There is good news and bad news in the latest Gallup poll on atheist politicians. For the second time in less than a year, Gallup reports that a majority of Americans would vote for an atheist for president. However, the 54 percent who would vote for an atheist are offset by 43 percent who said they would not vote for an atheist even if she or he was well-qualified.
The 54 percent polled is a remarkable advance since in 1958 only 18 percent said they could vote for a nonbeliever. Not unexpectedly, the highest opposition became from Republicans (58 percent).
For those who argue for faith-based politics, the poll is likely to fuel their warnings of a secular conspiracy. However, for those of us who believe in a high wall of separation, the poll shows that people could be finally moving away from the use of faith by politicians to secure votes and to obscure their record. This is not a trend to reject faith. This remains a deeply faithful country. Rather, it is a slow recognition that civic leadership does not depend on leaders necessarily believing in your God or any God. Notably, there are also many secular leaders who are deeply religious but believe in strong separation of church and state principles. We have many leaders of faith who are deserving of support and this poll suggests that more Americans are willing to consider leaders who are agnostic or atheist rather than impose a religious litmus test. Yet, with 43 percent still saying that they will vote on the basis of religious prejudice, there remains work to be done.
Source: USA Today
35 thoughts on “Gallup: 54 Percent Of Americans Would Vote For Atheist For President”
I will also point out that an openly atheist politician would be more trustworthy than one claiming to be a Christian. Logic would tell you that, if you could process it. A person trying to deceive the religious into voting for them would not hesitate to call themselves a Christian, there is no way you can test it, and no actual penalty for lying about it.
A politician that openly admitted to being an atheist is putting the truth above their selfish interest. They could keep their atheism a secret, they would have nothing to gain by alienating the true believers, which outnumber atheists at least ten to one. Which would only mean they are brave enough to suffer that loss in the interest of telling the truth, and not gaining votes under false pretense.
Hubert: I am an atheist, I have a foundation. It is just not based upon a fantasy or on received wisdom that is full of unproven (and unprovable) ideas. The religious foundation is the one of shifting sand; it rejects the very idea that life and consciousness are precious (by claiming they do not really ever end, and cannot really be harmed, that nobody is really ever gone).
It is religion that claims the purpose of life is just the pointless slavery of pleasing a superior being, with “praise” or “worship” so you can buddy around with the big guy and spend eternity as a begging child.
It is religion that tries to remove all choice in life with the blackmail threat of eternal, horrific pain if you fail to “choose” as you are told you must. The choice “Obey Me or I’ll burn you alive” is not a “choice,” it is coercion under the threat of endless torture.
Most atheists have a moral compass; we understand better than you that life and consciousness are precious, because we do not believe there is anything AFTER life.
We are more forgiving than you, because we do not imagine people are breaking the arbitrary and capricious laws of an imaginary being, by being gay, or getting an abortion, or getting divorced, or having sex out of wedlock, or working on a Sunday.
We are more generous than you, because we do not make the mistake of suspecting bad luck, misfortune, poverty or disease are some kind of punishment from God.
We are less awe-struck than you, because we do not assume good fortune, wealth, riches or fame are the gifts of God upon those he favors, and we are more resilient than you, because we do not assume we are being cosmically punished if our time on Earth gets difficult.
And we are more responsible than you, because we do not assume there exists some master plan, or that we will be supernaturally protected or guided. We take responsibility for our own lives, and our own choices, and our own safety, and the safety of our children and family.
I do not have to believe in God to believe that my fellow humans should be treated fairly, and equally, and that we are all in this together. That is the true North for my moral compass.
Well, I would say you can’t get any worse than what we have now. But yes, an atheist president would be worse. Why would you want someone that has no foundation. If you are going to build a house, for example, you don’t build one on shifting sand, you want some sort of solid foundation. Atheism is devoid of logic and common sense, and has no moral compass, and no foundation. That would be a horrible mistake to have someone in the driver’s seat who is an atheist.
