Today, we filed the complaint below in the challenge to Utah’s criminal polygamy law. I am still in Salt Lake City for the filing. With me today is our local counsel Adam Alba, an outstanding young attorney and one of my former students. As noted earlier, the lawsuit is on behalf of my clients, the Brown family. The Browns are featured in the TLC program Sister Wives as an openly polygamous family.
The Plaintiffs are Kody Brown, Christine Brown, Janelle Brown, Meri Brown, and Robyn Sullivan.
The Defendants are Governor Gary Herbert, Attorney General Mark Shurtleff, and County Attorney Jeffrey R. Buhman.
There are seven claims for relief:
Claim One: Due Process
Claim Two: Equal Protection
Claim Three: Free Exercise
Claim Four: Free Speech
Claim Five: Freedom of Association
Claim Six: Establishment of Religion
Claim Seven: 42 U.S.C. § 1983
As in past cases, I will have to be circumspect in what I say after the filing of this action. However, we are honored to represent the Brown family in this historic challenge,” said Professor Turley. “We believe that this case represents the strongest factual and legal basis for a challenge to the criminalization of polygamy ever filed in the federal courts. We are not demanding the recognition of polygamous marriage. We are only challenging the right of the state to prosecute people for their private relations and demanding equal treatment with other citizens in living their lives according to their own beliefs. This action seeks to protect one of the defining principles of this country, what Justice Louis Brandeis called ‘the right to be left alone.’ In that sense, it is a challenge designed to benefit not just polygamists but all citizens who wish to live their lives according to their own values – even if those values run counter to those of the majority in the state.
The following is the statement from Kody Brown, which will be the only statement at this time on the filing:
Statement of Kody Brown:
“There are tens of thousands of plural families in Utah and other states. We are one of those families. We only wish to live our private lives according to our beliefs. While we understand that this may be a long struggle in court, it has already been a long struggle for my family and other plural families to end the stereotypes and unfair treatment given consensual polygamy. We are indebted to Professor Turley and his team for their work and dedication. Together we hope to secure equal treatment with other families in the United States.”
Here is the complaint filed today: Brown Complaint
Jonathan Turley
l http://www.slate.com/blogs/xx_factor/2011/07/12/kody_brown_of_sister_wives_is_challenging_utah_polygamy_law.html
“is that poly relationships MUST somehow be based on male domination rather”
I personally have never dominated any female in any relationship, perhaps it’s because the women that attract me are not the types that seek or would stand for domination. In truth I’ve never even fantasized about that because I do believe that in general women are smarter and much more interesting than men.
Well said, Mike S.
“These laws (amendments) and political decisions are all about legislating morality. No society can exist without doing so.”
Miles,
I think you are conflating premises here and your quote above shows what I mean. All society’s need basic rules of existence. That of course is shaping, but it is not necessarily “moral shaping.” That is where I make the distinction. Morality connotes both religion and public mores. In my opinion a society has no business shaping the religious/sexual morality of its people.
“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights…
And here’s another…. “Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.”
Take away creator from the first quote and what you have is simply a structural not moral issue. The founders were trying to develop a country,
different from what had come before in human history, that would allow its’ citizens to make up their own minds as to the life they chose to live. This was grounded in the experience of many groups that had arrived on these shores from places where they were denied religious liberty (i.e. Puritans, Quakers, Catholics, Jews, etc.). Their one enormous hypocrisy though was that they allowed slavery for political reasons.
This hypocrisy was redressed in the second paragraph above after our bloodiest war. These men all were Enlightenment thinkers, trying to create what was to them a rational state. To me, at least, this wasn’t religious morality, it was an ingenious way to allow people to live with personal freedom of action, thought and speech. No religion at the time of the Constitution’s writing preached this, nor believed in it conceptually.
The constitution is moot on marriage, on sexuality and even on honesty, all
of which are moral issues. I am much in favor of this lawsuit prevailing, not because I think polygamy is a perfectly good idea, it wouldn’t work for me personally and I know this from experience. Much prior to my three decade marriage I lived for six years in a polymorphous relationship.which scarred me emotionally. Yet it was a valuable learning situation for me in allowing me to determine what I truly wanted and was capable of in a relationship and I’ve chosen strict monogamy.
