
There is an interesting controversy in Brooklyn after the city yielded to the Hasidic community in sandblasting off bike lanes on roads. Hasidic leaders complained that they are having trouble obeying their religious law forbidding them from staring at members of the opposite sex with women biking around in shorts. Bicycle advocates have been trying to repaint the lanes.
The Hasidic community has long viewed this enclave as their special area, even though other families and artists have moved in recently. That has caused trouble with the Shomrim Patrol, a Hasidic neighborhood watch group. The Shomrim recently apprehended two cycling advocates who were repainting the lane and called the police. No charges were filed but the bikers were prevented from repainting the lane.
I find it incredible that the city would yield to such demands by a religious group to erase bike lanes. A Department of Transportation spokesman said: “We will continue to work with any community on ways we can make changes to our streets without compromising safety.” However, this is a religious-based objection to women who are not covered. Yet, reports indicate that Mayor Bloomberg wanted to appease the Hasidic community before his recently close election.
Hasidic leaders say that the cyclists endanger families and children. However, this is not the view of the city in creating these lanes and they are found in every major city. The real objection appears to be their lifestyle and the rigid religious beliefs of this sect. It is a clearly improper decision that uses city resources to enforce values of a single religious group.
For the full story, click here
These Hasidic are not being hypocritical. All goyim are subhuman in their eyes. Stupid, backward, and superstitious, sure, but hypocritical? No way. I wish I hope the law suits been filed already. Can a private citizen bring an action against a govermentment official under the honest services theory? I know these suits have been brought as shareholder suits.
Does this mayor really need the Hasidic vote that bad???
I knew that Jews control much of Washington but I didn’t realize that their influence extended down to the local level as well.
I really don’t know why society tolerates these pathetic anachronisms who live in the past.
Then, of course, I guess all ‘believers’ live in the past! When are we going to progress to a religion-free world?
Never, I say never, should any religious group influence the government when it infringes on the rights of others.
Simple solution. If looking away won’t work, moving away should do the trick!
oh please, i used to see these f*&kers’ old station wagons lined up on the prostitution blocks on saturday nights, getting their blowjobs. and i’ve stood next to more than one on a subway, with a porn mag inside their religious papers. they should join their brethren in misogyny, the taliban in afghanistan if we’re too loose here.
Jill got it right. First, the imposition of restrictions on the freedom to travel public roads purely out of deference to religious sensibilities springs from the same mentality that imposes restrictions on freedom of speech by prohibiting language insulting to religious belief.
Second, if one fears being overcome with lust at the sight of a woman in shorts, the solution is not to look, closely followed by a visit to one’s shrink. The views of the Hasidic community in this instance mirror those of people who blame rape victims for “asking for it” by wearing clothing deemed provocative.
If minimal self-control is out of the question for these folks, perhaps they should purchase blinders from the company that supplies the carriage drivers in Central Park.
So the Hasidic men would rather put bicyclists in danger than summon up enough self control and virtue to deal with their problems themselves?
Doesn’t sound like much of a religion to me.
I too have the same edict as Tsutsugamushi although mine is rooted in philosophical choice rather than religious dogma and ergo has nothing to do with the state. My reasoning is that if you weren’t supposed to look, women wouldn’t be pleasing to look at. Even women look at other women (and not in a sexual way either [necessarily]). This is not a secret. From “Isn’t she just beautiful?” to “My what an interesting fashion choice . . . but it looks good on you.” If you have women friends or a wife or a girlfriend, you know this is true. Yes, women are by nature designed to be seen by us guys and the female competition. If they weren’t, L’Oreal and Victoria’s Secret would make watch batteries or spatulas or something. It’s the primary way women got our brutish male ancestors to pay attention to them (and ergo help keep them alive in a world where being a strong killer was a survival advantage) instead of killing and eating – activities which many man seem capable of doing for prolonged periods of time left to their own devices.
It falls under that “water is wet” and “food is tasty” part of human nature. If it’s a “mistake”, you shouldn’t be taking it up with the city, but rather with the anthropomorphic sky god you’re all so excited about.
To resist the tao is to invite disaster.
rcampbell:
“This may not be your most inane statement, but it’s sure to be in the top five.”
Thank you for that endorsement. I try my best but sometimes I fall short. But hopefully, in the near future, I can say something that you really think is inane. I restrain myself most days.
Swarthmore mom–
“I don’t think calling Hasidic men “creepy and unclean” is respectful of diversity.”
You’re right–it isn’t. That’s my point. The Hasidic men didn’t approve of the way the women were dressed. Those men complained about women biking in shorts because THEY had a problem looking at their bare knees/legs and then got the city to remove biking lanes. I think that shows that those men don’t have much respect for the rights of women.
And I don’t think Hasidic men opposing bike shorts is respectful of diversity or anything else.
I don’t think calling Hasidic men “creepy and unclean” is respectful of diversity.
Elaine M.,
Do not forget to inform the City officials that your coven has a special covenant with the gods of your understanding. And that Ghost busters was just a peremptory view of the purgatory that will visit the city.
“Hasidic leaders complained that they are having trouble obeying their religious law forbidding them from staring at members of the opposite sex with women biking around in shorts.”
If the Hasidic are “having trouble obeying their religious law”, isn’t that on them?? How is this the fault/responsibility of the female bikers or the City of New York?
I weigh too much, but it’s not the fault of Dominos Pizza that I can’t show any self-control when it comes to eating.
All the while, the Hasidic communities men have no problem having their hands et al. all over prepubesent girls’ body parts located above the knees.
Good idea Elaine, don’t forget to tell them you’re a high priestess so they’ll listen to you! 🙂
I think those women who like to bike around Brooklyn wearing shorts should complain to Mayor Bloomberg–and tell him that those unshaven men dressed in strange-looking getups appear unclean and creepy–and that the women can’t bear to look upon them without feeling afraid.
My religion prohibits me from not looking at women in shorts. How does the city deal with that?
Byron
“the flood gates were opened when manger scenes were taken down”
This may not be your most inane statement, but it’s sure to be in the top five.
Mangers are no problem on private property. Got it!! You can have the manger scene you wish at your chrurch, office, front yard. You can have a scene totooed on your head if you wish. It’s only when such thing appear on PUBLIC PROPERTY where this is an issue. If that’s not enough freedom of religion for you, that’s just too bad. That’s the law, no more, no less.
C. Everette:
the Flying Spaghetti Monster was removed, now that is a travesty of justice. Why would anyone stoop so low.
People are way to serious about this stuff. They must not have much faith in their beliefs.
C. Everett:
that is a concern, but then they would be competing with the group that doesn’t want us to smoke, or eat high fat food, have firearms or home school, and wants us to wear seat belts and helmets and limit other choices.
I guess I am stuck in the middle of a family feud between moronic siblings who want to be the ones telling everyone else what is right and wrong.