
There is an interesting controversy in Brooklyn after the city yielded to the Hasidic community in sandblasting off bike lanes on roads. Hasidic leaders complained that they are having trouble obeying their religious law forbidding them from staring at members of the opposite sex with women biking around in shorts. Bicycle advocates have been trying to repaint the lanes.
The Hasidic community has long viewed this enclave as their special area, even though other families and artists have moved in recently. That has caused trouble with the Shomrim Patrol, a Hasidic neighborhood watch group. The Shomrim recently apprehended two cycling advocates who were repainting the lane and called the police. No charges were filed but the bikers were prevented from repainting the lane.
I find it incredible that the city would yield to such demands by a religious group to erase bike lanes. A Department of Transportation spokesman said: “We will continue to work with any community on ways we can make changes to our streets without compromising safety.” However, this is a religious-based objection to women who are not covered. Yet, reports indicate that Mayor Bloomberg wanted to appease the Hasidic community before his recently close election.
Hasidic leaders say that the cyclists endanger families and children. However, this is not the view of the city in creating these lanes and they are found in every major city. The real objection appears to be their lifestyle and the rigid religious beliefs of this sect. It is a clearly improper decision that uses city resources to enforce values of a single religious group.
For the full story, click here
Theocrats — YET AGAIN — who refuse to grasp the simple concept that America is a SECULAR nation.
One of the reasons why we have a Constitution is to keep religious fanatics from pushing the rest of us around.
If these were Muslims, all Holy Hell would be raised. Where I live, the biggest pests are politicized Southern Baptists and Evangelicals.
Religious fundamentalists of EVERY faith need to learn to tolerate the MAJORITY. After all, WE tolerate them.
Elaine M. 1, December 11, 2009 at 4:50 pm
“AY– Did Orwell wear bow ties? …!”
——–
Simon and Garfunkel song “America” from the Album “Bookends” which had “America”, (started listing the great/classic songs from this album but there were too many- all of them) as well as ” Old Friends”, their most haunting song.
Lyric fragment from “America”:
Laughing on the bus, Playing games with the faces
She said the man in the
gabardine suit was a spy
I said “Be careful, his bow tie is really a camera”
Probably a redundant posting for a poetess such as yourself.
Gyges:
“That’s why it’s not illegal for me to tell my son Mickey Mouse is real”
But it would be immoral.
Lottakatz–
You may also want to check out I Spy Guys’ Thighs!
Elaine M. 1, December 11, 2009 at 4:50 pm
“AY– Did Orwell wear bow ties? I don’t need a camera–Google Gams is watching you!”
——–
Google Gams? I did not know, PLEASE post the link for me. PLEASE. Some of us ladies are ‘leg-men’ too. I actually though that the bicycle and spandex were invented to provide us Ladies That Stare At Men’s Gams (coming soon to a theatre near you) didn’t have to use our x-ray vision superpower. 🙂
Removing bike lanes because some of the riders are dressed in something less than Sharia law is like closing all restaurants because they aren’t Halal or Kosher.
One of the founding principles of our country is freedom of religion, which this issue is based around. When it comes to enforcing rules of decency the government has established rules for this that have been argued in the courts for many years and what is accepted by the general public and the courts can’t be used as an argument for punishing others.
In this case a few people who are not meeting the religious standard of one group are the excuse for denying the rights of the greater public. This is what leads to women wearing Burkas.
It’s ironic that the extremists in religion try to regulate others for their own weaknesses. “We can’t handle seeing attractive people in tight fitting clothes so we should ban them and anyone like them from being around us!”
I wonder how many laws there are in Israel against wearing tight clothes.
The argument that bike lanes should be removed to prevent people from wearing tight fitting clothes is fallacious and a poor excuse for the real issue. What is really the issue here is that people don’t want to share the road with bicycles. Have the Hasid’s been stopping people not on a bicycle for wearing tightly fitting clothes? Is this a major issue with other types of transportation such as pedestrians or the subway or buses or cars?
Has there been a rash of attacks by bicyclists on people in Brooklyn or anywhere else? I don’t think so. If the Shomrim Patrol doesn’t like the way other people in their neighborhood are dressing then they should file formal complaints and ask for respect from others and educate others as to what offends them, not by vandalizing city property. Their laws are theirs and not something they should force on others. This is why our founding fathers emphasized freedom of religion, so that people wouldn’t be burned at the stake for these type of issues.
