Pelosi’s Court: How the Jan. 6 Committee Undermined its Own Legitimacy

Below is my column in The Hill on the January 6th Committee hearings and how the Democrats undermined the legitimacy of their investigation by breaking the long tradition of bipartisan and balanced membership on such special committees. Many of us support the effort to release more information and evidence on what occurred on that day. However, Speaker Nancy Pelosi decided to forego even the pretense of a bipartisan and full inquiry.

Here is the column:

In 1924, Lord Gordon Hewart famously declared, “Justice should not only be done, but should manifestly and undoubtedly be seen to be done.” The lord chief justice of England, he believed that even a small allegation of possible bias by a court clerk meant justice was not seen to be done and, thus, was not done.

Lord Hewart’s quote came to mind while watching the opening night of the House’s Jan. 6 select committee public hearings. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) decided a year ago to break from tradition and blocked two Republican committee members selected by GOP leaders. In response, House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) pulled his other committee nominees, and Pelosi then seated two staunchly anti-Trump Republicans — Reps. Liz Cheney (Wyoming) and Adam Kinzinger (Illinois).

Congress has a long history of bipartisan investigatory and select committees. Many were formed during deep political rifts — yet, for 230 years, Congress maintained the need for bipartisan membership. That was the case with the Watergate committees, the House Committee on Assassinations, the Special Committee to Investigate the National Defense Program, the House Select Committee to Investigate Covert Arms Transactions and other investigations. It would have been easy to stack the decks and limit the members by party on each of those committees, but past congressional leaders understood that the credibility of such investigations required balance, including opposing views.

Pelosi’s decision to gut that process was something of a signature muscle play. As a witness in the first Trump impeachment, I was highly critical of her insistence that the House would impeach before Christmas rather than conduct the traditional impeachment investigation with witnesses. Instead of building a more convincing case, Pelosi preferred to impeach with virtually no record, for a certain defeat in the Senate. In the second impeachment, she went one better: She held no hearing at all and pushed through the first “snap impeachment.”

The Jan. 6 committee was similarly stripped of any pretense. It was as subtle a political move as Pelosi’s ripping up President Trump’s State of the Union speech. Asked what she hoped to achieve from the committee on the first day of hearings, Pelosi tellingly referred to it as a “narrative.” It is the difference between seeing and simulating justice.

According to The New York Times, that narrative is meant to “recast the midterm message” and “give [Democrats] a platform for making a broader case about why they deserve to stay in power.” It was packaged with the help of a high-powered media figure brought in to help stage the event. Much of the media touted how the hearings would be “must-see TV” and would force voters “not to look away” from Trump’s “coup.” Countervailing evidence was edited out. Thus, Trump was shown calling for the protesters to “march” on the Capitol — but not his additional words to do so “peacefully.”

That withheld line from Trump would hardly have exonerated the former president. I publicly condemned Trump’s speech while it was being given, and I called for a bipartisan vote of censure over his responsibility in the Capitol riot. The new footage shown by the committee only magnified the revulsion many of us felt in watching this desecration of our Capitol and our constitutional process. However, such one-sided accounts rob these proceedings of a sense of authenticity and authority.

However, they deliver precisely what Pelosi demands: politics unburdened by process. Ironically, it is the very same dismissal of process and principle that is often attributed to Trump.

The shame is that it could have been so much more if the committee were balanced and allowed a broader scope of inquiry.

For example, the first two witnesses highlighted the ongoing controversy over the failure of Congress to adequately prepare for the riot despite repeated warnings from the executive branch. Capitol Police officer Caroline Edwards and Nick Quested, a British documentarian, both noted the shocking absence of sufficient officers around the Capitol. Quested described “hundreds” of Proud Boys marching on the Capitol and seeing a single officer at one barricade; Edwards described a handful of officers holding back hundreds of protesters. Critical anti-riot equipment was not distributed or was affirmatively withheld. Security objectives were ignored, and even Edwards said officers were quickly and easily overrun due to lack of support.

Four days before the riot, records indicate the Capitol allegedly was asked if it wanted to request National Guard troops but declined. Yet The Washington Post and PolitiFact have insisted this is false. It would be useful to get the full story on what decisions were made — but House leaders appear to have curtailed inquiries into the failure to properly staff or equip officers at the scene, to erect fencing, or to call for the National Guard after the riot erupted.

This first hearing looked like the uncontested opening statement in a persona non grata proceeding, a hearing designed to denounce or expel an individual. Much of the evidence was designed to show that Trump repeatedly was told that he lost the election and thus had no good faith basis to challenge the election’s certification.

