Nuremberg Revisited: Obama Administration Files To Dismiss Case Against John Yoo

John Yoo is being defended in court this month by the Administration. Not the Bush Administration. The Obama Administration. As with the lawsuits over electronic surveillance and torture, the Obama administration wants the lawsuit against Yoo dismissed and is defending the right of Justice Department officials to help establish a torture program — an established war crime. I will be discussing the issue on this segment of MSNBC Countdown.

The Obama Administration has filed a brief that brushes over the war crimes aspects of Yoo’s work at the Justice Department. Instead, it insists that attorneys must be free to give advice — even if it is to establish a torture program.

In its filing before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, the Justice Department insists that there is “the risk of deterring full and frank advice regarding the military’s detention and treatment of those determined to be enemies during an armed conflict.” Instead it argues that the Justice Department has other means to punish lawyers like the Office of Professional Responsibility. Of course, the Bush Administration effectively blocked such investigations and Yoo is no longer with the Justice Department. The OPR has been dismissed as ineffectual, including in an ABA Journal, as the Justice Department’s “roach motel”—“the cases go in, but nothing ever comes out.”

The Justice Department first defended Yoo as counsel and then paid for private counsel to represent him (here). His public-funded private counsel is Miguel Estrada, who was forced to withdraw his nomination by George Bush for the Court of Appeals after strong opposition from the Democrats.

Yoo is being sued by Jose Padilla, who was effectively blocked in contesting his abusive confinement and mistreatment as part of this criminal case and in a habeas action. The Bush Administration brought new charges to moot a case before the Supreme Court could rule. The Court previously sent his case back on a technicality.

It is important to note that the Administration did not have to file this brief since it had withdrawn as counsel and paid for Yoo’s private counsel. It has decided that it wants to establish the law claimed by the Bush Administration protecting Justice officials who support alleged war crimes. They are effectively doubling down by withdrawing as counsel and then reappearing as a non-party amicus.

The Obama Administration has gutted the hard-fought victories in Nuremberg where lawyers and judges were often guilty of war crimes in their legal advice and opinions. The third of the twelve trials for war crimes involved 16 German jurists and lawyers. Nine had been officials of the Reich Ministry of Justice, the others were prosecutors and judges of the Special Courts and People’s Courts of Nazi Germany. It would have been a larger group but two lawyers committed suicide before trial: Adolf Georg Thierack, former minister of justice, and Carl Westphal, a ministerial counsellor.

They included Herbert Klemm, who was sentenced to life imprisonment and served as minister of justice, director of the Ministry’s Legal Education and Training Division, and deputy director of the National Socialist Lawyer’s League.

Oswald Rothaug received life imprisonment for his role as a prosecutor and later a judge.

Wilhelm von Ammon received ten years for his work as a justice official in occupied areas.

Guenther Joel received ten years for being an adviser (like Yoo) to the Ministry of Justice and later a judge.

Curt Rothenberger was also a legal adviser and was given seven years for his writings at the Ministry of Justice and as the deputy president of the Academy of German Law

Wolfgang Mettgenberg received ten years as representative of the Criminal Legislation Administration Division of the Ministry of Justice,

Ernst Lautz (10 years) had been chief public prosecutor of the People’s Court.

Franz Schlegelberger, a former Ministry of Justice official, was convicted and sentenced to life for conspiracy and other war crimes. The court found:

‘…that Schlegelberger supported the pretension of Hitler in his assumption of power to deal with life and death in disregard of even the pretense of judicial process. By his exhortations and directives, Schlegelberger contributed to the destruction of judicial independence. It was his signature on the decree of 7 February 1942 which imposed upon the Ministry of Justice and the courts the burden of the prosecution, trial, and disposal of the victims of Hitler’s Night and Fog. For this he must be charged with primary responsibility.

‘He was guilty of instituting and supporting procedures for the wholesale persecution of Jews and Poles. Concerning Jews, his ideas were less brutal than those of his associates, but they can scarcely be called humane. When the “final solution of the Jewish question” was under discussion, the question arose as to the disposition of half-Jews. The deportation of full Jews to the East was then in full swing throughout Germany. Schlegelberger was unwilling to extend the system to half-Jews.’

