Trump Claims Chief Boy Scout Declared His Speech To Be “The Greatest Speech Ever Made”

280px-Boy_Scouts_of_America_corporate_trademark.svgdonald_trump_president-elect_portrait_croppedPresident Donald Trump has been widely criticized for his breaking an 80-year-old tradition in making political comments at the Boy Scouts National Jamboree in West Virginia.  When asked about the controversy, however, Trump refused to apologize and instead said that there were no “mixed” views at the event.  Rather, he said that the head of the Boy Scouts called him and told him it was “the greatest speech that was ever made to them.”  That comment left many scratching their heads since the Boy Scouts apologized to parents for the Presidents speech and said yesterday that they are unaware of any such telephone call.

 

Continue reading “Trump Claims Chief Boy Scout Declared His Speech To Be “The Greatest Speech Ever Made””

Montclair Professor Calls For Trump To Be Killed

download-1Women’s Studies Professor Kevin Allred at Montclair State University is back in the news.  Allred previously attracted national attention (while on the Rutgers faculty) after he was reportedly ordered to go through a psychiatric evaluation after students “felt threatened” by him following Trump’s election.  Now, Allred (who teaches a course on Beyonce) posted a comment that he hoped someone would kill Donald Trump.  As should come as little surprise to many who know my view of the First Amendment, I view this statement as protected speech and hyperbolic.  However, it was reckless, hateful, and worthy of condemnation.

Continue reading “Montclair Professor Calls For Trump To Be Killed”

Wash Post: Trump Personally Dictated Misleading Public Statement Of Trump Jr. On Russian Meeting

 

220px-Washington_Post_buildingdonald_trump_president-elect_portrait_croppedThe Washington Post is reporting that President Donald Trump personally dictated the misleading statement issued by Donald Trump Jr. about his meeting with a Russian leader — a meeting that was expressly set up to received damaging information from the Russian government on Hillary Clinton.  The report that the President became personally involved in the statement — which inaccurately portrayed the meeting — is yet another example of an operation that has stumbled through scandal after scandal.  Where most Administrations would have actively insulated the President from any role in the statement, Trump directed events and dictated the four-line statement that would be issued by his son.

Continue reading “Wash Post: Trump Personally Dictated Misleading Public Statement Of Trump Jr. On Russian Meeting”

Trump’s “Favorite” Poll Shows Sharp Decline in Support With 61 Percent Disapproval

donald_trump_president-elect_portrait_croppedRasmussen’s daily Presidential Tracking Poll was often been cited by  President Donald Trump as his favorite poll.  Rasmussen is viewed as right-leaning and has generally shown Trump with higher polls than other polls.  The most recent poll however shows a sharp decline in support for Trump with 61 percent of likely voters now disapproving of Trump’s performance as president.

Continue reading “Trump’s “Favorite” Poll Shows Sharp Decline in Support With 61 Percent Disapproval”

Trump Calls On Police To Be Rougher In Handling Suspects In Speech Denounced By Police Organizations

Controversial statements by President Donald Trump in the past have often been treated by his supporters as hyperbole or not to be taken strictly or even seriously.  However, a speech last Friday had some particularly chilling elements for anyone who believes in the rule of the law.  Trump was speaking to law enforcement officers and urged them not to be “too nice” to suspected criminals and gang members.  He further seemed to encourage intentional acts of harm and abuse in the handling of prisoners. The comments were irresponsible and should be be corrected by the White House.  We recently discussed Trump’s praise for Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte, who has bragged about extrajudicial killings and encouraged police abuse.  This is obviously not that extreme but it is still highly disturbing in a speech where the President has pledged that “We have your backs 100 percent” while encouraging them to be rough in handling of suspects. His comments have led to police organizations publicly rejecting the comments and assuring the public that they will not engage in such conduct.

Continue reading “Trump Calls On Police To Be Rougher In Handling Suspects In Speech Denounced By Police Organizations”

Michigan Supreme Court Rules That Police Can Charge Man For Drunk Driving On His Own Driveway

There is an interesting case out of Michigan where the Michigan Supreme Court ruled that a man can be charged with driving while intoxicated on his own private driveway.  The case against Gino Rea of Northville was reinstated in this decision (PDF) after the court found that the law encompasses any area accessible to motor vehicles, even if it is on private property.

Continue reading “Michigan Supreme Court Rules That Police Can Charge Man For Drunk Driving On His Own Driveway”

Oregon Case Renews Debate Over Sanctuary Laws

Sergio_Jose_Martinez_31_1501021110440_10127549_ver1.0The case of Sergio Jose Martinez, 31, in Portland, Oregon is likely to magnify the current debate over sanctuary cities.  Martinez broke into the home of a 65-year-old woman and sexual assaulted her. He then stole her car and proceeded to assault another woman.  He was finally arrested after a chase by police. It was discovered that Martinez was previously arrested and, despite a long criminal history and an immigration detainer, was released by authorities.  He has been deported 20 previous times and has at least five probation violations.

Continue reading “Oregon Case Renews Debate Over Sanctuary Laws”

The Health Care Debate We Should Be Having-Part One

By Mike Appleton, Weekend Contributor

“We’re going to have insurance for everybody. There was a philosophy in some circles that if you can’t pay for it, you don’t get it. That’s not going to happen with us. . . . It will be in a much simplified form. Much less expensive and much better.”

-President-elect Donald Trump, Washington Post (January 15, 2017)

Even if one supports the Affordable Care Act, there was nothing satisfying about watching the legislative circus over repeal and replacement unfold in the Senate over the past few weeks. To an outsider the entire process appeared disjointed and at times almost incoherent. It became increasingly impossible to fathom what Senate Republicans were trying to accomplish. So when the final effort, an eight-page bill apparently drafted over lunch, was rejected in a 51-49 vote, the most appropriate emotional response was neither elation nor disappointment, merely exhaustion.

