Today, we filed the complaint below in the challenge to Utah’s criminal polygamy law. I am still in Salt Lake City for the filing. With me today is our local counsel Adam Alba, an outstanding young attorney and one of my former students. As noted earlier, the lawsuit is on behalf of my clients, the Brown family. The Browns are featured in the TLC program Sister Wives as an openly polygamous family.
The Plaintiffs are Kody Brown, Christine Brown, Janelle Brown, Meri Brown, and Robyn Sullivan.
The Defendants are Governor Gary Herbert, Attorney General Mark Shurtleff, and County Attorney Jeffrey R. Buhman.
There are seven claims for relief:
Claim One: Due Process
Claim Two: Equal Protection
Claim Three: Free Exercise
Claim Four: Free Speech
Claim Five: Freedom of Association
Claim Six: Establishment of Religion
Claim Seven: 42 U.S.C. § 1983
As in past cases, I will have to be circumspect in what I say after the filing of this action. However, we are honored to represent the Brown family in this historic challenge,” said Professor Turley. “We believe that this case represents the strongest factual and legal basis for a challenge to the criminalization of polygamy ever filed in the federal courts. We are not demanding the recognition of polygamous marriage. We are only challenging the right of the state to prosecute people for their private relations and demanding equal treatment with other citizens in living their lives according to their own beliefs. This action seeks to protect one of the defining principles of this country, what Justice Louis Brandeis called ‘the right to be left alone.’ In that sense, it is a challenge designed to benefit not just polygamists but all citizens who wish to live their lives according to their own values – even if those values run counter to those of the majority in the state.
The following is the statement from Kody Brown, which will be the only statement at this time on the filing:
Statement of Kody Brown:
“There are tens of thousands of plural families in Utah and other states. We are one of those families. We only wish to live our private lives according to our beliefs. While we understand that this may be a long struggle in court, it has already been a long struggle for my family and other plural families to end the stereotypes and unfair treatment given consensual polygamy. We are indebted to Professor Turley and his team for their work and dedication. Together we hope to secure equal treatment with other families in the United States.”
Here is the complaint filed today: Brown Complaint
Jonathan Turley
Mespo,
I institutionally see a Brown v. Board of Ed. type argument working here. It’s not the lying eyes so much as what the eyes are lying about.
The price for that form of refuge is the inherent devaluing of the woman and the denigrating of her sense of self as COMPLETE equal.
Then throw on all your other observations…
Polygamy is in no way equal to monogamy per the treatment of women.
I see a lot of mean assuming that women don’t favor polygamy because they don’t. Females tend to be hypergamous, men tend not to be. As you can see from the current dating market at colleges, young women bend over backwards for the most sought after men. Now it’s a winners take all game. Who’s to say that women might not prefer 1/5 an alpha male over the eventual beta male they will finally settle for down the round and then divorce.
Mike S:
With Bob’s approval I’m sure, we defer to a greater soul. Enjoy with our compliments.
False equivalence. Rape and slavery are not the same as a voluntary consensual relationship. Most guys don’t have the Horde to go out collecting women for them.
Bob and Mespo,
You’ll have to tear my kewpie doll out of my cold dead hands if you want it.
Mike S.,
“From what I saw of the first years shows the children seem fine and the family seems to raise them well.”
It’s a TV “reality” show. Appearances can be deceiving. Do you suppose the family would want to come across as dysfunctional on national TV? What are/were the motives of this polygamous family? I have to question how this family came to have its own show. I also have to question why, if polygamy is illegal in Utah, the family would want to broadcast it to the world.
I’m not accusing this family of anything–but I’m left to wonder about certain things. Call me a skeptic.
“Take a step back and look at it as a licensed institution that shapes society, and only then do you see its victims. That is, you would see them, if you looked.”
Miles,
From my last post above to Elaine, I addressed that concern. However, I disagree with you on another premise and that is that society’s are to be shaped by laws or a legal system. Who among us is that wise to know the effects on a society of any activity allowed/disallowed for years down the line? Prohibition was instituted to positively shape society away from intoxication. That was the essence of the argument for the Amendment. How did that work out? The War on Drugs is another example of trying to shape society’s mores, the country is losing.
In a country such as ours hopefully governed by a Constitution and with its citizens having the right of freedom, the idea of government shaping social norms is not a good one. Many people live lives that I personally don’t approve of, but as long as they break no laws and no laws are made unconstitutionally to ban their behavior, my attitude is live and let live. No good has ever come from legislating morality and no good ever will.
If one wanted to see just how locked out of reproduction beta males are in a polygamous society one only needs to look so far as the number of descendants of Genghis Khan there are.
Bob, Esq.:
I do agree that this whole arrangement has the feel of paternalism with women regarded as collectible trophy chattel. I fail to understand the advantages for women in a relationship which protects successor wives not at all in terms of intestate succession and separate maintenance. I see very little to be gained except some measure of security and perhaps it true as the Eagles told us in “Lying Eyes, that ” every form of refuge has its price.”
http://www.tudou.com/programs/view/cmCjwibhSN4/
Elaine,
I will say though that empirical evidence that it’s bad for children would be something I’d consider a valid reason for keeping polygamy criminalized. By bad for children too I mean some measurable detrimental effect other than just a predisposition to adopt their parents attitudes about polygamy. Something concrete and not a common thing in any parent/child relationship like an increased rate of depression or other mental health issues or the like.