Well, many of us said exactly that two years ago. Moreover, if the effort is to convict Trump of being a narcissistic or craven person, you hardly need a select committee to make that case to the Democratic base or to much of the rest of America.

Perhaps the most surprising element in the start of the hearings is the person who was portrayed as the guardian of democracy: former Attorney General William Barr. After Democrats called for Barr to be impeached or even criminally charged, he was shown repeatedly as holding the line against Trump’s claims and demands. For those of us who have defended Barr for years, it was a welcome but weird sight to behold.

There is considerable evidence that Trump’s people planned for a certification challenge, but that was always anticipated. Not long after the election, I wrote about that possibility in what I called the “Death Star strategy.” It is not a crime to plan such a challenge, even without good cause. Without any direct connection to organizing or supporting the ensuing violence, that would remain a moral — not a legal — failure.

Indeed, if opposing views were allowed, then Republicans likely would call for the testimony of committee Chairman Bennie Thompson (D-Miss.), who voted to challenge the certification of the 2004 results of President George W. Bush’s reelection; committee member Jamie Raskin (D-Md.) sought to challenge Trump’s certification in 2016. Both did so under the very law that Trump’s congressional supporters used in 2020. And Pelosi and Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) praised the challengeorganized by then-Sen. Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.) in 2004.

The difference, of course, is that while there were violent protests in 2016 in Washington, there was not a riot that breached the Capitol. Yet, given that history, it was more important than ever for House leaders to reinforce the credibility of this committee by adhering to the long-respected principle of bipartisan appointments.

But this is Speaker Pelosi’s — not Lord Hewart’s — “court,” where the only thing “manifestly and undoubtedly” guaranteed is politics, without the pretense of principle.

Jonathan Turley is the Shapiro Professor of Public Interest Law at George Washington University. Follow him on Twitter @JonathanTurley.

542 thoughts on “Pelosi’s Court: How the Jan. 6 Committee Undermined its Own Legitimacy”

  1. Trump is a Putin Puppet that’s how he won the election, he pee’s on beds and speaks to a corrupt Ukrainian government.

    I can prove it, just ask Hillary, Adam Schiff and Eric Swalwell. They have the proof, they even said they do! They’re the salt of the earth and don’t lie. I also have a full record album of Guy Lombardo and his Royal Canadians performing “auld lang syne” if anyone is interested?

  2. I think we have a good idea of what the American Public thinks of this hearing. Ratings of CBS, ABC, NBC showed a total of 19 million viewers out of 330 million+ people. We could score this like a movie and see what the drop off in viewership for this week will be and then watch the ratings till the end. That might tell us more about this hearing than what is actually said or not said.
    I am a conservative republican but I would not be unhappy if both Pelosi and Trump removed themselves from the political landscape.
    Mrs. Pelosi might also consider that if she gets her deepest wish fulfilled, that something far more formidable than Trump might appear in the Republican lineup. You know someone young with a young family, photogenic, smart, less of a narcissist than most politicians, with a wide variety of experiences but who might be even more adept at passing the Trump agenda than Trump ever was. Her dream might turn into a nitemare.

    1. Sorry, I agree with most of your sentiment, but if your hypothetical candidate is slick, polished, and has made a career out of running for office I’m not interested. I too consider myself conservative, albeit with a libertarian streak a mile wide. I am just sick to death of career politicians and worse yet ones who come from family dynasties. That is how we have got to this point, from both Democrats and Republicans. I want someone who says it plain and straight, like something I’d hear from someone across the bar after shift change, warts, cussing, inappropriate outbursts and all. I want someone who has struggled to put gas in the tank and put food on the table like the rest of us. Everyday America needs to be represented by an everyday American.

      1. Unfortunately, the American political system makes this impossible. At least with the vast majority of candidates. One has to kiss the corporate ring in order to get the level of money needed to run. Funny though, the candidate who most closely fits the bill of looking across the bar at someone grinding out their living would be AOC who was a bartender until right before she won her seat.

        eb

        1. She’s ruled out because if you think government is the answer, you’re asking the wrong question.

      2. Currentsitguy,

        “Democracy is a pathetic belief in the collective wisdom of individual ignorance.”

        -H.L. Mencken

        1. Although I am a huge fan of Mencken, I categorically reject anything that requires anything on a collective level. There are no Rights but individual ones, and coercion is always evil and wrong no matter how large the majority is who desire it. The largest mistake we made as a nation is embodied in the lack of a single word in the Declaration of Independence:

          “That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed”

          Should read

          “That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the unanimous consent of the governed”

          Without that one word government is just two wolves and a sheep deciding what’s for dinner. Would it hamstring government into almost paralysis? Yes! But that’s the whole point. People don’t need to be governed, they need to work it out to a mutually acceptable situation themselves on an individual to individual basis.

