Scientists (Again) Criticize Obama Administration Over Claims of Recovery of Gulf After BP Spill

Remember when Obama energy advisor Carol Browner assured the public that the oil from the BP spill has miraculously disappeared after criticism of Obama’s opening up the pristine areas of Eastern coast to exploration? Well, the Administration is still at odds with scientists who insist that the damage is devastating.

A leading scientist, Samantha Joye of University of Georgia has released video and slide evidence that the oil is not degrading despite continued assurances from the Obama Administration that the oil has largely dissipated. She insists that the Administration’s magic microbes” have “consumed maybe 10 percent of the total discharge, the rest of it we don’t know . . . there’s a lot of it out there.” Both the Administration and a BP scientist with a grant from BP insist that most of the oil is gone.

Yet, Joye and colleagues took 250 cores of the sea floor and travelled across 2,600 square miles. They also show pictures of totally dead areas as well as extremely high levels of methane — something they insist is being ignored by the effort to leave a rosy picture of the spill and “miracle” recovery.

Kenneth Feinberg, the government’s oil compensation fund czar, insisted that the Gulf of Mexico would almost fully recover by 2012. The scientists insist that this is simply wrong and a continuing underestimation of the damage caused by the spill.

Source: ABC

Jonathan Turley

25 thoughts on “Scientists (Again) Criticize Obama Administration Over Claims of Recovery of Gulf After BP Spill”

  1. LK/eniobob/pete,

    That was a most excellent triple play.

    From: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/robert-l-cavnar/new-scientific-study-bp-m_b_825705.html

    “Samantha Joye of the University of Georgia, has found that much of the oil from the Macondo well is still on the bottom of the Gulf and has killed much of the deepwater sea life in that area. Joye’s study consisted of manned deepsea submersible trips and over 250 seafloor cores over 2,600 square miles of the Gulf.

    Joye said of the report, ‘Magic microbes consumed maybe 10 percent of the total discharge, the rest of it we don’t know; there’s a lot of it out there.’ Disputing oil spill czar Ken Feinberg’s assertion that the Gulf will be back to normal by next year, Joye told the Associated Press, ‘I’ve been to the bottom. I’ve seen what it looks like with my own eyes. It’s not going to be fine by 2012. You see what the bottom looks like, you have a different opinion.’ Jane Lubchenco, director of NOAA who published the Happy Talk Report last August, though, is undeterred. On Saturday, she said, ‘…it’s not a contradiction to say that although most of the oil is gone, there still remains oil out there.’

    So. We have a new, exhaustive report by academics that says the sea floor around the Macondo well is dead with a lot of oil on the bottom, yet we still have formerly respected scientists like Lubchenco, who now work for the government, issuing confusing, if not conflicting statements claiming the contrary based on little, if any credible research. And, in the midst of this continuing crisis, we see little to no interest from the media about the tragedy and destruction. To my knowledge, this is the first rigorous study done of the sea floor that has been made public. It’s not surprising that it directly contradicts the claims made by the US government over the last six months that everything in the Gulf is okey-dokey.

    Of course, it’s not. Far from it.”

    The government lying upon behalf of a corporation in an attempt to limit their liability?

    Kilgore: Smell that? You smell that?
    Lance: What?
    Kilgore: [Fascism], son. Nothing else in the world smells like that.
    (kneels)
    Kilgore: I love the smell of [fascism] in the morning. You know, one time we had [an ocean] bombed, for 12 hours. When it was all over, I walked up. We didn’t find one of ’em, not one [fish]. The smell, you know that gasoline smell, the whole [sea]. Smelled like
    (sniffing, pondering)
    Kilgore: [BP’s and Halliburton’s negligence and crimes].

  2. LK:

    “IMO the President and his administration have sold their souls to the devil too.”

    Well if they haven’t it sure seems like they are taking bids.

  3. Another posting gone missing- s***. In any event Blah, blah, blah,… 91,000 claims filed with the BP compensation commission and only 1 settled so far, the law firm doing the work is getting $850,000.00 a month to do the investigation/disbursement. I’m thinking Mr. Feinberg has sold his soul to the devil.