Your assumption that all such relationships are exploitative is only sustainable by looking into the examples of powerful men who one way or another amass a group of more than one woman. In all of the cases you choose the women had no choice. Today, except for barbarity like the Jeffs type of compound, this is not necessarily true and the Browns are an example of that. I do make a distinction between laws that order a society and laws that impose someone’s notion of morality on a society. I am against the latter.
Elaine, your original post raised several valid concern that many people share. I personally felt the need to address some of the issues but recognize that just raising a point doesn’t define your position. I’m sorry you have to keep explaining that.
Once again, the “anti” arguments keep getting based on treating “polygamy” as a synonym for “polygyny”. If *I* know living, breathing polyandrists, how many are there I DON’T know about? And I doubt they would be impressed by being told they could “be dismissed as a practical matter”.
I do not see the relevance of invoking “descendants of Genghis Khan”, as I expect that by this time they would include most inhabitants of the northern hemisphere. Didn’t I read that most Europeans are descended from Charlemagne?
Something else which comes to mind is Chesterton’s observation that “a man can have as many wives as he wants as long as he does not call them his wives– or rather, as long as he does not go through certain more or less mystical ceremonies to call them his wives.” Thus, Hefner goes uncriticized for his harem because he does not CALL them wives.
Gray Peterson,
I wrote: “I’d say we must be cautious about defending certain rights of individuals regarding the adherence to the teachings/practices of their churches. Some FDLS groups force young women into marriages with much older men. In some cases, the women are practically held captive.”
You wrote: “Do not confuse the abuses of the compounds, shrouded in secrecy due to illegality, with the independent households like the Brown’s.”
I didn’t confuse the two. Please note the that I wrote about “certain rights” and “some FDLS groups.” I was just suggesting that we should be careful about defending some practices on religious grounds. BTW, I never wrote anything on this thread about criminalizing polygamy.
Mike S.,
Great points….
from Elaine M.
[quote]I’d say we must be cautious about defending certain rights of individuals regarding the adherence to the teachings/practices of their churches. Some FDLS groups force young women into marriages with much older men. In some cases, the women are practically held captive.[/quote]
Child bigamy is unlawful under a separate Utah statute which is not being challenged by Professor Turley and the Brown family nor would they: All of the wives were over the age of 18 when they either legally or spiritually married into the family.
Do not confuse the abuses of the compounds, shrouded in secrecy due to illegality, with the independent households like the Brown’s.
The states which still prohibited “unnatural acts” between same-gender and opposite gendered couples made the argument that they had to ban the sexual acts between same gender couples in order to keep the STD level low and to keep “Cruising” to a minimum, which is ridiculous on it’s face. The Supreme Court still ruled against the bans on private conduct.
Utah’s reasons for keeping the cohabiting polygamy ban is ridiculous on it’s face. Given the logic of these Utah prosecutors, any person who is openly gay and says so on television could be prosecuted under Utah’s sodomy law. That is ridiculous.
I’m not certain that Kody Brown likes me particularly. I’m sort of outside of his faith and I’m pretty certain to be damned to many FLDS, but the government has no business telling people to closet themselves when they engage in consenting relationships with other adults. No business, none whatsoever.
even lee marvin and clint eastwood managed to share a wife
>”it is overwhelmingly one husband multiple wives, and has some paternalistic overtones.”
Since the majority of documented modern practitioners are LDS fundamentalists that is to be expected. I posted in 2008 “Orthodox (insert religion here) is a threat to racial and sexual equality.”* and I stand by that statement. Any relationship that is derived from the elevation of one partner over another is unhealthy.
But just as modern marriage has evolved away from being a property transaction between a father and a suitor, modern poly relationships are being recognized as a good choice for some people for a variety of reasons. It is certainly not for everyone, and as someone who was raised by two wonderful, loving parents in a monogamous relationship I’m not even going to say poly is for most people. But someone shouldn’t have to worry about getting arrested in Utah for honestly answering a question about their family life. THAT is what this lawsuit is about. I don’t feel a need for my relationship to be validated by the state. I certainly don’t feel the need for religious validation. I just don’t want people to assume that I’m some kind of misogynistic monster just because of a lifestyle choice or that I somehow cannot love a child that doesn’t share my genes.
That and you know, it would be nice not to have to worry about going to jail.
* http://jonathanturley.org/2008/09/16/england-officially-recognizes-sharia-rulings/
MASkeptic:
My views are based on a very limited exposure to the topic. From what I can determine from the Brown family and the limited reading I’ve done, it is overwhelmingly one husband multiple wives, and has some paternalistic overtones. i am always willing to hear new information.