          1. Yours is a radical idea. It sounds to me to be a tyranny of a tiny minority, not a democracy.

    2. Oddly, I tend to agree with aspects of what you say. I think the R’s need trump for fundraising purposes + being unelectable. The dream scenario for Mitch McConnell is to control the Senate under D control of the executive. The perfect setting for fundraising and grinding the Senate to a halt on everything other than judges.

      eb

  3. Turley, who likes to complain about the “age of rage” but feeds it daily with his biased commentary, is silent about the fact that the House originally passed legislation creating a totally bipartisan National Commission to Investigate the January 6 Attack on the United States Capitol Complex Act, and Senate Republicans filibustered it: https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/3233/text

    Under that Act, Republicans in Congress would have had total control over half the members of the Commission, without an ability from Pelosi or any other Democrat to veto their choices.

    But Republicans in the Senate prevented it.

    That’s why Pelosi created a Select Committee, and by the rules of the House, Pelosi could then choose whatever members she wanted. As Turley notes, “House Speaker Nancy Pelosi … blocked two Republican committee members selected by GOP leaders.” He isn’t honest enough to name them: Jim Jordan and Jim Banks, and she did so because they’d both opposed the opposed the creation of a Select Committee and made it clear that they had no interest in carrying out its work. She accepted the other 3 Republicans proposed by House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy, but as Turley notes, McCarthy then “pulled his other committee nominees,” Reps. Rodney Davis, Kelly Armstrong, and Troy Nehls.

    McCarthy is the one to blame for there only being 2 Republicans on the Committee.

    So Turley shouldn’t be saying that “for 230 years, Congress maintained the need for bipartisan membership” and then pretending that the Democrats are the ones who got in the way, especially since the Select Committee IS bipartisan. Turley simply doesn’t like the Republicans serving on the Committee. He’s happy to say that “Pelosi’s decision to gut that process was something of a signature muscle play,” but would never say that McCarthy gutted the process by pulling the remaining members he nominated or that the Senate Republicans gutted the National Commission process in signature muscle plays.

    He wants to feed “the age of rage.” Hypocrite.

    He also claims — without evidence — that “House leaders appear to have curtailed inquiries into the failure to properly staff or equip officers at the scene, to erect fencing, or to call for the National Guard after the riot erupted.” What evidence is he basing this on? The Committee is said to have interviewed almost 1000 people. Why is he assuming that none were asked questions about that very topic? Again, he assumes is because he gets off on feeding the rage he daily complains about.

    “Barr … was shown repeatedly as holding the line against Trump’s claims and demands”

    If he’d actually wanted to hold the line, he wouldn’t have resigned in that crucial period of time.

    “The difference, of course, is that while there were violent protests in 2016 in Washington, there was not a riot that breached the Capitol.”

    That’s one difference. Another more significant one is that NEVER before was there a President pushing the VP to act unconstitutionally and unilaterally reject legally chosen electors’ votes. But of course, Turley can’t bring himself to address this. As Judge Carter noted, “Disagreeing with the law entitled President Trump to seek a remedy in court, not to disrupt a constitutionally-mandated process.”

    1. Yeah this a even more pathetic than Turkey’s usual copy-paste pablum. The Legal Laughingstock of Langley again misses the Forrest for the trees. It is the Republican Party which is illegitimate and certainly not these hearings.

    2. As Judge Carter noted, “Disagreeing with the law entitled President Trump to seek a remedy in court, not to disrupt a constitutionally-mandated process.”
      ****************************
      Yep, telling folks to peacefully protest is “disrupting” a “constitutionally mandated process” with guess what? A constitutionally protected process. Maybe the biggest Constitutionally protected process! Think that judge ever read the US Constitution?

      1. Don’t be so disingenuous mespo.

        The statement I quoted was not about the protest on Jan. 6. It was about the memo that had been forwarded to Eastman by Giuliani — and that Eastman had shared with Trump, and Trump was acting on — that was subject to the crime-fraud exception. That memo was written by attorney Kenneth Chesebro. You can read it here:
        https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/62613089/350/2/john-c-eastman-v-bennie-g-thompson/

        And you can read Judge Carter’s ruling in full here, confirming that the sentence I quoted was not about the protest:
        https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/62613089/260/john-c-eastman-v-bennie-g-thompson/

        As for the people who broke into the Capitol (which was closed to visitors due to Covid), no, breaking into the Capitol is not “A constitutionally protected process.” Peaceful protest is constitutionally protected. That was not a peaceful protest.