AY–
Did Orwell wear bow ties? I don’t need a camera–Google Gams is watching you!
Gyges:
The idea protecting freedom, property, and person is part of a moral code.
An affair could be illegal if the people wished. I’m reporting you to Santa about the Mickey thingy.
Not surprising that the most misogynistic religion in the city full of sexual repressed men, who are some of the biggest client of the hookers in town, would push for such a loony thing.
Ah, just in time for Christmas, another wonderful story about the Jews. (-;
This is ridiculous, of course, and until the local Jewry seal off the neighborhood and make it entirely private, they really ought to respect others. But they don’t. I say this as a Jew who knows the orthodoxy all too well, and the way they look at the world is simple: “If it matters to me, you must do it; if it matters to YOU, who cares.”
What this particular overstepping points out more than anything is that the local pols are completely beholden to the local Jewish community.
I’ve spoken to my Jewish brethren about this many times: Isolation breeds contempt. With this bike lane issue, you may think you’ve won, but you just made a whole lot of people think you are absurd, overbearing, and totally unfair. The sad thing is, I know you don’t care a whit about what others think.
And that is the problem.
Tootie,
Personally, I think those bicyclists are just asking to get hit by a car, just look at the way they dress.
In all seriousness: Laws in the US do not exist to enforce moral codes, they exist to protect freedom, property, health, etc. That’s why it’s not illegal for me to have an affair. That’s why it’s not illegal for me to tell my son Mickey Mouse is real. Heck I’m not even legally required to obey the golden rule.
Maverrick:
You quoted from my post but I never said anything about child molesters. And, yes, you have a right to walk around nekked. In your own house, for example.
Buddha Isn’t Laughing:
So, women have a religious code that sanctifies sexual slavery? And their…um….ancient leader had sex with a 9 year old when she was in her mid fifties, and women today still love her anyway?
I’m with ya bro, keep the women out.
maverratick,
I never thought of people riding by children on bikes as child molesters but as you point it out, it makes perfect sense.
“I don’t see how the lines make any difference except as protest since bikers don’t need the lines to pass by. Unless bikers cannot ride on the roads without bike lanes.”
I acknowledge your point that bicyclists are molesting small children by wearing their necessary biking attire as they pass by them at 14 mph, although I respectfully disagree.
But have you ever been put in a position where you have to ride a bike as your only transportation, as I have been? Have you ever even ridden a bike, you nitwit? The bike lane isn’t there for “protest”, it’s needed to reduce accidents. A road without a bike lane has people driving their cars over where it would be. I almost got killed on a road with no bike lane one morning on the way to work, by a guy who was almost hitting the left rear mirrors on parked cars along the street. And riding on the sidewalk is illegal.
I have a perfect right to walk around half-naked, BTW.
You have a problem.
With one piece bathing suits.
(Insert Lewis Black double-take here.)
Well Tootles, I think you’ve hit upon solution with your post about Muslims.
Tootie 1, December 11, 2009 at 6:42 am
We should not permit Muslims to immigrate to this country.
Ever.
http://jonathanturley.org/2008/04/02/leading-english-muslim-endorses-the-killing-and-raping-of-non-muslims/#comment-97020
We should just not allow women to immigrate here either.
And to keep all us sinners from looking at them? We should abort every female foetus too. Just to be safe. You don’t want them to grow up and have breasts! Never can tell when Tootles isn’t going to be able to control himself! You randy rascal you!
Oh, I’m sorry! Is the abortion thing going too far for you and your anthropomorphic sky god? Take it up with Him.
He’s the one who intelligently designed you to be a busybody undersexed overstimulated prude who takes out their feelings of sexual inadequacy by attacking women’s rights. He did give you eyelids. Well. I hope he did, but hey, there is no lifeguard in the gene pool.
You need a leash. Your dogma is going to get run over by some karma if you keep letting it play out in the street without any coherent supervision like that.
Did I mention the Muslim post was a fine display of bigotry?
Good show.
This is assuming your goal was to shred any credibility you might have had and your preference for propagation of the species involves a petrie dish.
I, like the Hasidics, am offended by woman (or men) appearing semi-naked in public. I don’t see how the lines make any difference except as protest since bikers don’t need the lines to pass by. Unless bikers cannot ride on the roads without bike lanes.