Bob, Miles, mespo, Nate, et al.
Wow. Just… wow.
The baseline assumption that keeps getting made in your arguments (with several of Miles’ points excepted) is that poly relationships MUST somehow be based on male domination rather than mutual love and affection. As if an informed, independent, and healthy woman or man is incapable of loving more than one person in a relationship or making healthy decisions about the relationships in which they are involved.
The needs of a healthy relationship don’t suddenly change because you have more than one partner and there is an incredible amount of work that goes into making sure that everyone is getting what they need emotionally. And no one suddenly loses the ability to walk away if their needs aren’t being met.
So many of the vilifications I’ve read don’t take into account a woman with multiple husbands. Or a man with multiple wives, some of whom may have other husbands of their own. It’s just automatically assumed that anyone who’s involved must be some kind of ego tripping misogynist or a religious wacko or both.
As I mentioned in the previous article this is not an academic issue for me.
Bob, am I diminishing my loved ones or treating them like chattel? Am /I/ diminished somehow mespo for being in a polyamorous relationship? Are you prepared to assert that without knowing one single detail about our situation?
There’s a lot of things I admire about Josef Smith.
But I spit at his feet when it comes to polygamy.
His people are still paying for his mistake… and his lies.
mespo,
“May the legislature permit a condition of inequality to exist with respect to legal rights enjoyed by other members of the same class?”
I think that goes to the heart of my contention. If the inequality is assumed through valid consent and is a transactional cost for entering into a non-traditional agreement, why should the court disallow that relationship absent some other policy interest? Just like a contract for professional fights. It’s against public policy to contract to fight as a general rule, but if the persons possess informed valid consent including their assumptions of risk, the state allows those contracts. I see the assumption of risk in a polygamous marriage to be analogous. It’s a non-standard arrangement that will carry certain risks like a proportionately lower claim in intestate successions, etc. As long as all parties know these risks and enter into the relationship with valid consent, I really don’t see the harm.
Bob, Esq.:
It sure is an interesting equal protection argument. May the legislature pass a law sanctioning a relationship of subservience of one gender to another? Or put more concretely may the legislature permit a condition of inequality to exist with respect to legal rights enjoyed by other members of the same class? Intriguing!
Mespo,
I think it can be both. But it would be less a rights issue and more of a power issue in the courts. That’s to say there’s nothing in the constitution empowering the government to treat women as less than equal as a result of a successful argument under any of the other protections afforded.
Assume Turley wins every point on his brief in the abstract, yet the result necessitates treating women as less than equal, where does the court derive its power to grant Turley the relief prayed for?
Gene,
“It’s not like a Sheik building a harem. ”
It’s pretty much exactly like that.
“Most people aren’t going to want to enter into a polygamous relationship”
Every man who marries an additional wife reduces the number of available women by that amount. I think there are lots of reasons that many men would choose multiple wives. Society is changing, and it can change.
” to suggest that if polygamy were made legal that monogamy would be threatened and we’d suddenly have an excess of bachelor’s I think flies in the face of human nature.”
I have a very different view of human nature from you. Polygamous marriages are historically normative. Just read the bible, to take but one example. Polygamy is natural, and it is historically common.
What is not natural is equality. Equality is something you have to build with laws and social norms. Monogamy is part of creating a community based on rough political equality.
Moving in a polygamous direction as a society is as easy as falling off a log. There are always powerful, disproportionately attractive men who can offer things that multiple women want. That’s the way the world is and always has been. What happens when you let things go in that direction is a world that I don’t want to live in, and I think if you think about it that you wouldn’t want it either.
Bob, Esq:
History says you’re right, but is this a value judgment for the legislature or a rights issue for the courts? There is certainly both a rational and historic basis for legislation.
Hey, here’s another effort to shape society…. “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights…
And here’s another…. “Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.”
And, wisely, in the 19th century another threat to human equality was also banned from our political community: polygamy. Utah’s admittance to the union required its renunciation.
If that’s shaping society, then I don’t know what kind of person could possibly oppose it. These laws (amendments) and political decisions are all about legislating morality. No society can exist without doing so. We have some basic norms that establish the kind of society we are and want to be.
Slavery got settled in the constitution, but unfortunately polygamy, which is also a fundamental question of human equality, was settled in more political and less concrete manner. Too bad. Now it can be re-litigated by Mr. Turley. It remains a contested ground.