It was the “ideas” that these lawyers advanced that made the war crimes possible. Other officials were tried but acquitted. All of these officials used arguments similar to those in the Obama Administration’s brief of why lawyers are not responsible for war crimes that they defend and justify. Bush selected people like Yoo to justify the war crime of torture. If they had written against it, the Administration might have abandoned the effort. The CIA director and others were already concerned about the prospect of prosecution. The Obama Administration’s brief revisits Nuremberg and sweeps away such quaint notions. Indeed, the brief for Yoo could have been used directly to support legal advisers Wolfgang Mettgenberg, Guenther Joel, and Wilhelm von Ammon.

If successful in this case, the Obama Administration will succeed in returning the world to the rules leading to the war crimes at Nuremberg. Quite a legacy for the world’s newest Nobel Peace Prize winner.

Defenders of the Administration insist that the brief does not expressly gut Nuremberg or reference war crimes. Of course, that is the point. The brief does not make any exception for liability for legal advice when it is part of a torture program or war crime. When combined with the Administration’s refusal to appoint a special prosecutor for the torture program (and the President’s promise that no CIA employees would be prosecuted), the brief closes the circle: there will be no criminal or civil liability for the war crimes committed by the Bush Administration.

The only reference to substantive criminal prosecution is in the following abstract statement:

That is not to say that the actions of a Department of Justice attorney providing advice should go unchecked. Department of Justice attorneys, if they abuse their authority, are subject to possible state and federal bar sanctions, see 28 U.S.C. § 530B, investigation by both the Office of Professional Responsibility and the Office of the Inspector General, as well as criminal investigation and prosecution, where appropriate. If Congress believes that additional avenues of recourse are necessary in cases where Department of Justice attorneys provide legal advice regarding matters relating to war powers and national security, it could enact appropriate legislation. Given the sensitivities of such claims, and the risk of deterring full and frank advice regarding matters of national security, however, this is a clear case where “special factors” strongly counsel against the recognition of a Bivens action.

“[W]here appropriate” are the key words. The Administration has already blocked criminal prosecution for torture. More importantly, this case is about Yoo’s involvement in creating that program. However, even in assisting in the establishment of a torture program, the Administration insists that there can not be civil liability (let alone criminal liability). If the Administration wanted to maintain the rule created at Nuremberg, it would have stated clearly that no privilege or law protects a lawyer who is assisting in the establishment of a war crime or torture program. Of course, the Administration has already said the opposite. Obama and Holder have stated that “just following orders” is a complete defense for CIA employees (here).

The effort to ignore the clear position of this Administration shows the dangers of a cult of personality. Just as conservatives ignored Bush’s violation of core conservative values on the budget and big government, some liberals are ignoring Obama’s violation of core liberal values on civil liberties and privacy.

For the DOJ brief, click here.

182 thoughts on “Nuremberg Revisited: Obama Administration Files To Dismiss Case Against John Yoo”

  1. Mr. Turley, I want to thank you for your many appearances on Keith Olbermann’s MSNBC program. You do a great service to the Bar and your presentation and demeanor do much to inform laypeople on the outrageous conduct of the Bush Administration and the mind-boggling behavior of the Obama Administration. This behavior is clearly not change we can believe in and I hope you will continue your work.

  2. I had such high hopes as a supporter of this President.
    I am outraged, disgusted, and so disppointed in this administration.

    The President is gambling with his base (they think we will forget) and is quickly ensuring that he will not be re-elected. No one to blame but himself

  3. I voted for change and not for a continuation of Bush administration policies. Prior to the national election, I spoke with my representative about pursuing the law-breaking of the Bush administration. He told me he would support efforts to bring people who broke our laws to justice.

    Is it all just lip-service and hollow campaign promises?

    Apparently so.

    Thank you Mr. Turley and Mr. Olbermann for an open and intelligent discussion as always.

  4. lottakatz,

    I think you should have sent Obama back his own letter and asked for his help, $5.00 or whatever, to help you achieve Universal, single payer coverage. Then submit your own website to Obama for his contribution to the cause! Everyone who got that stupid e-mail should do the same thing. That could be interesting.

  5. This case is especially disturbing because they did not have to file anything in this case. We taxpayers are already paying for his private attorney so why are we paying for a Justice attorney to file an amicus brief as well?

  6. The Professor is on Olbermann (as I type) giving his views on this case- he’s kind’a pissed it seems, voice went up a bit there 🙂 You go Prof! Good on you.