        1. “Don’t be so disingenuous mespo.

          The statement I quoted was not about the protest on Jan. 6. It was about the memo that had been forwarded to Eastman by Giuliani — and that Eastman had shared with Trump, and Trump was acting on — that was subject to the crime-fraud exception.”
          ***************************************
          Guess that cut and paste job of yours omitted the topic and resulted in an oblique reference to an otherwise unnamed judge who said … something about something. You’d think Correct the Record would have better editors for your tripe but alas competency was never a Dim virtue. Mea culpa for thinking it was about the topic at hand. I’ll await your next sophistry with better references, hopefully.

          1. Work on your reading skills mespo

            In my original post, I clearly said “As Judge Carter noted, “Disagreeing with the law entitled President Trump to seek a remedy in court, not to disrupt a constitutionally-mandated process.””

            Not sure how you take “Judge Carter” and interpret it as “an otherwise unnamed judge.”

            1. Otherwise unnamed except the sole oblique reference you made. And you want me to work on my reading skills? How about those writing skills or don’t you read what you write?

              1. If you didn’t know that I was quoting part of Carter’s ruling about the crime-fraud exception in Eastman v Thompson, then the adult response would have been to ask what I was quoting from instead of ASSuming that he was talking about the J6 protest.

                Of course, in all of this, you cannot bring yourself to address Carter’s point about Trump’s effort to get Pence to act unconstitutionally during the vote certification: “Disagreeing with the law entitled President Trump to seek a remedy in court, not to disrupt a constitutionally-mandated process.”

        2. Still off in lala land. To be subject to the crime fraud exception the memo must itself be evidence of a crime.

          This has been addressed repeatedly – Eastman can not commit a crime by offering a legal oppinion that you do not like that is consistent with the constitution, that follows the relevant law and that reflects what has actually occured in the past.

          This is the root problem with the democrats entire J6 mess.

          You are trying to criminalize political disagreement. That is dangerous, stupid and unconstitutional.

          It is not Eastman on the wrong side of the law and constitution – it is YOU.

          You are attempting to bend the crime fraud exception to destroy priviledge where there is SELF-EVIDENTLY no crime.

          It is also stupid claims like this that resulted in Eastman taking the 5th. Once you accuse someone of acting criminally you can no longer compell their testimony PERIOD. Not about ANYTHING.

          So you make up fake crimes,
          You pretend that non crimes allow you to violate long established privildges,
          and then you are suprised when those involve act like they are being accused of committing a crime – because they are.

          The 5th amendment exists for many purposes – one of which is to thwart these show trials like the J6 hearings.

    3. Turley,

      I am no fan of Pelosi but it absolutely disingenuous to ignore the context of the formation of the Select Committee, as detailed above. You try to compare this situation to past commissions, but by failing to address Pelosi’s filibustered attempt to create a bipartisan commission, you intentionally ignore the circumstances which make this situation unique. If you truly want to compare this to past commissions, you would need to find another time in American history, where a commission was created to investigate an event, involving predominantly the actions of one party, and where said party turned down an opportunity to provide disinterested members of its party to sit on such investigative committee. Do any of your comparisons above involve precisely these circumstances?

      While I agree that the Select Committee is political theater, this is directly the result of McCarthy’s actions to put Jim Jordan and Jim Banks on the Committee, and to then remove the whole party from it when Pelosi rightfully rejected their inclusion. Your failure to recount this procedural history invalidates your article categorically.

      We need to have politicians who put country above party on both sides of the aisle. You only feed the “age of rage” by selectively ignoring the details which have proximately caused the creation of the political charade we now see.

    4. In your haste to play team sport you try to conflate the workings of the House with those of the Senate. As long as you’re happy if the next GOP Speaker gets to organize their committees in the same fashion.
      This committee announced its conclusion at its first meeting. That’s all you need to know.

      1. “you try to conflate the workings of the House with those of the Senate”

        Nope.

        What was initially proposed — through legislation that would have been passed by both chambers — was a National Commission with members chosen by both Republicans and Democrats in both chambers.

        The sole reason that it ended up as a House Select Committee — not a National Commission — is because the Senate Republicans filibustered the National Commission legislation passed by the House. I linked to the text of the National Commission Act, but apparently you’re too lazy to read it.

        “As long as you’re happy if the next GOP Speaker gets to organize their committees in the same fashion.”

        The Speaker has long had the ability to create Select Committees, and the rules for their creation predate Pelosi.

        “This committee announced its conclusion at its first meeting”

        I’m not sure what you’re interpreting as the committee’s “conclusion.” Please do quote what “conclusion” you believe was announced.

