Today, we filed the complaint below in the challenge to Utah’s criminal polygamy law. I am still in Salt Lake City for the filing. With me today is our local counsel Adam Alba, an outstanding young attorney and one of my former students. As noted earlier, the lawsuit is on behalf of my clients, the Brown family. The Browns are featured in the TLC program Sister Wives as an openly polygamous family.
The Plaintiffs are Kody Brown, Christine Brown, Janelle Brown, Meri Brown, and Robyn Sullivan.
The Defendants are Governor Gary Herbert, Attorney General Mark Shurtleff, and County Attorney Jeffrey R. Buhman.
There are seven claims for relief:
Claim One: Due Process
Claim Two: Equal Protection
Claim Three: Free Exercise
Claim Four: Free Speech
Claim Five: Freedom of Association
Claim Six: Establishment of Religion
Claim Seven: 42 U.S.C. § 1983
As in past cases, I will have to be circumspect in what I say after the filing of this action. However, we are honored to represent the Brown family in this historic challenge,” said Professor Turley. “We believe that this case represents the strongest factual and legal basis for a challenge to the criminalization of polygamy ever filed in the federal courts. We are not demanding the recognition of polygamous marriage. We are only challenging the right of the state to prosecute people for their private relations and demanding equal treatment with other citizens in living their lives according to their own beliefs. This action seeks to protect one of the defining principles of this country, what Justice Louis Brandeis called ‘the right to be left alone.’ In that sense, it is a challenge designed to benefit not just polygamists but all citizens who wish to live their lives according to their own values – even if those values run counter to those of the majority in the state.
The following is the statement from Kody Brown, which will be the only statement at this time on the filing:
Statement of Kody Brown:
“There are tens of thousands of plural families in Utah and other states. We are one of those families. We only wish to live our private lives according to our beliefs. While we understand that this may be a long struggle in court, it has already been a long struggle for my family and other plural families to end the stereotypes and unfair treatment given consensual polygamy. We are indebted to Professor Turley and his team for their work and dedication. Together we hope to secure equal treatment with other families in the United States.”
Here is the complaint filed today: Brown Complaint
Jonathan Turley
Bob,
How exactly does entering into a relationship voluntarily where one may have an unequal position comport to a violation of equality as long as consent was valid? What about the rich guy who marries an unskilled unemployed woman? They are not in equitable positions either, but there is no gender based class argument being made against that inequity? Marriages, like lots of relationships, often have dominant and subservient parties. As long as entry into that relationship is consensual and valid, I’m not sure where I see where you are going with Brown considering that was based on forced racial segregation where consent was vitiated as a matter of state policy.
Mike,
Steve McQueen couldn’t hold a candle to William Holden in Stalag 17. Incredible wit, steel resolve, the essence of ‘cool’ and the perfect mindset to adopt when surrounded by mindless jingoism.
Elaine,
Just so we are clear on terms, when I say valid consent I mean that consent is informed, is freely, mindfully, and actively given, uses mutually understandable words or actions, and indicates a willingness to engage in mutually agreed upon sexual activity. In your example, informed and freely are compromised as are possibly mutually understandable language.
Well Gene,
I’d probably fire a few emails back and forth with Mespo, who’s put a lot more thought in this matter than I, and in those emails I’d probably start out by saying this policy of treating women as collectibles has a Brown v. Board of Ed. feel to it. You know, marrying many women tends to treat those women less equally than in a monogamous relationship.
What do you think Mespo?
Elaine,
And I have no issue with regulation of that kind of practice, just with criminalizing polygamy in general. You’re talking about a situation where valid consent is compromised.
If anyone wants to read Boerne v Flores, here it is . . .
http://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/95-2074.ZO.html
Gene H.,
Please note that the first comment that I made was in response to something that Mike S. had written.
Mike S. wrote: “However, I will defend the right of individual, non-conforming Mormon’s to adhere to what they believe are the true Mormon teachings of their Prophet.”
My response: I’d say we must be cautious about defending certain rights of individuals regarding the adherence to the teachings/practices of their churches. Some FDLS groups force young women into marriages with much older men. In some cases, the women are practically held captive.
