
There is an interesting controversy in Brooklyn after the city yielded to the Hasidic community in sandblasting off bike lanes on roads. Hasidic leaders complained that they are having trouble obeying their religious law forbidding them from staring at members of the opposite sex with women biking around in shorts. Bicycle advocates have been trying to repaint the lanes.
The Hasidic community has long viewed this enclave as their special area, even though other families and artists have moved in recently. That has caused trouble with the Shomrim Patrol, a Hasidic neighborhood watch group. The Shomrim recently apprehended two cycling advocates who were repainting the lane and called the police. No charges were filed but the bikers were prevented from repainting the lane.
I find it incredible that the city would yield to such demands by a religious group to erase bike lanes. A Department of Transportation spokesman said: “We will continue to work with any community on ways we can make changes to our streets without compromising safety.” However, this is a religious-based objection to women who are not covered. Yet, reports indicate that Mayor Bloomberg wanted to appease the Hasidic community before his recently close election.
Hasidic leaders say that the cyclists endanger families and children. However, this is not the view of the city in creating these lanes and they are found in every major city. The real objection appears to be their lifestyle and the rigid religious beliefs of this sect. It is a clearly improper decision that uses city resources to enforce values of a single religious group.
For the full story, click here
Those evil women–biking around with bare knees! No wonder that community in Brooklyn was in an uproar.
Bare knees? Perish the thought!!! Selling kidneys and laundering money? Not so bad.
New Jersey Mayors, Five Rabbis Arrested in Corruption Probe (Bloomberg.com, 7/24/2009)
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=aS75MsiDa4WU
also Byron, don’t forget that last year when the Flying Spaghetti Monster (Ramen) was placed on a courthouse lawn in Crossville Tennessee the end result was that all statues were removed.
more sensible not to allow them in the first place
Buddha: “The word “God” shouldn’t be on our currency or in the Pledge ”
right said, although we shouldn’t have a pledge to begin with
Byron : As I have said before just let everyone put up a display and it will all end of it’s own accord
it will not end until the false prophets get their way and turn this Country into a theocracy that allows them to control every facet of American life.
OK! All you NY bicycling women — show the bearded ninnies your other cheek, please.
Bryon,
No one is taking away anyone’s religious symbols. You can put religious symbols on any private property that you want. There are plenty of manger scenes in the churches all over town, no one is denied seeing or touching a manger scene.
The state may not favor one religion over another, or no religion at all. This is an example of a govt. complying with a specific religion’s belief system. That is so completely offensive and unconstitutional I don’t understand how anyone who values our system of govt. would condone it, even for a second.
This clearly violates our Constitution. If the city yields to one religious group’s insane demands, they will need to yield to any other’s as well. This yielding to religionists has no place in a secular govt. No theocracy functions well as a govt. NONE of our politicians should pander to theocrats of any kind. It disgusts me that politicians so readily trade out the rights of women for getting elected.
Again, notice the hatred of women in these fundamentalists sects. Also note that the men fail to take any responsibility for their own behavior (as others noted above). Don’t want to see women on bikes? Don’t look so hard. Politicians, you seem to hate women as well. Guess what, women vote. Go to Hell.
Byron–
“As I have said before just let everyone put up a display and it will all end of it’s own accord.”
I doubt that strategy would work. Remember this?
Pruning the Tree of Knowledge: Religious Advocates Vandalize Atheist Tree and Officials Demand That It Be Shortened By Eight Feet To Be Lower Than The Christmas Tree
http://jonathanturley.org/2009/12/04/pruning-the-tree-of-knowledge-religious-advocates-vandalize-atheist-tree-and-officials-demand-that-it-be-shorten-by-eight-feet-to-be-lower-than-the-christmas-tree/
Elaine:
“pedalphiliacs” great word.
They use religion as a stick as these people are doing. And they are being consistent with the people who are taking religious symbols away. Mostly Christian symbols and mostly because someone would be offended. So these people are offended, it makes sense to me. Maybe I am off base but that is what it seems like.
Buddha:
I understand those issues. I think a good bit of this kind of thing is a reaction to pulling manger scenes down from city hall. The old “hey he is doing it why cant I” thing.
People are emboldened by the ACLU suing a city to block a manger scene so they think hey we can do it the other way around and say we are being discriminated against because of our religion.
As I have said before just let everyone put up a display and it will all end of it’s own accord.
Byron–
“the flood gates were opened when manger scenes were taken down.”
How does that open the flood gates for other religious groups to have their demands met by public officials?
Byron,
Manger scenes being up in the first place is the problem. Government and religion are bad mix. That’s why the Founding Fathers went out of their way to make ours a secular government. It’s just been 200 years of zealots attacking that wise decision that is the problem. The word “God” shouldn’t be on our currency or in the Pledge – also the doing of fundie zealots. God isn’t American and most Americans who claim he is “on their side” wouldn’t recognize Jesus actual teachings if he clubbed them over the head with the lessons.
NYC v. Case Law
FAIL.
You’ve both created an effective endorsement AND excessive entanglement. Nice job.
Amazing, isn’t it? that in the Twenty-first Century politicians feel they must appease a sub-culture, a sect, a cult which refuses to teach its own members to respect the individuality and privacy of those of us who participate in the greater society and its mores. If the members of the cult in question are offended by the sight of a woman’s bare leg it is their problem, not the City of New York’s.
The members of this tiny Jewish subcultural sect wear suits a hundred years out of style and have never felt the edge of a razor on their faces. This somehow indicates they have a direct phone line to some god or other. Therefore, in deference to this tiny cult’s “holiness,” the secular political leaders of New York City acquiesce to their ridiculous demands. Utter nonsense.
It is not just New York City but the entire Western World which, I believe, has gone too far in kowtowing to the wishes of old men who wear funny clothes be they members of a fundamentalist Jewish sect or the crossing dressing leaders of a major Christian sect, Iranian ayatollahs and Libyan strongman Moammar Gadhafi who looks as if he’s just returned from the local Renaissance Faire.
Looks like this Hasidic community is a group of female pedalphiliacs.
mespo,
How were the Depositions? Back to the east coast yet?
you did not allow for others to state a faith either. So how would you state a belief in atheism? do they go to meetings with like minded individuals? How do they unite to have enough to be recognized as a belief?
the flood gates were opened when manger scenes were taken down.
nal, nal, nal,
Then they would have to put pants on and it would still be possible to get the garb caught in the sprockets. I still vote for plucking his own eye out as he has already committed adultery in his mind I am sure.
The answer: Biking in Burkas.
Ah but the good Hasidic has not followed the teaching of his faith and take personal responsibility of ones self. He should be plucking his eye out. He now has that image struck in the mind. Moses would not be pleased as he has committed adultery in his minds eye.
Or is this more about controlling these unyielding women that have not submitted to the male authority figure?
Moses would still not be pleased….Which one of the core practices of the 613 mitzvo’s has been violated?