized crime syndicates who terrorized each other and sometime the general population.

        Banning marijuana did not prevent degenerate hippies or rich kids from highly privileged families in suburbia from smoking the devil’s lettuce. People still inject heroin into their veins despite it being unlawful to do so for decades and $millions spent on campaigns to discourage illegal drug use. Someone during the Biden administration brought cocaine into the White House and left it laying around despite recreational cocaine use and possession being illegal. Homosexuality and miscegenation were once unlawful activities, but it did not stop some people from engaging in homosexual conduct or mixed race sexual relations.

        Nobody likes what happened at Uvalde, Columbine, or Sandy Hook. The difference is between the realists and the fantasists. The realists see that there are an estimated 300 million+ firearms in private hands. The vast, overwhelming majority of gun owners -likely greater than 95% – do not use them unlawfully.

        The fantasists seem to think that turning 95% of the gun owning population into instant criminals will stop gun violence. It won’t. We can reasonably surmise from historical analogies and human nature that all it will do is turn otherwise law abiding gun owners into instant criminals and push the gun economy underground.

        1. @Anonymous–

          An excellent post. It’s a pity that you don’t use a “handle” so we can tell which amongst the plethora of Anonymice you are, but I have come to understand why some of the commenters here choose not to use a handle.

        2. Self-reported self-defense claims are suspect. They don’t offer an explanation that a baseball bat or pepper spray would have been just as effective; even a cast-iron frying pan could have been sufficient.

          It is very unlikely that a good person with a gun stops a bad guy with a gun already drawn and aimed. But a gun can certainly kill a girl for trying to turn a car around in a driveway.

          Kaylin Gillis – she’s just another trophy for self-defense gun lovers.

    2. Many of my comments are meant as humor. fyi

      I do think the dems are moving toward guard your castle idea only if it’s private property. Votes needed in collectives. Transport to ranges require a yearly pass like State Park passes. No hunting or hunting season is a pass now, I think. I’m not a hunter. I could be if hungry. I don’t know if scrubjays, and crows are tasty otoh. Who was it, what group were killing ducks in parks as food? Haitians?

    1. As a once frequent visitor to Sequoia National Park, it became appalling when bizarre visitors began carving initials into the giant sequoias and painting the granite with spray paints, x. If they wanted a large rock for their garden just bring the pick-up and a sledgehammer. Jesus H Christ…

Leave a Reply