    5. The Act you mentioned called the riot on January 6 a “domestic terrorist attack” before they even conducted an investigation so it was rightly rejected by the GOP. Why didn’t Thompson or any other Democrat sponsor a bill to create a committee to investigate the multiple attacks on Federal Court houses in Portland and Seattle where rioters clashed with federal officers, smashed windows, and started fires? No one on the left referred to those riots as domestic terrorist attacks even though they were just as violent and officers were injured.

      The minority was not allowed to choose their representatives on the select committee. That’s a fact. Turley never said Pelosi broke any rules. He is accusing her of breaking a long standing tradition that gave people the impression it was a bipartisan effort. This committee does not.

      We have yet to see if the committee has investigated the security failures but so far Turley appears to be correct. We know, according to NBC news and other outlets the FBI and other agencies warned the Capital Police and the Mayor of D.C. “about the possibility of violence during the protests” so why were they so woefully unprepared as many have pointed out? We know, according to the Capital Police’s own timeline, that the Pentagon asked them if they were going to request Guard troops four days before the riot and was told the next day that “a request for National Guard support is not forthcoming at this time”. Yet on the very same day, January 3rd, the Capital Police revised their assessment to state “Due to the tense political environment following the 2020 election, the threat of disruptive actions and violence cannot be ruled out.” On January 4th, the COP Sund asked the Sergeant of Arms for both the House and Senate “for authority to have National Guard to assist with security for the January 6, 2021 event based on briefing with law enforcement partners and revised intelligence assessment.” The next line on the Capital Police’s timeline states “COP Sund’s request is denied.” So was this an intelligence failure? No. Was this a planning failure? To some degree but at least we know the Pentagon approached the Capital Police and eventually they wanted help from the National Guard but were denied. Denied not by Trump or the Pentagon but leadership in Congress. The Sergeants of Arms would not have denied COP Sund’s request without direction from the majority leaders in Congress. So let’s see if any of that comes up during the investigation.

      1. The LEOs who publicly testified under oath months ago referred to the violent protesters as domestics terrorists, and when asked why, Officer Hodges said “I came prepared: U.S. Code, Title 18, part one, chapter 113B (as in brown), section 2331. ‘The term domestic terrorism means (A) activities that involve acts dangerous to human life that are a violation of the criminal laws of the United States or of any State, and (B) appear to be intended to intimidate or coerce a civilian population or to influence the policy of a government by intimidation or coercion, or to affect the conduct of a government by mass destruction, assassination, or kidnapping and occur primarily within the territorial jurisdiction of the United States.'” You didn’t need an investigation to conclude that it was a “domestic terrorist attack,” as it fits the legal definition.

        “The minority was not allowed to choose their representatives on the select committee. That’s a fact.”

        Pelosi was willing to seat 3 of the 5 Reps. nominated by McCarthy. That’s a fact. McCarthy is the one who pulled the other three off. That’s a fact. The House rules leave the membership of Select Committees entirely to the Speaker. That’s a fact. The only reason that the House Select Committee was created was because the Senate Republicans filibustered the creation of a bicameral National Commission where the GOP would have had total control over half the members of the Commission. That’s a fact.

        “He is accusing her of breaking a long standing tradition that gave people the impression it was a bipartisan effort.”

        Duh.

        And as I pointed out, she is not the one who broke the long standing tradition. The GOP did.

    6. More BS from an anonymous commentator. Not surprising since the democrats have been continuously lying.

    7. ” not to disrupt”

      This has so many meanings it becomes meaningless as does the above statement. True had a right to challenge. There is no question of that. All that remains is how the Jan6 committee frames the interviews. What the Jan6 committee is doing at present is a fraud. It might be legal fraud, but it is a fraud anyway. Presenting only one side that solely uses opinion instead of fact proves nothing.

  4. When the history is written in great detail, among the residue of nancy pelosi’s tactics during her decades in the House will be included two failed impeachments and a Special January 6th Committee whose conclusions were drawn in advance and which failed in its mission…..at least that’s.the opinion of many. And when she is put out to pasture come January, 2023, hopefully she will not be heard from again. From November, 2006 to the present, she was and has continued to be worthy of the title ‘the most dangerous woman in America.’…….at least that’s the opinion of a great many.

    1. Trump was impeached twice by the House. Strange that you consider them “failed impeachments.” If they’d failed, then he wouldn’t have been impeached either time.