  7. rcampbell 1, December 9, 2009 at 7:21 pm
    “WTF!!! This on the heels of the Senate Democrats’ and the President’s blatant and massive capitulation to the insurance industry on health care reform …”
    ———–

    I was one of the people that recieved an e-mail over President Obama’s signature asking for money and promising to ‘never give up’ on health carereform. I opened the email during “The Ed Show” and went ballistic. I replied of course:

    Original letter:

    (My name removed)

    “As we head into the final stretch on health reform, big insurance company lobbyists and their partisan allies hope that their relentless attacks and millions of dollars can intimidate us into accepting the status quo.

    So I have a message for them, from all of us: Not this time. We have come too far. We will not turn back. We will not back down.

    But do not doubt — the opponents of reform will not rest. So I need you to fight alongside me.

    We must continue to build out our campaign — to spread the facts on the air and on the ground, and to bring in more volunteers and train them to join the fight. I urgently need your help to keep this 50-state movement for reform going strong.

    Please donate $5 or whatever you can afford today:

    http://my.democrats.org/FinalStretch

    Let’s win this together,

    President Barack Obama”

    +++++
    My reply:

    “Where is universal coverage or a strong public option? Unless there is a strong public option or universal care ‘health reform’ is just a give away to the health insurance companies and through my taxes I’ll not only pay almost 5K for my own insurance (the employer pays about 7K) but subsidies for others mandated by law to join the insurance scam. Meanwhile, my rate raise letter for next year has already been sent to me (12%) along with a listing of my REDUCED benefits. And you want me to send you money? So you can do what, help elect more Democratic quislings? Buy Joe Lieberman a holiday gift for all of his support on this issue. I had been a lifelong Democrat but you folks are just to pitiful for me to support anymore with money or votes. Shame on you.

    Fee free to write me again when there is a final signed bill that has universal coverage or a strong and effective public option.

    (My name removed)”

    ++++

    They have some nerve.

  8. I’m just posting this in case anyone hasn’t seen the video of Yoo’s testimony in June 2008, in the House Judiciary Subcommittee Hearing on Detainee Interrogation, being asked by Rep. John Conyers (D-MI):

    “I didn’t ask Yoo if Yoo ever gave him [that] advice! I asked Yoo, ‘Do Yoo think the president could order a suspect buried alive?!?'”

  9. “His public-funded private counsel…”
    _________________________________

    This is salt in the eyes and the wounds of injustice.

    S-Mom,

    As a longtime Republican, I had to virtually force myself to vote for Obama. However, as you say, he was the only candidate for whom I could vote. I had an obligation to vote since I did not vote in 2000 because I saw what Bush was and I could not/cannot stand Gore’s V.P. pick Joe Lieberman.

  10. Swarthmore mom:

    you are right, hopefully in 2012 there will be decent people on both the top tickets. although my side doesn’t look too good at this point. Mostly religious right compassionate conservatives. I had my fill of those with W, never again.

  11. Here is what free advice concerning torture legally consists of: Torture is against the law of the US. It is against international law. You may not legally engage in any form of torture. Would you like to go over any and all circumstances in which you, Mr. President, feel torture is legal? Let me go through those with you one by one and I will tell you why you may not engage in torture under any circumstances, even those you have just mentioned. If you persist in going ahead, I will resign and make public each and every one of my objections to your proposed/actual use of torture.

    There you have it. Free and fair advice, based on the law, not how to subvert the law but how to follow it. The executive and his minions are not free of the law, they are bound by it. The president takes his one and only oath to faithfully execute the laws of the United States. I know this won’t happen, because it never did with Bush, but Obama should be impeached.

  12. Byron There was no one else to vote for. Hillary is about the same as Obama. We know what happened to Edwards. We were not going to vote for McCain-Palin.

  13. what did you expect from him? he is all smoke and mirrors, a fabrication created by others and used as a tool by others.

    Bush snookered me, welcome to the club of people who wished they had voted for someone else.

  14. Holder and Obama were more quickly corrupted by power than any men I have seen in my lifetime.

    Rcampbell, I voted for Obama because I did not want a Republican in the W.H.; however, we have even gotten something worse. What a gut-wrenching hypocrite for whom I voted, thinking that no one in my Party was uncorrupted enough to run this country for at least 8 years.

    There has to be a way to stop this maddening abuse of this Executive power.

    On legal principle alone, I would think that any noncorrupt lawyer would be outraged by what is happening here.

  15. WTF!!!

    This on the heels of the Senate Democrats’ and the President’s blatant and massive capitulation to the insurance industry on health care reform is too much. Obama a Socialist? Hardly! In my view, he may as well be called a Republican.

Comments are closed.