Elaine,
I know of no such study, but perhaps Mike S. or OS would.
Bob,
Okay, I’d just need to see it in action to be convinced by that line of argument.
Gene H.,
“as long as all the participants are there voluntarily, of age and no one is harmed,…”
One would have to question whether the children of such marriages may be harmed. I don’t have the answer to that. Do you know if anyone has ever conducted a study/studies on the subject?
Miles,
I think perhaps you are exaggerating the general appeal of polygamy. I don’t know if you really think it’s that big a danger to society or if you’re simply engaging in scare tactics for whatever reason, but the simple facts concerning divorce rates in this country tend to belie any concern that polygamy is going to run rampant if allowed. Most people prefer simply monogamous relationships (regardless of gender) and have since the dawn of civilization. It is only a small percentage of people who would be interested in a polygamous arrangement in a free society where people cannot be bought and sold into marriage. It’s not like a Sheik building a harem. Most people aren’t going to want to enter into a polygamous relationship for the same reasons I’d never get into one: more parties take the complications inherent in a monogamous relationship if it should go wrong and multiply them. It’s a lot of potential hassle for a lifestyle – assuming that multiple sex partners is the driving criteria – that could be maintained by remaining single. If the goal is large communal family? Maybe some people see that hassle as a cost worth the benefit. However, to suggest that if polygamy were made legal that monogamy would be threatened and we’d suddenly have an excess of bachelor’s I think flies in the face of human nature.
“The range of human behavior is in the direction of being infinite and yet we mostly have so much in common in the way we feel. Other than in instances of exploitation, force or coercion, we should all be free to explore our heart’s desires, in all their possible complexities.”
Elaine,
At 4:10 pm today I posted the above quote on the other “Brown thread.” I chose the words “Other than in instances of exploitation, force or coercion”
carefully and I’ll explain why. Prominent in many of the arguments against
gay rights, gay marriage and gay adoption were charges that permitting these rights would encourage pedophilia. This would force many who are in favor of full equality for gay people to preclude this type of argument by asserting that of course pedophilia was wrong but……..etc. I’m well aware of the abuses of monsters like Jeffs and of the “lost boys” phenomena. I also stated on that thread that I’m not a fan of the LDS, or Mormonism in general and I’ve done some reading on the subject. All abuses of the type that come from people like Jeffs should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law. Instances of exploitation, force and/or coercion cover this reprehensible behavior.
There is, however, no particular correlation between the Brown Family (for whom I’ve already stated my distaste) and the well known abuses of certain Mormon fundamentalists. From what I saw of the first years shows the children seem fine and the family seems to raise them well. The wives of the family entered into this form of relationship without coercion. This family is not one, apparently, that would act in the manner of Jeffs, or the compounds that produce “lost boys.” I imagine there are many polygamous family’s where the family atmosphere is benevolent and beneficial. I also imagine there are many examples of polyandry in our country where the participants are closeted.
Would I encourage my single daughter to enter into a polygamous marriage, no I wouldn’t and would try to talk her out of it. I’ve raised my daughters to be independent women and so my opinion wouldn’t sway her. If she decided to, however, I would give her all the support she needed. Knowing her I doubt that route is on her horizon.
lottakatz,
Well said!
“and no one is harmed”
The Brown v. Board of Ed. angle would set out to show just who is harmed and why.
Bob,
I’d have to see that fleshed out because I’m having a real hard time with chattels being able to grant valid consent. Don’t get me wrong. As a practical concern I think polygamy is generally one of the worst ideas in the history of bad ideas, but as a civil liberties matter, as long as all the participants are there voluntarily, of age and no one is harmed, I have to go with the choice that grants the individuals their choice over societal preference.
If you continue to debate polygamy in terms of the people allowed in, it can look like a joyous realization of religious freedom, personal choice, etc.
Take a step back and look at it as a licensed institution that shapes society, and only then do you see its victims. That is, you would see them, if you looked.
The male victims of polygamy are invisible, driven away, and not in the courtroom where Mr.Turley will be helping some happy family appeal for its right to be a family like any other.
The victims of a polygamist social system are wounded, abused, dispirited and they have no fancy lawyers like Mr. Turley. Indeed, I don’t even know what legal standing they have. But I do know what moral standing they have.
The number of polygamists is small today, and their thrown away young men can still go off to swim in the larger ocean of the US population where potential mates can still be found, so for now their fate will go unnoticed.
But multiply the number of polygamist families, and you’ll see what will happen. It won’t be pretty, and Mr. Turley will have had a role in bringing it about.
Gene,
Separate is not necessarily equal. Consent does not necessitate lack of harm to the women or society.
Brown was all about the psychological and sociological damage done by separate but equal.
Thus the argument becomes that one cannot equate polygamy with monogamy because (for instance) it treats women as collectible chattels.
[Insert all the other crap wrong with it as expressed by Mespo in the other thread here: ]
Like I said, I can conceive of a template for an argument, but I’d need someone like Mespo to flesh it out.