
There is an interesting controversy in Brooklyn after the city yielded to the Hasidic community in sandblasting off bike lanes on roads. Hasidic leaders complained that they are having trouble obeying their religious law forbidding them from staring at members of the opposite sex with women biking around in shorts. Bicycle advocates have been trying to repaint the lanes.
The Hasidic community has long viewed this enclave as their special area, even though other families and artists have moved in recently. That has caused trouble with the Shomrim Patrol, a Hasidic neighborhood watch group. The Shomrim recently apprehended two cycling advocates who were repainting the lane and called the police. No charges were filed but the bikers were prevented from repainting the lane.
I find it incredible that the city would yield to such demands by a religious group to erase bike lanes. A Department of Transportation spokesman said: “We will continue to work with any community on ways we can make changes to our streets without compromising safety.” However, this is a religious-based objection to women who are not covered. Yet, reports indicate that Mayor Bloomberg wanted to appease the Hasidic community before his recently close election.
Hasidic leaders say that the cyclists endanger families and children. However, this is not the view of the city in creating these lanes and they are found in every major city. The real objection appears to be their lifestyle and the rigid religious beliefs of this sect. It is a clearly improper decision that uses city resources to enforce values of a single religious group.
For the full story, click here
Most of the other bike lanes around the City should also be removed. Bikes are great for the summer and if you are young, but if you are older or in the winter time, bikes are not good for NYC. The bike lanes have contributed to far greater pollution, since cars now drive slower, and the traffic jams that bike lanes cause, causes greater noise from road-raged drivers honking. The bike lane idea sounds good, but it does not work here.
So what do the Hasidic men do when women, especially tourists during the summer months enter their shops in Manhattan’s Diamond District? Hmm…
I think the cast of Hair or East Side Story should walk though the neighborhood….
I agree with San Diego. Women should walk or jog through the neighborhood in their bikinis. It will make the biking shorts look like burqas in comparison.
I did not read any place that anyone is forcing these old geezers to stare at women’s behinds.
People and their religion are the ultimate insanity. Get rid of the gods, demons, angels, etc. and the world would probably be living in peace.
Elaine,
Orwell would have hated that his name has become a political buzzword. Also, every time you call refer to something as being like “Big Brother” Orwell punches a cat. Orwell’s first rule for saving the English Language:
“Never use a metaphor, simile or other figure of speech which you are used to seeing in print.”
http://gutenberg.net.au/ebooks03/0300011h.html#part42
Have female bike lane advocates start walking through the area in bikinis. This will have to wait for warmer weather, but tell the Hasidic community that they can have it one of two ways: the folks will keep walking through their community with little to nothing on, or they can let the bike lanes go through.
If they start calling for people to be arrested for walking on the sidewalks, it will only get worse for them.
In my state Missouri if your a bicyclist and there aren’t bike lanes then your order of proceeding is as any other vehicle on the road, you own the traffic lane just like a car or truck does and have to act like any other vehicle on the road- stop at all stop signs, obey the speed limit, etc. Bike lanes are also a way to let municipalities off the hook regarding actual application of the law regarding bicyclists.
Actually I feel less agitated now and regret the vitriol in my previous post. However I would still like to summarize the point- for the THOUSANDTH time now- that the bike lane is there for motorists, not bicyclists, so that the bicyclists are not confined to riding down half the width of the road that they would otherwise. And it’s pretty obvious here that the motive of this 50% squeeze is to discourage bicycling on the road entirely.
maverratick, You’re right and it removes ambiguity from the law, bike riders should stay in the bike lanes and cars should stay in the car lanes. Liability is easier to sort out. In most states that have an order of proceeding on their streets bicyclists come in right after pedestrians. With that and bike lanes liability assessments become routine.
> Removing the bike lane will do nothing. you don’t need a specific painted lines to bike a long the road side. It’s only there as a guide.