Nick: Well, I am pretty much the litigious one, not my family. I have been litigious on their behalf. I don’t trust our justice system to deliver justice without a lawyer or two demanding it. That’s just the reality of the world we live in, and I am a pragmatic person.
Its Dog The Father. God ain’t got no offspring.
So..an anecdotal experiences w/ a few barristers means “Lawyers Rock?” Although it certainly does sound like a litigious family, it is hardly dispositive.
bettykath: Lawyers or not, members of Congress are elected officials that cannot be dismissed for failing to do a job, because they have no defined duties at all; they do not have to show up, vote, report, or do anything else.
Once elected, they can spend their entire term campaigning to be re-elected, and many do. That isn’t a lawyering job, that is a politician’s job. Their failure is not a result of them being lawyers, their failures are a result of them being elected politicians, and perhaps by virtue of being presented with, um, irresistible opportunities as a result of their power.
Of the half dozen lawyers in my life, all are honorable people that have successfully protected me, kept members of my family out of prison, put criminals threatening my family in prison, recovered money stolen from me and negotiated contracts and insurance settlements on my behalf to my great benefit (and sometimes unexpected benefit).
I have been a client several times, and although the cases are by their nature fraught, I have not had a bad outcome yet. Lawyers rock.
BTW, most members of Congress are male, most are over fifty, most are white, none of those commonalities are the cause of their failures either.
Attorneys depend on conflict to succeed. If there is no conflict, they are quite adept @ creating it. That is maybe what they are best at doing. bettykath just astutely pointed out that basic fact.
Does the people who were polled know that any polietricker in a high a office is a freemason or eastern star and and their only higher power is satan itself?
Tony C. I guess we’ve had different experiences with lawyers. Most members of Congress are lawyers and you can see what they’ve brought us.
Nick: If you want to fight for the world, you are better off using those trained for the battle. I am not a lawyer, but I have had some very positive (even life changing) experiences employing them. Lawyers can be victorious in battles my pizza delivery guy would not even comprehend. And those are the battles to be fought.
* the watch tower has many jewalls in the 666-ties brink of disaster bi the HUE of Phu Ket with chet and david through history . s ‘ watch !
… with Say-tan is like living in an ocotillo.
have you ever scene a dog pull teddy bear’ss from it’s feat, or poor-key pine quills from a whiz-stol stop. they always go back to tri to kill the little p i gee. the whistle stops comeing the loco.motive is a petty coat junk-shun.Canonbal expapie-ruse. copy rite by Jonknee cash.and chinook saulmon carreed their seed U P stream.
nick spinelli 1, April 23, 2013 at 12:32 pm
My counterintuitive thought would be to have plumbers, electricians, school crossing guards, cab drivers, hell..pizza delivery guys, save our world before attorneys.
There you go trying to cull favor again Nick. 😉
it looks like everybody sat on their watch and JESUS CHRIST,!, the GOD GODAMNED motors still running in the display cases… *
“uhm-bill-I-call, a sir-I- eu s tar…
…sum-malli-ya , morerocko too.ore-land oh in pie-rates.care-rib bein atom an eve and a snake in dizz an knee world.waltz in a limbo pair a dice, with a bad back.both built a world from the ground up swamp…
… a-gnat-to-me…, the wholey land
x- sperie-ants built on his expert-ice.
one is for please-sure, the other for pay’ne. pay-n the gate-ores is wrong. mount-tease pie-thons are are all over and devour sm. souls, knot knowing when they receive them…
… ‘ says that you are bourne in sin and you can go to hell for that in a rapeture…
… AND YOUR MOTHER TWO!
sew how can the Miss conception be pure or Mary. all thies P on GOD weighting with a cutting tongue…
…all blessed children come from GOD…
…with D’N’An who would be late…
…their C U P runneth over with blessings…
…in the end times…
…start askeying QUEstions.
…would they just simply stare at the word of GOD,
…IF jesus blood ran down and atoms skull came to life
Blouise, Good additions to the list.
Comments are closed.