      1. If Pelosi’s objecctive was only to soil Trump’s presidential legacy, the you’re right – it was a resounding success for Pelosi – But if the purpose of an impeachment is to remove a person from office, Pelosi failed, twice.
        And you have to admit that the ‘snap’ impeachment in January of 2021 was vindictive, a knee-jerk abuse of power by Pelosi who had to know it would fail…..what with Trump leaving office in a matter of days anyway —
        Pelosi’s “Italian” streak was in high evidence — vendetta….

        1. Richard Lowe “Italian streak”? Stooping to Hollywood stereotypes doesn’t help your POV one bit — and tarring an entire people because of the corruption of one very American individual is just plain stupid. There are idiot trolls on this thread, but you’re the first idiot I’ve come across to denigrate Turley’s own heritage.

      2. The purpose of an impeachment is to remove someone from office. They failed.

        1. No, that’s the purpose of the trial. Apparently you don’t understand the difference between the impeachment (in the House) and the trial (in the Senate). The purpose of impeachment is like the purpose of indictment: to bring someone to trial.

          1. So Democrats initiated the impeachment process twice because they weren’t trying to remove Trump from office? Got it, you’re brilliant. Keep up the good work.

      3. Another dumb comment likely from the same anonymous. He wasn’t convicted. Democrats would impeach a pineapple if they could.

  5. Professor Turley – if you keep talking like this, the s@@tlibs will call you a ‘nazi’ too and you will not be invited to anymore cocktail parities in Georgetown.

    antonio

  6. Turley defends Barr:

    “For those of us who have defended Barr for years, it was a welcome but weird sight to behold.”

    Trump stated Barr “sucked.”

    Ok, Trumpists, who’s telling the truth?

    Is Turley right defending Barr for stating that Trump was lying about election conspiracies or is Trump right that the election was REALLY stolen?

    Who ya gonna believe- Trump or Turley?

    1. Barr works for the Swamp. Nothing new about that observation. He decalre after three full weeks, with no hearings and no known FBI investigation there was no evidence of election fraud. Subsequent facts have shown otherwise. He may not “suck,” but being rash with his pronouncements seems about right. He doesn’t see evil; he sees politics. Typical approach by a man with politics as his tool. That’s a common blinder when you work in DC.

      1. Mespo says:

        “Barr works for the Swamp.”

        Turley is defending the Swamp? What does that make him? Part of the Swamp? Sounds like you are suffering from “Barr Derangement Syndrome” if I may borrow a Trumpist tactic.

        You say: “He declared after three full weeks, with no hearings and no known FBI investigation there was no evidence of election fraud.”

        Trump declared there WOULD BE fraud long before the election!! Trump is even worse than Barr!

        You say: “Subsequent facts have shown otherwise.”

        You are a liar. Prove me wrong.

        1. Breathless Jeff:
          “Barr works for the Swamp.”

          Turley is defending the Swamp? What does that make him? Part of the Swamp? Sounds like you are suffering from “Barr Derangement Syndrome” if I may borrow a Trumpist tactic.

          You say: “He declared after three full weeks, with no hearings and no known FBI investigation there was no evidence of election fraud.”

          Trump declared there WOULD BE fraud long before the election!! Trump is even worse than Barr!

          You say: “Subsequent facts have shown otherwise.”

          You are a liar. Prove me wrong.”

          ***************************
          1. Let’s take the last part first: I’d prove you wrong but you refuse to watch “2000 Mules” so that would be tough when you’re willfully ignorant. That said, here’s the stats on what decent people and voting Dims who see it say about it:

          “Among voters who have seen “2000 Mules,” 85% of Republicans, 68% of Democrats and 77% of unaffiliated voters say the movie strengthened their conviction that there was systematic and widespread election fraud in the 2020 election.

          Among voters who have seen the documentary, 78% say they would recommend “2000 Mules” to others regardless of whether or not they share their political beliefs. That includes 84% of Republicans, 73% of Democrats and 74% of unaffiliated voters who have seen the film.” (https://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/public_surveys/2000_mules_documentary_s_message_resonates_with_voters)

          2. Trump’s staements are irrelevant to Barr’s but I’m guessing Trump had intelligence that the Cloven Hoof Party would try something. They have since at least the 60s (LBJ’s Harris County fiasco being just one example) so why stop now?

          3. As for JT, he’s a friend of Barr’s so he’ll defend him. That makes JT loyal (and Barr rash). I have no such connection so I can call it the way I see it.

          1. Mespo actually said:

            “Let’s take the last part first: I’d prove you wrong but you refuse to watch “2000 Mules” so that would be tough when you’re willfully ignorant.”

            Apparently you did not watch Barr’s testimony today. When “2000 Mules” was brought up, he could not contain himself! He spontaneously laughed out loud because the movie was so ludicrous:

            https://youtu.be/Nz6smxo-MkE

            Turley has not said one word- not one- contesting any of Barr’s testimony.