    I’m also not happy with the Obama administration telling the Pentagon to buy more Gulf seafood and feed it to the troops. That just props up the Gulf economy and benefits the oil companies that are at fault. It makes it appear that the damage is not significant and the crisis in the fishing industry is over. That matters for compensation claims as well as any claims where duration and severity of the impact is a basis or mitigating factor. IMO the President and his administration have sold their souls to the devil too.

    No links this time.

  4. Woosty, I read about the Gulf Stream being ‘stuck’ and followed up some weeks later to see if I could find any info and didn’t find anything. I’d also like a follow-up on whatever was going on.

  5. Elaine,
    Great song! I remember it well. This is just one more example of the power of the corporation. The administration’s stand can be summarized with this phrase, “ignore the man behind the curtain”. I think we should all incorporate and then we will have more influence with our elected officials.

  6. I’ve read some speculation of the gulfstream being ‘dead’ or slowed and contributing to the weather changes recently….I just don’t see any sources for studies that I would trust….anyone else see anything?

  7. Elaine is the “B” supposed to be the new marking for officers to shoot twice….one for each hole? Or is it for the tags of the Tazer to cover the markings….

  8. And you may not believe this.But as a licensed limousine driver of over twenty five years Gene Odom and I have crossed paths many times along with Gary Rossington, formally of the Rossington Collins Band and Leon Wilkenson. Security was an impor tant part of bein in da limousine bidness. no what eye mean.

  9. It’s a shame that this great agrarian nation allows itself to be lied to and polluted by these oil criminals both foreign and domestic when over night if we were to lift the ridiculous ban on Industrial Hemp not marijuana but Hemp, we could employ and develop Flex Fuel Vehicles and cut our oil consumption by 50% in a few year easily..

    Industrial Hemp would give us Cellulose Ethanol and also Bio-diesel from it’s numerous seeds as well, it Renews every 4 months and you can pack an acre with it as there is no need to grow it in rows.. This could then be refined or distilled regionally thus enhancing American National Security were as our refineries are now all packed into 3 dense regions and easy targets for any aggressor or even terror attack if the latter hasn’t already occurred and been kept from our nation’s attention as I suspect…

    Brazil using Sugar Cane is already at 45% Renewable Energy..!

    What are we chopped liver..?

    Why does Obama insist upon risking American National Security and undermining our self reliance for the sake of these corrupt industries as well as the ghouls and swine Speculators such as Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley who manipulate the Oil Futures Market criminally as well now as the food Futures Market destabilizing already dangerous regions as we are seeing on the news daily, with no clear or certain outcome in America’s or the world’s best interest, due to his ignorant suspect refusal to cooperate with Sarkozy and Merkel who called for and all but begged for International Regulations on the Commodities and Futures Market so early in his ever more disappointing administration and presidency..?

    Electric Cars run primarily on burning Coal remember that..!

    See Hemp4Fuel.com…

    Why Hemp? http://www.hemp4fuel.com/page.php?2

    Or go to the Why Hemp? section there..

    Do we really want to create a mutant algae that could mutate again and pollute the oceans of the world or become a new proprietal (sp?) commodity of these corrupt indecent industrialist..!

    Why not create Real Green Jobs and Set the American people free from these ever more dangerous even insane efforts to drill into mother earth risking another poorly managed calamity as we witnessed in the Gulf of Mexico..?

    Grow Here, Grow Now..!

  10. Not that I know…..

    [youtube=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p6q9nBusrq8&w=480&h=390]

  11. White man have been sneaking up on us for years. I had a wife and two children but they all died on the trail of tears. Now all I have is a piece of this hard rock candy but it’s not for eatin, it’s only for looking through.

  12. It may have been caught up by the GULF-STREAM and so is transported to the European coasts where it, due to shallower waters ,will re-surface ,evaporate and come down as rain-or snow.

Comments are closed.