Isn’t the clarion call of the Libertarian that everyone should be free to do what they want up to the point that it infringes on the rights of others, then at that juncture, the law can step in?
What right does any of us have to walk around in public semi-naked (or suggestively)? I don’t think any. I’m sure a case against it might be made because we already draw a line on this issue. The question at hand in the larger issue is where to draw the line and who wins in the debate about drawing it.
I think a case is already made in law and medicine that exposing children is adult nudity is not a good idea. What case ought we then make about exposing them to near nudity or semi-nudity? I think this is something we should discuss in our communities because children are affected by this public conduct. I once attended a play for children with my child at a local theater. It was really a BAD play, but there was one annoying feature of some of the dancers: they appeared to be naked. Every time they took they stage, the children all around us kept say “naked”, “no clothes on”, etc., etc. It thoroughly distracted the children and me. I actually thought they were naked too.
This was not a good idea to even dress people to look nude.
Most beaches in America do not allow public nudity. Some do not even allow thong-style bathing suits. There is a reason for this and the reason is sensible, even scientific.
The reasons are even practical. If the streets are loaded with half-naked individuals and one wants to avoid looking at them, passage becomes next to impossible if not dangerous as one averts the eyes continually. Who can walk around normally if he has to not look where he is going? But what unusual danger or imposition does a person experience being adequately covered?
When people do not respect others in public, these problems arise. Young boys (I’m talking about little ones under the age of 10) are continually exposed to adult womens’ bodies in public, and men may joke about this (if they do I consider them perverts) but I consider this exposure a form of sexual harassment. I consider it barbaric and depraved.
I find it to be a glaring moral error on the part of liberally minded women who claim to be interested in justice (usually found hugging trees, kittens, and bottled water) to not give a hoot about little children exposed to semi-nude adult bodies in public. These women are virtually silent about this form of assault on children.
Boys are surely not in the position of having the maturity to fend off these images or understand the sexual nature of them, or how their brains are wired regarding the female human body.
And I think that a case can be made that civilizations which allowed public nudity and semi-nudity were corrupt civilizations–even advanced ones. The advanced Greeks and Romans both had much public nudity and it went hand in hand with slavery.
When you look at the most esteemed among us, judges, Kings and Queens, graduating students, brides: the more fabric, the more honor. When you look at how wicked people treat the oppressed or the captive, forcing them to strip naked is a favorite way to humiliate them. Think Abu Grhaib.
Leftists will continually mock Christians (and apparently devout Jews) who complain about nudity on TV and tell them to just turn the TV off. Fair enough. But once that pours out into the streets it is not fair to then demand people walk around half-blind to avoid it.
I stopped watching the Olympics because the female outfits got sluttier and sluttier over the years. How is it that men can ice skate adequately or even perhaps better, fully clothed, but the women are forced (there are rules for this) to expose their crotches and butts to the public? The same goes for gymnasts.
There is something perverse about this.
And yes, I think the swim suits they wear in the Olympics are obscene. Do I think it is worth it for a culture to promote frivolous public activities if it requires semi-nude dressing?
No.
Mike S.
Thank you for taking the time to write such an interesting and informative piece.
=================================================================
Many politicians are easily bullied by “block” voters as is obviously the case with Bloomberg. All the negative publicity that he and the community who successfully bullied him receive is just reward for their collective lack of character.
I trust the citizens of New York to stand fast in their resolve to get their bike lanes back and to have a great deal of fun in doing so.
I busy myself during the day only to pop on over to Prof Turley’s website and be DEPRESSED at the state of enlightenment in the world!
Seriously, are we going backwards???????
Mike S, Thanks for the information. I am always surprised at what interesting and generally innovative ideas (for the time) give rise to traditions and beliefs. It’s a constant challenge to keep reminding myself that when associating or attributing motives to groups it has to be a pointillist approach, you just can’t use a paint roller.
I had as best friends a fundamentalist Christian and a Jehovah’s Witness’s. We were all in our early twenties and they weren’t adhering to their religions but they did talk about them a lot. I was an alien, by that time I had left the RRC and was atheist so we had some interesting and weird conversations. I realized Christians came in many flavors real fast.
“God can be reached through ecstacy”. In the 18th Century. Wow. I will Google Baal Shem Tov. I seem to remember that being a popular endeavor in the 60’s-early 70’s in some circles and as a premise for a new “Martian” religion in an in a Heinlein book. It’s an idea with staying power, I’ll give it that.