            Either Turley is a NeverTrumper or Trump is a liar. One or the other.

            1. “Apparently you did not watch Barr’s testimony today. When “2000 Mules” was brought up, he could not contain himself! He spontaneously laughed out loud because the movie was so ludicrous:”
              *************************
              Never met a witness yet who gave credibility to something that totally exposed his incompetence and eviscerated his credibility. By the way, the head shrinkers call this defense mechanism “denial diminishment”: where you dismiss a countervailing idea without giving any basis for it because you fear the consequences of acknowledging any credibility. Barr did exactly that. Here’s some jolly witnesses you might recognize when they too were confronted with countervailing evidence:

              1. Mespo,

                I have a suggestion for a worthwhile movie to watch instead of “2000 Mules.” Watch “Judgement at Nuremberg.”

                BTW, Fox’s Mark Levin is a modern day Judge Roland Freisler:

                https://youtu.be/SKOCmBXrVY8

                Mark Levin followers will recognize the screaming attacks and vociferous denunciations.

                1. JT:
                  Seen it many times. Torben Meyer reminds me of Shifty Schiff. Marlene Dietrich as Fraulein Cheney and who could forget Capt. Kirk himself, William Shatner, as Adam Kinzinger. Adam’s been beamed up way too many times.

                  1. Mespo,

                    I see Dr. Turley as Dr. Ernst Janning.

                    One day I do earnestly hope that Turley will acknowledge the liars with whom he served at Fox and exclaim as did Janning that he was:

                    “worse than any of them because he knew what they were, and he went along with them. Jonathan Turley- who made his life excrement because he walked with them…. It is not easy to tell the truth; but if there is to be any salvation for [me], we who know our guilt must admit it… whatever the pain and humiliation.”

    2. Barr didn’t say Trump lied and now Barr is saying he had nothing to do with any violence at the Capitol. You are a nutcase.

  7. Hate Trump won’t change the midterms. Jan 6 Kabuki Theater won’t win the midterms.

    Reality wins! Inflation, GAS and groceries.

    James Carville: It’s the economy stupid!

    Biden’s policies got us here, Not Trump, Not Putin and Not the oil companies!

  8. Turley attacks:

    “Well, many of us said exactly that two years ago. Moreover, if the effort is to convict Trump of being a narcissistic or craven person, you hardly need a select committee to make that case to the Democratic base or to *much of the rest of America.*”

    Yikes! NeverTrumper or what?

    Once a “carnival snake charmer” always a “craven person.” I told you so.

  9. This whole thing is a Taxpayer funded anti Trump show…. Politicians spin and lie to the public, promoting themselves without much of a news media watchdog to ask a few important questions these days. We may not be as smart, or as they are, but we are not as stupid as they seem to think we are.

    1. No doubt you would have called the Watergate hearings “a Taxpayer funded anti Nixon show.”

      1. Check the composition of that committee and the rules VS. Jan 6 …very different

        1. Again: blame Kevin McCarthy (who withdrew the membership of 3 additional Republicans he’d originally nominated for the J6 Committee) and the the Senate Republicans (who filibustered the creation of a National J6 Commission, where they’d have controlled 1/2 the Commission membership without any Democratic say over the members they chose) for there not being more Republicans on the Committee.

      2. The Watergate hearings were actual hearings. These are not hearings. During an actual hearing, the people accused of wrongdoing are allowed cross examination. These televised events are nothing more than political stage craft to push a narrative.

        1. These are also actual hearings.

          “During an actual hearing, the people accused of wrongdoing are allowed cross examination.”

          You’re confusing a hearing with a trial. Nixon didn’t have any private lawyers at the Watergate hearings.

          1. No I’m not. Hearings allow for cross. On June 27, the president’s counsel, James St. Clair, opened Nixon’s impeachment defense before the Committee and was allowed cross examination of five witnesses and on July 18 St. Clair presented his final argument.

          2. BS, This is a Kangaroo Kommittee. Das fuhrer would be proud of you.

        2. Tell us, Major, were you duped by Trump’s lies or was it a case of willful blindness? The truth hurts doesn’t it?

  10. Grievance based on lies that republicans were left off the committee works for those who are disconnected from reality. And the facts are, Turley knows better, but using distractions for the alternative facts crowd works.