For the NINE-HUNDREDTH and NINETY-NINTH time in this thread:
It’s a guide to CAR DRIVERS. Not BICYCLISTS. BICYCLISTS already KNOW they have to hug the line of parallel parked cars. CAR DRIVERS assume- reasonably- that they should ride directly down the midline between the parked cars and the lane divider if they don’t see the bike lane, allowing BICYCLISTS half the space to avoid an ACCIDENT. It’s there for SAFETY.
Do REAL lifetimes need to be ended so that these Hasids don’t spend their ETERNAL lifetimes in their imagined LA-LA LAND by giving in to their own temptations to look at TITTIES? Even their GOD-DAMNED YAHWEH should be smart enough to see the greed and selfishness in such acts, unless they think he has an IQ of NINETY.
Removing the bike lane will do nothing. you don’t need a specific painted lines to bike a long the road side. It’s only there as a guide.
Also screw these people. Since when does the government take a back seat to religion?
The whole purpose of
“forbidding them from staring at members of the opposite sex”
is to resist temptations!!
if bike lane is removed, that is an easier life to live. These guys are cheating them selves.
Good to know that NYC hasn’t heard of Lemmon. How the Hasidic community can bootstrap “health and safety” to their own stultifying and rigid doctrine, to compel the City to remove the lanes is absolutely beyond me.
Elaine M.,
Don’t be silly, only be aware of 1) a man in a bus; 2) sitting in a gabardine suit; 3) wearing a bow tie. If you worry about all of the people wearing bow ties that will just make you nuts.
lottakatz–
Those lyrics are new to me.
Orwell got it right though, didn’t he? I’m glad Eric Blair took the nom de plume of George Orwell. Claiming things/events are Blairian just doesn’t pack the same punch as saying they’re Orwellian.
BTW, I’m going to be wary of men wearing bow ties from now on.
Hey! While you fairy tale loving folks are busy fighting over whether it’s Santa or the tooth fairy or the boogie man who worries about who sticks his or her genitals where, can the rest of us have out our planet back???
Drop these fucks into an oven
Mad Tom: December 11, 2009 at 6:57 pm
Nonreligious fundamentalists also need to learn to tolerate religious fundamentalists and understand that whatever a local government is willing to grant any community within their jurisdiction indeed REFLECTS the democratic process.
I’m sure that nonreligious fundies are just as annoyed with the gains religious fundies make in the democratic process as the religious fundies are annoyed with the gains the nonreligious fundies make. The goal is to let each group make the best arguments and win whatever they can.
The issue with the Muslims goes to why it is important not to let Muslims immigrate to the country since their community is one that advocates Sharia–a thoroughly undemocratic process which is aimed at destroying representative government, unlike Christianity. I think it is silly to invite people here who would destroy our form of government.
For those Muslims who are already here, the issue becomes one freedom of speech. We non Muslims must remain free to expound about the vile details of Islam which are as odious as the details of any immoral code of conduct are. Among these details are sexual slavery, and torture (chopping off the body parts of criminals).
If we keep labeling critics of Islam bigots, haters, and racists (Islam is not a racial group) we will not be able to demonstrate to our fellow citizens that Islam is to be shunned. I’m not saying you labeled anyone.
It could be a mistake that you read the criticism of Muslims, but not the criticism of southern baptists, as a double standard. When actually the criticism of Islam is often a criticism of the very substance of the faith (Jihad, polygamy, and the such). I’d like to invite you to make this critical distinction.
Widespread law in America that REFLECTS Biblical ethics are a precedent in our local governments, as the founders allowed (belonging to the states). This is how the views of the people bubble upwards into our laws. Those nonreligious folks who come along centuries later tend to think that the remnant of that ethical system is some sort of violation of the democratic process, when in fact it is the natural process of it. Granted, there are many things which are unconstitutional and our system has tools to deal with that.
Let the best arguments (which conform to the Constitution) win!
:o)
Bryon and Gyges,
Are you telling me that Mickey Mouse is not real? Hey, I suspected that the Easter Bunny is not real, can you tell me if he is? What about Santa? I have heard that we have a Satan in a Santa is that true too? I believe in the good jojo Santa. Don’t you?
Personally I find sausage curls on grown men offensive.