Efforts to lay blame for the debacle have already begun, of course. Reince Preibus has been summarily booted from the White House and the three Republicans who defied Mitch McConnell by voting against the so-called “skinny” repeal bill have been castigated by the right. But it would be wrong to think that there isn’t a way forward. That first requires that we dispel several misconceptions. Continue reading “The Health Care Debate We Should Be Having-Part One”

Scaramucci’s Profane Tirade Is No “Italian Thing”

scaramucciBelow is my column in USA Today on the profane and shocking statements by the new White House Communications Director Anthony Scaramucci.  The staements were later defended as “an Italian thing.”  The suggestion was that this was just a form of Italian venting.  It was not.  First, as someone raised in a Sicilian family, I would not have been able to sit for a month if I ever spoke like that to anyone.  Indeed, we just celebrated the 90th birthday of my mother, Angela Piazza Turley,  in Chicago. If she read such statements by me in the press, I would have been met with a cane at the door.  Second, this was not venting. It was raving and seriously undermined both Scaramucci and the Administration.

Here is the column:

Continue reading “Scaramucci’s Profane Tirade Is No “Italian Thing””

Chicago On Pace For Record Year Of Homicides With 400 Murders

Chicago_Police_StarI am in Chicago, my hometown, to celebrate my mother’s 90th birthday.  I always love coming home to his city, but which is beautiful in the summer.  I took the kids swimming in Lake Michigan with huge waves and a perfect day. However, the city is reeling from an ever-rising murder rate.  Just four years ago, the city passed 400 homicides around Thanksgiving.  We just passed that mark in July in what could be a record bloody year in the Windy City.

Continue reading “Chicago On Pace For Record Year Of Homicides With 400 Murders”

Going Full Springer: Scaramucci’s Tirade Sends White House Staff And GOP Members Scrambling For Cover

White House communications director Anthony Scaramucci on Thursday  has left the Trump Administration staggering around Washington with no one clearly in control of the staff and, ironically, an increase in leaks about Scaramucci and fears of the President’s staff.  In the meantime, the crude comments of Scaramucci have undermined any effort of the White House to convey strength after the stinging defeat of the “skinny” health care bill.  With Republicans in open revolt, the Scaramucci controversy conveys a team in disarray and division. This was the worst possible time to go full Jerry Springer.

Continue reading “Going Full Springer: Scaramucci’s Tirade Sends White House Staff And GOP Members Scrambling For Cover”

Boy Scouts Apologize To Parents For Trump’s Jamboree Speech But White House Declines To Apologize


Many were surprised — and a bit saddened — to hear President Donald Trump give a highly partisan speech at the National Scout Jamboree.  For roughly 80 years, Presidents have avoided political speeches at the event. That tradition was shattered in a big way by Trump on Monday before 40,000 scouts.  Now the Boy Scouts of America has issued a formal apology to all of the parents about the content of Trump’s speech — a stinging rebuke for the President.  The White House responded by refusing to apologize from the departure of 80 years of precedent.

 

Continue reading “Boy Scouts Apologize To Parents For Trump’s Jamboree Speech But White House Declines To Apologize”

The Doomsday Scenario: How Replacing Sessions Could Trigger A Cascading Series Of Unfortunate Events

Superman_Doomsday_logojeff_sessions_official_portraitBelow is my column in USA Today on the possibility of a “Doomsday scenario” where President Donald Trump first fired (or forces the resignation) of Jeff Sessions and then moves to fire Special Counsel Robert Mueller.  That scenario was reinforced yesterday with reports that Trump has discussed firing Sessions and giving a recess appointment to his successor — the very scenario laid out earlier in this column.   In addition, Trump blasted Sessions again yesterday — this time criticizing him for not replacing Acting FBI Director Andrew McCabe, whose wife ran for office in Virginia in 2015 and received large contributions from the Democratic Party.   

Trump’s unrelenting criticism of Sessions is occurring at the same time as new leaks about his discussing not just a replacement but a recess appointment — something the Democrats have vowed to prevent.  The question is whether some Republicans might join in that effort to prevent the type of Doomsday scenario laid out in this earlier column.

Continue reading “The Doomsday Scenario: How Replacing Sessions Could Trigger A Cascading Series Of Unfortunate Events”

Judge Richard Posner Declares Support For Supreme Court Expansion Proposal

I have previously discussed the legendary career of Judge Richard Posner of the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit.  Widely viewed as the father of Law and Economics, Posner remains one of greatest influences on American jurisprudence in the history of this country.  I have long been a great admirer of his work and teach his theories as part of my torts course.  It is for that reason that I was delighted when my co-counsel sent me the interview below where Judge Posner expressed support for the proposal that I have advanced for many years to reform the Supreme Court.  Posner agrees with the proposal to expand the Supreme Court to nineteen members.

Continue reading “Judge Richard Posner Declares Support For Supreme Court Expansion Proposal”

Michigan Judge Threatens To Throw Out Plea Bargain After Murderer Smirks Through Victim Statement

Screen Shot 2017-07-26 at 10.49.07 PM.pngDefense counsel often discuss demeanor in court with our clients.  One thing that we all agree on is that it is a uniquely bad idea to smirk during victim statements, particularly in a murder case.  That is one lesson Danta Wright, 17, did not learn and it almost cost him the plea bargain negotiated with prosecutors.

Continue reading “Michigan Judge Threatens To Throw Out Plea Bargain After Murderer Smirks Through Victim Statement”