    1. ‘The Soviet-style show trial would be grotesque even if Democrats didn’t control the entire government and even if the country weren’t in a free fall. That the exclusively Democrat-appointed committee is running the show trial in these circumstances is a disaster.’ ~mz hemingway

  11. Nice deflection post. The point of the committee is to lay bare the direct threats to our democracy. For two months Trump lied about the election and a tried to stay in power by any means. It culminated with the first attempted coup in US in US history. This can not be forgotten nor downplayed. It is essential that Pelosi does not allow the Republicans to sabotage it.

    1. Trump was proven right. The election wasn’t secure and that is a proven fact. The only thing in question is why Biden who lost the election is in the White House. You don’t know the answer to that, nor have you noted the inconsistencies of the left on the Jan 6 panel.

      Do you know when Pelosi will be forced to release all her communications?

  12. ““Panelists” including Rep. Adam Schiff, who pushed the Russia collusion hoax and led the failed first impeachment, and Rep. Raskin, who vowed to impeach Trump before he took office and led the failed second impeachment. They both sound objective and credible!” ~joel pollak

  13. The Dems are going to provide certainty to their followers: “I knew it…”.

    But will they convince thinking Americans?

    I doubt it; a show trial is hard to dress up as justice.

  14. “In 1924, Lord Gordon Hewart famously declared, “Justice should not only be done, but should manifestly and undoubtedly be seen to be done.” The lord chief justice of England, he believed that even a small allegation of possible bias by a court clerk meant justice was not seen to be done and, thus, was not done.“
    *************************
    Seems those old white guys knew a thing or two about justice. Pelosi is the Queen of Hearts and knows practically nothing except power and rage. Time for her to exit like every tyrant by her own hand whether she knows it or not.

  15. Why haven’t any of these “witnesses” pled the 5th? You know, like Lois Lerner and all the Obama corrupt hacks? Why do any of the J6 witnesses answer a single question?

    1. Strange that you assume none of the Committee’s witnesses have pled the 5th. That’s false. Trump’s lawyer, John Eastman, pled the 5th ~150 times in his testimony to the Committee, and he’s not the only one.

      To be clear: you cannot invoke the 5th when asked questions that cannot possibly incriminate you, so most of the witnesses cannot plead the 5th.

      1. ” you cannot invoke the 5th when asked questions that cannot possibly incriminate you, so most of the witnesses cannot plead the 5th.”

        Hey dumb anonymous, how does one know that something can’t “possibly incriminate you”? You sound like an idiot.

        When questioned by a Democrat or the FBI, take the fifth, get a lawyer and speak only when you have a tape recorder.

      2. That is an incorrect legal understanding of the 5th amendment.
        The constitution litterally says
        “nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself”

        The J6 committee has made clear that they consider many Trump officials criminals.
        Therefore they Can not compel them to testify.

        Eastman did not take the 5th 100 times. He took it once.
        He reiterated his intention not to testify in a proceeding in which he was being accused of crimes repeatedly.

        The case law on the 5th is Clear.
        Where it is clear that YOU are being treated as a target you must notify those conducting the proceeding ahead of time.
        Where it is not clear you mus invoke it immediately on awareness that you are a target,
        and once you invoke it you may not testify further.

        You do not have the right to selectively invoke the 5th.

        Invoking the 5th is not an admission of guilt it is a recognition of the fact that you are a criminal target, that is all.

        There are about a bazzillion remarks by both committee members and pundits that they all consider Eastman’s actions criminal.
        That is all that is required.

      3. To be clear you MUST invoke the 5th in answer to ALL questions once you know that you are being accused of a crime.

        Unlike your false assertion the 5th amendment can not be invoked selectively.

        Check Brown v. United States – answering even a single question once you are aware that you are a target may waive the entire right.
        Eastman was aware he was a target long before he showed up.

        Again so that you are clear – what is relevant is Not whether you committed a crime, but whether you are subject to being accused of committing a crime. Eastman was already accused of committing a crime – he is not obligated to testify.

  16. Aw yes the daily Democrats are evil and the Republicans can do no wrong screed from the Professor. I actually remember when legal issues were discussed here. Never mind being the right wing go to “legal expert” seems to be your preferred position.

    Let me get this right how do you get a bipartisan committee to investigate Jan 6 when the only persons the Republicans are ready to appoint want the whole thing dropped or worse.

    1. JH:
      Well, of course, they are evil. Expecting us not to notice is awfully naive. Maybe we can sign on to your delusion and expect bipartisanship from a party of tyrants. The Dims prove who they are every day yet you want us to believe they aren’t what history shows them to be and for us to castigate JT for pointing up the obvious.

  17. why do you think you can “embarrass” full Fascists! They KNOW they control the DOJ and FBI…and JAIL people at Will
    Democrat Civil War 2.0

Comments are closed.