New York City Erases Bike Lanes to Appease Hasidic Men Who Object to Seeing Women in Bike Shorts

There is an interesting controversy in Brooklyn after the city yielded to the Hasidic community in sandblasting off bike lanes on roads. Hasidic leaders complained that they are having trouble obeying their religious law forbidding them from staring at members of the opposite sex with women biking around in shorts. Bicycle advocates have been trying to repaint the lanes.

The Hasidic community has long viewed this enclave as their special area, even though other families and artists have moved in recently. That has caused trouble with the Shomrim Patrol, a Hasidic neighborhood watch group. The Shomrim recently apprehended two cycling advocates who were repainting the lane and called the police. No charges were filed but the bikers were prevented from repainting the lane.

I find it incredible that the city would yield to such demands by a religious group to erase bike lanes. A Department of Transportation spokesman said: “We will continue to work with any community on ways we can make changes to our streets without compromising safety.” However, this is a religious-based objection to women who are not covered. Yet, reports indicate that Mayor Bloomberg wanted to appease the Hasidic community before his recently close election.

Hasidic leaders say that the cyclists endanger families and children. However, this is not the view of the city in creating these lanes and they are found in every major city. The real objection appears to be their lifestyle and the rigid religious beliefs of this sect. It is a clearly improper decision that uses city resources to enforce values of a single religious group.

For the full story, click here

317 thoughts on “New York City Erases Bike Lanes to Appease Hasidic Men Who Object to Seeing Women in Bike Shorts”

  1. AY to Elaine: “Is your Bow Tie really a camera?”
    —

    AY, are you accusing our ‘old friend’ Elaine of being a spy for the vast, underground, free-thinking, free-versing Porty conspiracy? Shame on you.

    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .

    Clever, veeeeeeery clever AY; now I’m going to have that Simon and Garfunkle song echoing around my head the rest of the night 🙂

  2. I like your frankness, Ms. EM, which is most often spot on in a respectful, yet satirical way.

  3. FF LEO–

    They KNOW what they’re missing. They just can’t bear to be reminded of it when looking at those short-wearing femmes fatales biking down the streets of Brooklyn.

  4. “Or, has this particular sect been gaining political power in the greater hassidic community of late?”

    LK,
    I was rushing out so didn’t get to write much. The Satmar haven’t been gaining in political power, as far as I know, because they are far out of the mainstream and not very respectful of other Jews. For instance they hate the Lubavitcher Hassidic Sect which is located about four miles away in Crown Heights, Brooklyn. Both these groups have political power because they can deliver votes with close to unanimity. In politics that translates into power even if your numbers aren’t great.

    To me both of these groups are more cults than anything else. They have their own schools and while their education is broader than in some of the Muslim extremist schools, their insularity is similar. Marriages within the community are generally arranged and discipline and obedience to the powers that be are expected. The outside world to the Satmar’s is considered alien, but they have more enmity for other Jews who they see as not following “the Satmar” letter of the law, than they do for non-Jews.

    The Lubavitcher Hassidim are much more part of the world and they are welcoming to all Jews. I worked as a NYC liaison with them for a time in the early 70’s and while I wasn’t impressed and felt them to be “cultlike,” though all in all they weren’t bad people and could be talked to.

    Anyone who thinks of the Jewish Community as “homogenous” in practice and belief doesn’t know much of Jews. Jews are as I’ve said before a contentious lot and broadly opinionated. The Hassidic tradition was begun by the Jewish Philosopher the “Baal Shem Tov” (“Master of the Good Name”), which you can Google or Wiki if interested. He developed a philosophic tradition in the 18th Century. The most important aspect of his philosophy was his belief that God can be reached through ecstacy, rather than ascetically. After him there was a splitting off of followers, each with their own interpretations. There developed a number of sects which basically remained somewhat true to the belief but followed different leaders. From being a radical interpretation of Judaism as the years passed they became more and more traditional and stuck in a time warp. Think of the Amish, but able to use modern technology.

