Bizarre, Constitutional Law, Criminal law, Free Speech, International, Politics, Society

Russia Moves To Shoot Down Turkish History: New Legislation Would Make Denial Of Armenian Genocide A Crime

260px-MarcharmeniansThe Russians appear to be moving in the aftermath of Turkey shooting down one of its fighters: it has targeted Turkish history in a new and abusive criminal law. Russian lawmaker Sergei Mironov said that his Just Russia party has proposed a bill that criminalizes the denial that the 1915 killings of Armenians by Ottoman Turkish forces was a “genocide.” I previously wrote about a similar law passed in France as not just a denial of free speech but academic freedom. The law was later struck down. The Russians are moving just weeks after the European Court of Human Rights ruled that Switzerland also violation freedom of speech for its criminalization of the denial of the killings of Armenians as genocide.

The Russian bill is clearly a peevish response to the Turkish engagement on the Syrian border. However, Mironov and his party wants to strike out against history and free speech in an act of retaliation.

“We have just submitted a bill on responsibility for failure to acknowledge the fact of a genocide of Armenians by Turkey in 1915,” Mironov, the leader of the opposition Just Russia party, said on his Twitter account, a day after the Turkish air force shot down a Russian jet.

Various respected academics have supported the claim of genocide by Turkey despite the denials of that country. However, this debate is not won by forcing those who disagree into forced silence. It is anti-intellectual. It is anti-free speech. It is wrong.

The latest case by the European Court of Human Rights found that Switzerland violated a Turkish politician’s right to freedom of speech by convicting Dogu Perincek for denying that the 1915 Armenian killings in the Ottoman empire constituted a genocide: “It was undisputed that Perincek’s conviction and punishment, together with the order to pay compensation to the Switzerland-Armenia Association, had constituted an interference with the exercise of his right to freedom of expression.”

The denial of the Armenian Genocide is officially outlawed in Turkey’s long-standing antagonist, Greece as well as Cyprus and Slovakia.

Baron Carl von Clausewitz said “War is a mere continuation of politics by other means.” It appears so is history.

12 thoughts on “Russia Moves To Shoot Down Turkish History: New Legislation Would Make Denial Of Armenian Genocide A Crime”

  1. “Russia is the hope of the world’. – Edgar Cayce And Vladimir Putin is my hero; end of story. I’m very glad to see many here aren’t swallowing the “Russian aggression” rot.

  3. This is a disservice to history. But, considering it is already illegal in “Free” Western Europe to “Deny the Holocaust,” and since more Russian died in WW2 than Jews, and now the Israelis are teamed up with the Saudis and IS to attack Russians, who can blame them.

  4. I do believe Turkey engaged in genocide of the Armenians.

    I also support free speech. Criminalizing opinions is anathema to free speech. We need to safeguard our own rights, because we can see the result of a lack of robust free speech rights.

  7. If Russia wants to give Turkey some payback, then arm the Kurds with SAM’s.

    So while the United States had long sought Turkey’s help in fighting ISIS, the events since the agreement reveal the tangle of diverging interests in the region.

    Strange, Kurds are fighting ISIS but on the same day that Turkey announced it would help fight the Islamic State,
    Turkish forces began an airstrike campaign against one of the very groups that has been crucial to stopping the advance of the Islamic State. The Kurds.

  9. Good for Russia, the Turks (Operation Gladio member) committed atrocities in Cyprus during their invasion/occupation and they regularly threaten Greece. Armenia is important to Russia but friendship with Turkey demanded diplomacy, that friendship has been shown to have been a sham. The Turks have also threatened Paraguay for recognising the Armenian genocide. Russia, an independent nation, has every right to place emphasis on its other relationships same as for other independent nations.

  11. Thought crimes increase. You can be sure the passage of this legislation has nothing to do with the love Puttin has for the Armenians! Will he try to enforce this law extra territorially?

Comments are closed.