“Other than William Holden in “Stalag 17,”
Bob,
We may disagree on this topic, but that was one hell of a movie. Having seen it when I was young I don’t remember the exact dialogue, but as he was going down the trap door Holden said something to the effect of if I ever see one of you guys again don’t bother to say hello. A great ending and response to his ill treatment.
Elaine,
No, you didn’t, but that’s what the case is about.
Bob,
Could you come up with a reason a policy argument that didn’t simply cater to male ego or to a particular flavor of Christianity? What’s your argument against it contractually? Constitutionally? I’d also like to hear them if you want to argue that people of age and able form valid consent don’t have a fundamental right to shack up irregardless of whether you approve of the form or not. I’d like to hear them if you want to make them. If not, that’s okay too.
Gene H.,
I didn’t say anything about criminalizing polygamy.
The drawback of any closed society is that children are subject to training that predisposes them to certain beliefs that are not necessarily in their best interest, such as women being submissive to men, marrying early etc. This is a wider problem than just the Mormon faith. It is widespread among fundamentalists and works to stifle a young woman from reaching what might be her full potential. I have a problem with that whole mindset but I don’t think it’s illegal.
The problem with a polygamist system where few men may have many wives but some or a large number of males may not is that the community ceases to grow in any stable fashion. If that’s not the case now where polygamy, while not legal, is ignored by the state why should that change dramatically if the law is changed? Is there some pent up demand among the available pool of women for some few attractive men that would change the equation?
If the concern is that women have a diminished ability to refuse a proposal of spiritual marriage then that changes the equation regarding the tenant of consent which should be a prerequisite in all marriages and associations. Either the law should be changed to remove all prohibitions to free association or the law needs to be enforced fairly and vigorously among all of Utah’s citizens.
Thanks for the info Elaine. I’ve read about the ‘lost boys’ in the past and frankly do not understand how a community can legally get away with that. Children younger than the age of emancipation can’t just be thrown away and no citizen can be ‘run out of town’, literally driven to another city and shoved out of a car. I would think that this is a criminal matter that comes of the state not enforcing laws already on its books. Maybe the lost boys need to ask about the legality of what happened to them as a class in a civil court.
kderosa,
It really doesn’t matter. I don’t see a rational basis for criminalizing polygamy either. But thanks for pointing me toward Boerne v Flores. The last time I had any occasion to look at law concerning Free Exercise was several years ago when the RFRA was still in play (which did have the compelling interest standard). There’s a lot wrong with that Flores decision, more than just what readily meets the eye, but then again, the Rehnquist court was only marginally better than the Roberts court.
For the record, I think Mespo earned the kewpie doll on this issue. I think those opinions were expressed on the other thread. Regardless, my distaste for this topic brings me back to what I said earlier about marriage itself; i.e. that it is not a fundamental right but a civil right created by society. And to be brutally honest, were I to invest any meaningful amount of time into this matter, I would probably wind up working out arguments against polygamy.
@GeneH, the test is rational basis not compelling interest.
Elaine,
You bring up a good point. Free exercise does have rational limits but those limits should always be considered in light of a competing compelling state interest. For example, not permitting human sacrifices reflects a compelling state interest. I fail to see any compelling state interests in criminalizing polygamy as long as the same safeguards that apply to other forms of marriage apply (parties must be of age of majority, valid consent, etc.) are applied.
Elaine,
I completely agree that religious conviction is not an exemption from the law or rational morality. However Miles seemed to be implying that because Hitler ate sandwiches, hoagies are evil.
““We don’t sell women into marriage in this country like they do in Saudi Arabia and parts of India.”
Once again proving that “haste/Hell” statement. 😉 I should stop trying to type as fast as I think. 🙄
MASkeptic,
My point in leaving my previous comment about some FDLS groups and Warren Jeffs was–as I stated earlier–to suggest we should be cautious about defending certain rights of individuals regarding the adherence to the teachings/practices of their churches.
MASkeptic,
You are welcome. I’m glad to have been helpful, but I think eloquence might have been better served if I had not left the word “marriage” out of “We don’t sell women into marriage this country like they do in Saudi Arabia and parts of India.” 🙂 Hell hath no fury like a post comment button pushed in haste.