    To be honest for me this is such a broad subject and so subjective to Jews, that it’s difficult for me to express myself tersely and to go on and on would not only be boring to non-Jews, but I lack the ability to correctly do the job. Suffice it to say that I think that NYC government is stupid to give into these demands, but then I like Bloomberg only to the extent that he is not Rudy G. and probably not as corrupt, which isn’t saying much.

  5. FF LEO,

    I do believe Mike S. did indeed tell us of when he worked in NYC and the political clout they have as they vote in blocks.

  6. Elaine M.,

    Are you per chance an Orwellian at heart? Is your Bow Tie really a camera? How did you know that I have such good looking gam’s? I do by the way, winking or because I am male I oink?

  7. Hey Mike Spindell, you should infiltrate them Hasidic Jews to tell them about your hippie days and what they have been a’missin’!

  8. One should be able to ride anywhere in the US they want to – no limits. IF these loons object – move back to Israel and STFU !!!

  9. AY–

    I’d advise against your bicycling through that section of Brooklyn while wearing those dandy green shorts of yours. You have mighty good-looking gams–if I do say so myself!

  10. This offends my daily practices. I sincerely hope that one plucks its eyes out if they are so justly offended.

  11. Buck-
    That’s exactly right- these guys are cheating! They’ve painted the streets so that the creatures God created from Adam’s rib (lovely women, thighs, butts, asses, mmm), to distinguish the holy from the hellbound, are out of sight! Just how the hell is God supposed to know then who deserves to go to heaven?

  12. If these Hasidic Jews can’t keep their woodies under control, then perhaps,
    they should stop looking at womens crotches, butts and all that other woody raising skin, hidden under bike shorts. This is nothing more than insecure men showing their hatred for women and trying to disguise it and justify it, using their religious beliefs, to condone it.

    Sounds like Sheria to me.

  13. MikeS, Thanks also for the info. It seemed strange that this would come up now unless there is a back-story of conflict that has not been covered by the media. I was thinking that women in shorts have probably been bicycling through their community for years but until the mayor needed their vote it wasn’t an issue to be taken seriously. Or, has this particular sect been gaining political power in the greater hassidic community of late? I’ll do a Google but you seem to have info that might be more up to date and/or personal.

  14. The hassidic sect in Williamsburgh, Brooklyn is known as the Satmar. They are in fact a cult within Judaisms and not an important one at that. I as a Jew would not be welcome to their prayer services, which is a violation of Jewish Law, but being a cult the Satmar don’t see the inconsistency. Incidentally, before someone brings it up they are opposed to Israel’s existence. They wield political power in their area because like any cult they vote as a block. I personally despise all they believe in as a Jew and their views are outside of normative Judaism.

  15. “Hasidic leaders complained that they are having trouble obeying their religious law forbidding them from staring at members of the opposite sex with women biking around in shorts.”

    As others have said, THEN STOP STARING.

    If a Hasidic man is having trouble obeying his religious law by turning his eyes away, it speaks to him and his own unholiness.

    Getting rid of female bicyclists simply makes entrance into heaven more *convenient* for those who don’t deserve to go there. It makes things more *inconvenient* for God, who then must quickly pick out who the hellbound Hasidics are when they make their occasional ventures down into Manhattan and stare at the hot girls on display down there.

  16. Women (and men) in shorts, in large organized numbers (Where is NOW?) should bicycle through the community across the width of the street on a reoccurring basis until the lanes are restored. If ever there was an apt use for the label ‘CIVIL rights’ issue/protest…

  17. And just how does this differ from attempting to impose Sharia Law?

    As a result of this I know that I now won’t be buying that expensive Christmas-gift camera from a Hasidic-owned camera store in New York. I’ll spend a few dollars more to buy one from someone who doesn’t disapprove of my bike shorts.

Comments are closed.